Software
Houzz Logo Print
petraah

Red October Question

16 years ago

Are you happy with 'Red October' hosta? I recently purchased one, however, whenever I see it in a display as a mature specimen, it seems to flatten out. Your opinions? Thanks.

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Red October has been a very slow grower for me. It is one of the first hosta's I purchased and is about eight years old. If I was going to the nursery to buy, it would not be on my list...many other better "reds". Like Cherry Berry for instance. It's not that I don't like it, it doesn't have the "WOW" factor for me.

    becky

  • 16 years ago

    I've had Red October for a number of years. I was sorta talked into it by the nursery owner. For years,it was a scrawny little plant,but even after moving it several times,it always came back up the next year. Now,I have it in a chimney flue planter,and thats where it looks the best,because of its cascading habit. I have to watch it,however,because it is a slug magnet. This year it looks the best it ever has. I would not recommend it to someone wanting to buy it,however. Just a few thoughts. Phil

  • 16 years ago

    Last year my Red October really started to show this flattened more horizontal effect. Mine is next to Sagae - so the two plants contrast nicely - tall vase big leaf vs low spreading narrow leaf.

    The red petiole feature however is really lost under the leaves.
    {{gwi:1014532}}

    Paul

  • 16 years ago

    Not a eye catcher by any means. I have it and Fall Bouquet which are similer and FB does have those wonderful full flower spikes in late summer.

    Probably wouldn't buy it if I was just starting out aquiring hostas.

    Happy Hosta Gardening,

    Connie

  • 16 years ago

    I like mine. I moved it this year as it was being overwhelmed by a large iris; you can see his red legs a little better now. Also, I like the grey-ish undersides. Not a show stopper but a solid hosta, IMHO. This guy is only a couple years old.

  • 16 years ago

    Mine was new last year and is still smallish and mostly upright. I bought it because my birthday is in October. :)
    isn't that a silly reason?

    chris

  • 16 years ago

    I like my Red October very much. I bought it in 2008 at a local nursery. I'm always surprised when a nursery around here has one that I don't already have. I've grown it in a pot raised above the ground against my garden wall. It shows it off very well. The leaves move around with the breeze, it's white underneath, red stems very pretty. Last year when I was trying to get all plants that I don't have a duplicate of into the ground (to protect it from winter loss) I carried it around the garden looking for a spot. The fact was I liked it where it was. I ended up making sure it had good drainage around the crown and kept it in the garage. I would definately replace it if it was lost. McT

  • 16 years ago

    I love mine. It looks pretty similar to gardenj's above, is about three years old, and is one of the first to come up in the spring and last to die back in the fall.

  • 16 years ago

    petraah, I've always had trouble maintaining Red October, it's very slug prone. even when keep bait around it. it gets floppy, early in the season it looks the best, if the slugs haven't got to it. not my favorite. One Mans Treasure has done better, also Katsuragawa Beni, Red Neck Heaven, Purple Glory. I have some new red,purple hybrids that have them beat, with white,silver backs with the purple all the way up the petiole starting into the leaf. Hostajim