Software
Houzz Logo Print
playinmud

H. 'Carnival' question

19 years ago

I still classify myself as a newbie, maybe not a green one, but still a novice. This is the first time I've encountered this on my gardening journey, and could use some help.

'Carnival' came up this year and has leafed out looking really odd. Its leaves are cupped upside down, so they look like umbrellas or better yet, parachutes. What is this? Oh, and the leaves are smaller than last year. Is it sick?

Its very weird.

Thanks!

Donna

Comments (26)

  • 19 years ago

    if it bugs you .. gently cup them the other way ...jeez.. do we have to tell you everything. .... lol .. yes.. peeps actually do this ....

    as for smaller this year... any chance its too deep???

    voles???

    just the fact they are in new jersey ... lol ...

    its not getting watered like the rest of them for some reason ... like on my drip system the dripper gets plugged???

    any shot at a picture ...>???

    ken

    PS: how can someones, whose bio says they have 285 hosta, call themselves a newbie .... ????

  • 19 years ago

    Hey Donna--apparently that is characteristic of one in it's maturing! My three are doing the same thing!

    I love the cream margins, don't you? :o)

    janice

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, and I found a lot of my hosta leafed out smaller this year, especially the ones in containers.
    I think it has something to do with the weird Spring '07! When I dig down to the crowns, I often find them
    partially mush! I've been pouring bleach water (10%)on the crowns, after I dig out as much of the mush as I can!

    janice

  • 19 years ago

    "just the fact they are in new jersey ... lol ..."

    rofl - I used to have a car that broke down every time I went to NJ!
    My Carnival cups down too. Stand a little gnome under it.
    Pam

  • 19 years ago

    I just planted a young,small Carnival this year,and,so far, the leaves are flat,or cupped upward. Maybe it is NJ?lol!! Phil

  • 19 years ago

    It was an up and down spring with hot and cold which can encourage the drawstring effect. In Carnival it often cups downwards and then the edges often get shredded. Unfortunately this is just the nature of this hosta. Some years it will look good and other years it will look terrible.

  • 19 years ago

    Yes Ken, Pam and Phil, I live in NJ, you're right that could have something to do with it...LOL! Remember, this is the Garden State, 3/4's of the world's eggplant is grown here. That's a lot of Eggplant Parmigianino!! And Ken I only have 278 hostas, bought a lot of tcs the first year...who knew they'd grow!! No one warned my that these cute puppies would grow up to be voracious dogs! LOL!

    Anyway, no voles, but it may be too deep, I'll check that out. Everything around 'Carnival' increased this year, except for 'Flamboyant' that looks pitiful too, I've got to move them both I guess. Maybe not enough sun, there's always plenty of water.

    Yes Janice I love that combo. Actually there isn't a hosta I don't like (I even like 'Undulata').

    "Drawstring effect"...that's what that is! I've heard the term, but had nothing to associate it with. Thanks Chris!

    Donna

  • 19 years ago

    Sorry about that,Donna! I found a pic of my new Carnival,for your perusal. See what you think. Phil
    {{gwi:1028334}}

  • 19 years ago

    Oh Phil, you're just trying to taunt me aren't you?! LOL!! That is a beauty. Thanks for sharing

    If I can get a minute I'll go take a pic of mine. Can't tonight, have to go to the pottery studio, but maybe tomorrow.

    Donna

  • 19 years ago

    Hang in there Donna. Here is my history with Carnival.

  • 19 years ago

    Here's mine ... 2nd year and cupping DOWN.
    {{gwi:909979}}

    Char

  • 19 years ago

    This is my second year Carnival
    {{gwi:909964}}

    Janet

  • 19 years ago

    Found this post very interesting because I just purchased Carnival and it is cupping down also (kinda like McT's 1st 2007 pic). I still thought it was very pretty and couldn't resist the 4 eye plant for $6.99!!!

    LOL at the visualization of Pam's suggestion - "put a little gnome under it"

    June

  • 19 years ago

    Carnival, 5 years old, has always cupped down.

  • 19 years ago

    my carnival
    {{gwi:923145}}

  • 19 years ago

    So is your 'Carnival' in deeper shade, ken?

    janice

  • 19 years ago

    yes as compared to many of mine in too much light ... but i also took the picture maybe a bit too late in the evening .... the cheapo camera is hard to deal with in deep shade but still kinda bright .... it has a hard time with the contrast ... so i have to use the editor and really zoom down the gamma .. hence a dark picture to get the leaf colors close ....

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Great pics everyone!

    Ken, yours is stunning, how old is it? Mine was a 1st year tc in 2005, so I guess its a 3yr tc? It did not leap this year as most of the others did. Maybe I should feed it?? Here's my pic.

    {{gwi:1028343}}

  • 19 years ago

    Donna--yours looks like mine! Could I ask what is going on, on the leaf, bottom left (not the hosta but the other one)???

    Ken, I asked about the shade situation, because I'm wondering if that's not why yours isn't experiencing
    the *draw-string* effect?

    janice

  • 19 years ago

    I can answer that,Janice. Those little squiggly things in the leaf are leaf miners,very common in Colombines. Phil

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Phil, that's what they are. The columbine just grow anywhere and are plagued by the leaf miners after they're done blooming. Don't know if there's a cure, but it doesn't seem to retard the columbine in any way. Good eye Janice. ;o)

    Donna

  • 19 years ago

    Lol, I thought the were supposed to bend downward. I figured it can't be good for the plant if water collects in the hollow formed with the tip turns upward.
    A lot of the pictures of this one at the Hosta Library show then turned downward.

  • 19 years ago

    drawstring is just when the green tissue [the interior tissue]grows faster than the white [the edge tissue]... perhaps a hot period at leaf extension ...

    this plant is not known for the drawstring effect... so something had to happen this spring for it to happen ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks Ken, its good to know that this isn't the norm.

    Donna

  • 19 years ago

    Donna I had some Columbines affected by leaf miners and read to just pinch off the affected leaves. It worked for me, no miners this year.

    If your whole plant is affected, then I don't know how that would work.

    Janet

  • 19 years ago

    Here's a pic of my 2nd year Carnival. I bought it as a pretty decent sized specimen last year, so that I could share it as part of the "Secret Trade" here at the hosta forum. It appears to be somewhat of a slug magnet, as evidenced by the small holes on some leaves (but I must admit, I've been rather negligent this year on my slug patrol...) In general, most of the leaves cup down, but some don't really cup at all. And you can see some leaves have some significant puckering, which I believe is a result of the extended late frost we had this spring.

    Buff

    Carnival 6-9-07