Software
Houzz Logo Print
grandmothers_rose

Are award winning iris 'better'?

Are iris that have received the Award of Merit or Wister or Dykes Medal better? How so? I notice that several I have marked as possible purchases as Dykes Medal winners (or multiple other awards) are not for sale, for example, in the Snowpeak online catalog. Do the "unawarded" iris have equally good substance, good branching, good disease resistance? Aargh! How do you decide?

Comments (16)

  • 20 years ago

    I would regard it as a positive. As with most awards it tends to be, "Who is the prettiest girl "IN" the beauty contest. Some Australian or French iris were introduced outside of the US and therefore ineligible for an award. Some from smaller growers just don't get enough attention. Walter had a plicata a few years ago that had exceptional branching and very good vigor, I don't know if it got any awards.
    There is the matter too of local vigor. Some iris just don't do well in all areas. Expose' does wonderfully in the drier climates, looks pretty average here in the rain.
    Unless they get sent to me as a bonus, I don't buy an iris I haven't seen growing first.

  • 20 years ago

    It is just a matter of personal opinion. Certainly the award winners are usually beautiful iris but I am not sure how much weight substance carries with the judges. I am sure branching plays a part but I doubt if they would know about being resistant to disease. In any given year there are several iris that are right there with the winners as far as form and beauty. Different iris will grow better in different climates but having won an award would not necessarily mean anything in your climate. If growers offer them for sale they must have some merit so I would choose the ones that you like.

  • 20 years ago

    I peruse the catalog pictures and buy what catches my eye and strikes my fancy. I do not pay to much attention to awards etc.
    And all iris rhizomes I have bought in threes, and planted them toe to toe, bloomed in spring with a BANG!
    Then your hooked!
    Great info Mr Moores.

  • 20 years ago

    *sigh* Well, from experience the only award winning roses consistantly worth growing are the Gamble Award winners because they have to have been in commerce for 10 years (I think), be relatively disease resistant, and smell wonderful. The award is only given as merited. I grew 3 and would endorse them all. Unfortunatley, the Japanese beetles liked them the best, too.

    I had hoped the Dyke's Medal would be similar. Ah well. I'm sure they will be pretty. There is no substitute for experience.

    Violet Shimmer strikes my fancy, too. Mr. Moores, do you hybridize for branching, substance, and disease resistance? Any recommendations? Humm?

    I found the AIS website and e-mailed Jerry Coates, the Region 4 rep. Is there a better way to find an Iris Society in my area?

  • 20 years ago

    Grandmother's Rose,

    The societies should be listed somewhere in the bulletin.

    Chesapeake & Potomac, Fredericksburg, and a new one in Richmond, I believe. Surely, there are others in VA. You could contact the Spoons at Winterbury Gardens in nw VA.

    Walter Moores

  • 20 years ago

    I would never buy an iris simply because it was a Dykes (or any other kind) of winner. I just buy what I see and what I like, awards notwithstanding. If I see it won an award I think 'Oh wow, cool! others think this one is really nice too!'
    I think this 'awards' thing is kind of political anyways. Seems you have to be one of the well known growers to get it nowadays. It means the iris got alot of publicity and it has been seen by alot of people. I think there are plenty of gorgeous, strong, floriferous iris developed by local or unknown hybridizers that will never get close to a national medal, but are just as beautiful. You will not see another DEBBY RAIRDON win the Dykes. (DR was bred by a backyard hobbyist)
    Walter's advice is good: a Dykes winner that is not going to perform in your area is not worth growing. Look for those developed in your region or growing well there.
    Laetitia

  • 20 years ago

    My two cents for any new iris growers out there.

    If you do not have access to viewing in person and rely on a catalog, do choose what appeals to you AND check to see if it won an award. I have had a number of zero-award beardeds and most are being removed. They may have looked great in a picture or the description was intriguing, but in person, ho hum. They are taking space from the Ahhh-factor iris.

    With the exception of hybridizers who have a small (huge by my standards) set-up, an iris that can't garner enough Honorable Mention (HM) votes is probably not worth the space in your garden.

    That leads to learning the names of the hybridizers. An iris from a major hybridizer not receiving enuf votes for an HM is quite different than one from a less well-known hybridizer. We are truly lucky Walter Moores participates on this forum. I watch for his iris especially now since I know his standards are high.

    Award of Merit (AM) winners are great looking iris. Period. When I've chosen an AM winner in my favorite colors (pink and lavender) I've never been disappointed. With the HM winners I have about a 50% track record.

  • 20 years ago

    There are several societies in VA. When I lived there 3 years ago, I was a member of the Central VA Iris Society, which meets in/near Richmond. I miss that group; they were very active. The Fredricksburg group is also very active, as is the C & P. I don't know about the other 2 in VA. But I would encourage you to join one - dues are cheap, and you'll learn a lot!

    I also attended the AIS National Convention in Northern VA in '03, and that year was WET. It rained pretty much the whole convention. Mr. Moores' guest irises at the convention were standouts. Many other irises were covered in leaf spot and had stalks flopped over from all the rain. His did not. I currently only have a couple of his intros in my collection, but based on their performance, I fully intend to add more in the near future. For an iris grower in humid VA, I would most definitely recommend his intros.

    The other standouts at the convention were the miniature tall beardeds, as a group. The more I see them, the more I like them. Try a few of those - I think you'll enjoy them. They seem to be less prone to a lot of iris maladies and bloom like fools.

    Iris awards are not immune to politics, so I take them with a grain of salt.

    Diana

  • 20 years ago

    Oops. I meant to include a link to the local societies in Region 4. Here you go.

    Diana

    Here is a link that might be useful: Region 4 Local Societies

  • 20 years ago

    Bless you, Diana. What you said will put a skip in my walk this morning.

    Walter Moores

  • 20 years ago

    Put a hop to it too Mr Moores!
    I have recieved Lemon Chess,Hawaiian Surf (which I did not realize was YOURS!) Have AscII Art & Purgatory on its way!
    Pictures for spring!
    Rae Ann

  • 20 years ago

    Hopefully you're floating above the ground with all the nice intros you've made!

    I added ASCII ART, and LEMON CHESS to my gardens this year.

    Thanks for your wonderful intros, and for contributing to this forum!

    Polly

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks to all of you. Enjoy your irises.

    Walter Moores

  • 20 years ago

    I e-mailed Jerry Coates, whose address I found on the AIS website for Virginia. He pointed me to Don and Ginny Spoon of Winterberry Gardens near Winchester, Va. They sent me a catalog AND directions to their gardens, about 90 minutes north of me.

    Looks like I'm hooked!

    I want to say a gigantic "Thank you!" to everyone who has answered my questions. I am starting off on the right foot with iris (as opposed to the left foot I put forth with roses.) Just when DH thought I was through spending money on the garden . . .

  • 20 years ago

    I have ordered from Winterberry the past three years. I believe they are the leaders in reblooming iris. I just let Ginny pick them for me and so far she has really picked the ones that will rebloom in my area. This year I went for continious bloom or repeat bloomers. Lee Mincy

Sponsored