Software
Houzz Logo Print
tomahawkclaim

HVX -- 2nd post

16 years ago

Something seemed to go wrong with the first post so, . . .

I don't think I have any HVX in my garden but . . .

Since HVX doesn't kill plants and can only be spread by the sap of an infected plant, what's wrong with just leaving a diseased plant in the garden? Would the disease spread from root to root even if the roots aren't cut? Nance

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    It could be spread if you were to remove a leaf....
    Some people do not removed leaves in the fall for this reason...fear it will be on your knife.

    But also think about this. Say you move. You leave the plant behind. Someone unknowingly digs it to divide with a friend cuz it's a cool looking plant. Well, it's spread.

    I think it's best to just get rid of it.... kind of a "for the good of the genus" kind of thing. The fewer plants there are out there with it, the less chance it'll spread. Even if it is just one plant.

  • 16 years ago

    I was just about to start a thread with this question. Maybe the experts can help us both out.
    I have a Sum and Substance with HVX. As long as I can stand it aesthetically (and I can, for now), wouldn`t it just be safest to leave the plant in the ground? It IS in a communal hosta bed, but it`s never touched or cut. I`m thinking about planting some heuchera around it and calling it a day. (Not so close to it where I might disturb the roots).Seems to me that digging it up will only invite problems, shovel infection, cut roots, sap, etc.
    My question is....can the virus spread simply through the soil on an otherwise untouched diseased plant?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sum and Substance with HVX

  • 16 years ago

    Animals, hail, strong wind, leaf blower, weeding, raking, or accidentally stepping on an HVX infected hosta could move it too. The worst culprits are those that rarely show symptoms like Halcyon, Minuteman, Patriot, Revolution or those that are really hard to see visually. They can carry it without you knowing, then even if you are "careful" with the known virused plants what about the unknown ones?

    I can pretty much guarantee that if you have one or two (or more) showing in the garden there are likely several more that also have it. You would have to test them all to find out which ones have it.

    Keeping HVX infected plants is far too risky if you value your collection at all. And yes, who knows what might happen to those horrific plants once you are gone. Do the right thing and get rid of them. We can't have any tolerance for virused plants or we won't ever get rid of the problem.

    Chris

  • 16 years ago

    Not to mention, it is possible that a deer browsing could snack on the infected plant and transmit the virus through its saliva to a healthy plant on the next bite.... I would pitch it too.

    Alexa

  • 16 years ago

    Bugs, pests, birds, woodchucks, squirrels, dogs, cats, slugs, etc.
    Basically anything associated w/ contact runs a "heavy" risk.

  • 16 years ago

    WOW! 3 of us posted at the exact same time with very similar thoughts.....

    Alexa

  • 16 years ago

    I would think of it as keeping the Typhoid Mary of hostas.

  • 16 years ago

    It sounds like the best course of action would be to round up it versus digging? It has already been stated but as I read the post about just leaving it I thought of my Tuesday. A rather large branch fell off during our rainy day. Smashed the HECK out of a very large hosta, ordinary green guy not a show piece except for its size..anyway IF it had been diseased...well you get the picture.

  • 16 years ago

    You could try Roundup, maybe even combine roundup and brush-b-gon. Repeated applications might be needed over the next couple seasons.

    And then never plant another hosta there.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm POSITIVE I have an August Moon with HVX. Until I get a confirmation with the test I sent for however, I won't touch it, but it has hosta ALL around it and I know if I dig, the engangled roots will be all be compromised. Digging just doesn't seem to be an option - what happens underground frightens me. So Roundup seems to be the best option. My plan is to protect everything next to it (from Roundup) with overturned pails and large boxes, then spray on a still day. If anyone sees anything wrong with this approach, please let me know.

    Westy

  • 16 years ago

    You can apply Round-Up with a disposable brush, or wear a rubber glove and put on a cloth glove over it. Dip your fingers in the Round-Up solution and wipe them on the leaves.

    -Babka

  • 16 years ago

    If you kill the plant with Roundup, will that kill all the virus, too?