Software
Houzz Logo Print
rubybaby43

MILs problems

19 years ago

Got a "panicky" email from my MIL this morning. I haven't had this problem. Does anyone have any input on what she should do?

MIL: Help! Help! I have something eating my petunias and starting to munch on the hostas planted in the front planter up against the house. They are small dark gray catapillars. What can I do to get rid of the things?????? Any ideas??

Thanks!!

Kristy :)

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago

    Buy a can of house and garden spray....or get some Safer insecdicidal soap or buy some BT ....but that takes longer and also endangers good worms that turn into butterflies.
    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    Buy a can of house and garden spray....or get some Safer insecdicidal soap or buy some BT ....but that takes longer and also endangers good worms that turn into butterflies.

    Thanks! Anytime I have had a worm/caterpillar problem in my garden I've had my 7-year-old DD pluck them. She enjoys it and it's free.

    I'll pass the word along.

    Kristy :)

  • 19 years ago

    NO NO NO ...

    FIRST YOU MUST ID THE BUG ..... and then you must act on the bug ....

    we do not recommend willy nilly spraying of anything ...

    there is a good chance that those bugs have nothing to do with the hosta .... and for all you know.. are eating the slugs that are making the problem ...

    the only worms i know of that attack hosta are cutworms.. and they were gone in late may ... even in the great white north of MN ...

    PLEASE.. have her take them to a yuppie garden center... and properly ID them before she goes nuclear on them ...

    good luck

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks, Ken! I'll send the word along! She's used to maintenance free plants for the most part. But since they bought their house a couple of years ago she has been pretty proactive in trying to take care of what the previous owners planted.

    Kristy :)

  • 19 years ago

    I was seeing cutworms on June 25th here so don't rule those out yet.

  • 19 years ago

    yeah .. but cutworms live in the soil .. and come out to chew at night.. and return to the soil .. and i have never seen more than one on a plant...

    they would not be on the plant in the middle of the day ... as far as i know..

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Hi Ken,
    The reason I said cutworms is cause the poster didn't give a time line to when these were being found. I've found them in the late evenings and early morning before the sun was completely gone. They were horrid this year and I found a couple of plants here that had 2 or 3 CW on them at once. We just can't rule out something cause one of us isn't seeing it anymore :-)

  • 19 years ago

    true true true ... but she said she got the email this morning....

    anyway ... you agree they have to ID the dirty rat, before they go spraying.. right????

    hey .. i aint no bug spert... for all i know.. you could be right ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    I'd say yes to id before doing anything. I wouldn't use chemicals though and would hand pick.

  • 19 years ago

    Did I open a "can of worms"? LOL!

    I told MIL to either ID them before she acted or to just pluck the babies off and toss them into a bucket of soapy water. The latter is what I have my DD do with the pests I find on my yarrow (that I regret ever planting!!). She didn't give me anymore than I shared here...but I suspect she probably saw them munching away on her plants and am guessing that they are, indeed, cutworms. :\

    Thanks for the input!
    Kristy :)