Software
Houzz Logo Print
shequit

Best deer repel for hostas

17 years ago

OK, I am guilty - don't post regularly. I do read, however.

Two weeks ago I transplanted about 50 hostas into a new garden area. So far, I have used "deer Stopper" regularly (every few days) and no damage. In fact, prints next to the hosta and no nibbles.

After all the work - I had to dig the hosta out of basically stone to move them to the new garden- I am looking for the best advice about repellent. I have also used "liquid fence" in the past with good results but all of these products are a bit pricey.

I found a site which describes a patent and gives pretty good details about the formula. I will try it and let you know if it works - lots less $$ to make it yourself.

If you have had any great success with repells, please let me know. I live in a Chicago suburb.

Thank you for reading.

Comments (4)

  • 17 years ago

    I have used both Liquid Fence and Plantskydd. I find that the Plantskydd works better but it is pretty messy and you look like you just came out of a bloody massacre. I will say it does work well. The other problem with it is you do need to reapply as new growth or flowers emerge. Last year the deer ate a lot of my streaked flower pods before I had a chance to spray. I tried another product this year called Deer Scram. This is in a powdered form and is rain resistant. The area I placed it in has not been browsed and we have been getting quite a bit of rain. Just like most of the others it is a bit pricey. Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    Zafo - thank you so much for the reply. I have never heard of Plantskydd, did you buy it on-line? If so, where? Also, why is it messy? When I used liquid fence, I put it into a pump spray and it was very easy to use, but as I mentioned, it can be pricey. BTW, I have a half acre of property to cover. Actually an acre, but the back half I just cannot deal with.

    I am still determined to produce a "home-made" cheap solution. If I have success, I will pass it on.

  • 17 years ago

    I have actually purchased Plantskydd in liquid form at a local nursery and also in bulk online. I was able to buy quite a bit cheaper in bulk. I need to check my records on the name of the online store. The bulk version came in a dry powder that you mix with water. Since it is rather thick after mixing my sprayer tended to clog and I would get the stuff all over me when trying to unclog it :) I should probably add more water to thin it out a bit. You can Google it to get more info if you are interested. I believe Plantskydd has a website. Like I said it does work very well if you can stand the smell for a day and the mess.

  • 17 years ago

    zafo - liquid fence also has a nasty smell but I will say the "deer stopper" that I used smelled like mint, nice.

    I am at this point making an emulsion of rosemary and mint oil to which I will add putrified eggs and a thickener. Hopefully I will have a condensed liquid to which I will add enough water to cover the area I am concerned about.

    OK, I am retired and bored!!!!!!!!!

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations