Software
Houzz Logo Print
mosswitch

Solution to the deer problem?

15 years ago

The deer chewed off tops of several hostas last year, and when I planted some newer, expensive hostas this year I wracked my brain trying to think of something to protect them. Up-side-down wire baskets work for a while, until they get too big, but that isn't a long-term solution.

I had quite a bit of bamboo left from another project, so I cut sharpened sticks 2-3' long, and stuck them in the ground in a circle or tepee shape over and around the new ones, rationalizing that deer bend down to graze, and if they got a noseful of sharp stick, that might deter them. So far it seems to be working. The only one that I didn't protect this way (ran out of sticks) got grazed off in a bed of about 10 other protected ones.

Worth a shot, anyway. I have to move the sticks a bit as the plants grow, but they are not obtrusive. I've also used tomato cages, cut in half, with the sharp ends pointed up, and that seems to help too.

Comments (13)

  • 15 years ago

    Does Liquid Fence not work for you?

    There's also a new systemic repellent out this year: Repellex.

    I'm pretty certain the deer I saw earlier this year came thru my garden. No hostas were touched, but a 3' tall lily had the top eaten off... it was spit off a few feet away. So, Liquid Fence stopped the deer from eating any more, I suppose.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't like to spray anything I don't have to. This garden is pretty much chemical free. I do have Ropel that I can use if I get desperate. I also use red pepper from time to time, and that works too.

  • 15 years ago

    Sharpened bamboo poles does not sound like a good idea.

    Try the pepper again or spray instead.

    Paul

  • 15 years ago

    Liquid Fence is basically eggs and garlic.

  • 15 years ago

    You know if you have a person fall on one of those bamboo sticks you're going to have a big problem. A little liquid fence is a lot more "organic" than using sharp objects than can harm children or domestic animals.

    Steve

  • 15 years ago

    Nobody is going to get hurt on those sticks (not poles), except the deer, trust me. Its not a pallisade. They aren't that sturdy or sharp, actually pretty flimsy, just enough to discourage browsing deer that are going to bump their noses but if a person were to be wandering around in the beds and "fall on them" they would just get knocked over. No small children around to get hurt on them and the only domestic animals are my cats that couldn't care less about the hosta beds. The stakes I use to tie up my lilies and perennials, etc are far sturdier and would be more hazardous if someone were to actually go stumbling around inside my beds.

    Even the tomato cages have the wires bent inwards so no one can get hurt on them. I only use those deep in the beds, not near the paths.

    And they don't have to be reapplied each time it rains, don't cost anything, and can be reused until they rot and get tossed into the shredder. When I run out of bamboo, I will just use tree and shrub prunings. Works for me.

  • 15 years ago

    Can you post a picture so we all get a better idea? My dog takes care of my deer problem, but others may need your ingenious solution. Nance

  • 15 years ago

    I do have to get out there and take some pictures. I'm behind on my garden journals and blogging this spring, we just recently lost our youngest daughter and things have been hectic and sad, but I will do better soon.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, mosswitch--so sorry to hear about your daughter! What a tragedy that I cannot imagine!! Saying a prayer for you today.
    Karen

  • 15 years ago

    Move to my house! I don't have any deer. Lol! Phil

  • 15 years ago

    Yeah, Phil, and I expect you'll want me to bring all my 500 + hostas with me, lol!

    Thank you, Karen, It was indeed a sad thing.

  • 15 years ago

    The ultimate solution is to plant anything you don't want eaten w/in a 7' ft high fence. But if that's not an option, be aware that deer will try out any new plant along their new route of travel--regardless of how deer resistant its purported to be. So always cover new plantings with netting for a week or so after planting. BTW, the bamboo does work and if its the small diameter stuff it won't seriously hurt anyone who falls on it. I often place the stakes so that they angle toward the center, making a sort of cage around and over the plant. I also use bamboo, closely spaced, around my Southern Magnolia in the winter to cut the wind--it doesn't get fouled by wet snow like burlap does. Its also great for seasonally fencing your more deer-sensitive shrubs like Clethra and Rhododendron.

  • 15 years ago

    I also use bird netting over newly transplanted moss to keep the %#&*@!!robins off of it.

    The stakes are the most effective method I've come across so far. I am using them all season long, as it doesn't seem to matter how long a hosta (or other plant) has been in the ground, whether it is a new plant or an old established one, sooner or later the deer are going to try it. Last year they ate a big established Regal Splendor to the ground, in August, after leaving it alone for years.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio