Software
Houzz Logo Print
runktrun

'Quote' Unquote

17 years ago

I tend to skim through many gardening books in search of my current topic of interest and know I have found a book that I need to sit down and slowly consume when I repeatedly grunt out loud (a signal to Joe) followed by and enthusiastic bid for him to stop and listen to what ever brilliantly written string of words that have deeply moved me. A recent recommendation from ViburnumValley to pick up Bringing Nature Home how native plants sustain wildlife in our gardens by Douglas W. Tallamy caused me to start reading aloud a few pages into chapter one and many chapters later my enthusiasm has yet to wane.

I thought we might post a quote from a gardening book that has moved us (laughter, insight, disbelief, ect) in someway to encourage some garden related discussion. From TallamyÂs Bringing Nature Home;

Early on in my assault on the aliens in our yard, I noticed a rather striking pattern. The alien plants that were taking over the land-the multiflora roses, the autumn olives, the oriental bittersweets, the Japanese honeysuckles, the Bradford pears, the Norway maples, and the mile-a-minute weeds-all had very little or no leaf damage from insects, while the red maples, black and pin oaks, black cherries, black gums, black walnuts, and black willows had obviously supplied many insects with food. This was alarming because it suggested a consequence of alien invasion occurring all over North America that neither I-nor anyone else, I discovered, after checking the scientific literature-had considered. If our native insect fauna cannot, or will not use alien plants for food, then insect populations in areas with many alien plants will be smaller than insect populations in areas with all natives. This may sound like a gardeners dream: a land without insects! But because so many animals depend partially or entirely on insect protein for food, a land without insects is a land without most forms of higher life (Wilson1987).

So what do you think of what Tallamy has written? Do you believe the ever increasing population of alien plants will have ever increasing effects on animal populations, if so to what lengths? And/or share with us a gardening related quote that has moved you in someway. kt

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Katy! I was thinking of you a lot recently. And because I am reading gardening books right now, I was thinking of your suggestion before it appeared here. I'm not with my books now, but I recently read Thoreau's essays on his bean crop and others that made me think "I'd just love to send this paragraph off to my Gardenweb friends" They don't have anything to do with Tallamy's observation, but they are about gardening. Back soon with some quotes!
    Marie

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Katy,
    Your post recalled, to me, a poem of Walt Whitman's...
    Roots and Leaves Themselves Alone

    Roots and leaves themselves alone are these.
    Scents brought to men and women from the wild woods and pond-side,
    Breast-sorrel and pinks of love, fingers that wind around tighter than vines.
    Gushes from the throats of birds hid in the foliage of trees as the sun is risen,
    Breezes of land and love set from living shores to you on the living sea, to you O sailors!
    Frost-mellow'd berries and Third-month twigs offer'd fresh to young persons wandering out in the fields
    when the winter breaks up.
    Love-buds put before you and withing you whoever you are.
    Buds to be unfolded on the old terms.
    If you bring the warmth of the sun to them they will open and bring form, color, perfume, to you.
    If you become the aliment and the wet they will become flowers, fruits, tall branches and trees.

    Molie

  • 17 years ago

    Tallamy's point is interesting, but I think he makes a big mistake by basing it on casual - no, make that sloppy - and limited observation of his property. There are LOTS of insects that eat multiflora rose and Norway maples, and I don't think we're in danger of having fewer total insects because of the dominance of these plants. That's just a guess, but as good a guess as his speculation, I'd bet.

    I think he's missing the point; there are certain insects that rely on specific local plants and that form an essential link in one part of the food web. It's not the total number of insects that's critical, it's the diversity of plants and insects that we need to maintain if we're going to hope to sustain diversity overall in the plant and animal kingdoms. I don't think we know all the "critical links" yet, but unfortunately, we'll probably know more as more species disappear.

    Just my 2 cents, freely available as always.

  • 17 years ago

    I'm guessing the Wilson 1987 is referenced from E.O. Wilson's Biophilia . He was an insect expert.. ants, I think... and used his observatons as a basis for his idea of biophilia. Will changes in the plant population alter the insect population or will the insect population adjust to the changing plant world? Do these two components of the natural world learn from each other and adjust over time? That is, will insects develop a "taste" for these alien plants as their preferred diet declines? I don't know the answer... time will tell.

    Dtd, you said it well ... our world depends on the interaction between plants and insects and that as long as there is diversity, there will be balance. But we can't control Nature... She controls us.

    Molie

  • 17 years ago

    When I moved here 6 years ago, this yard was overrun with most of the worst woody invasives in the Northeast. As I've removed the invasives, and planted many natives, I have casually observed increasing numbers of weird and interesting insects, not to mention an increase in the more obvious critters like birds and butterflies. Were they here before that but I didn't notice them? I'm not sure.

    My tentative hypothesis about invasive plants is this - there are a minority of native fauna species that will benefit from the invasive plants. For examples, Cardinals and Robins, which eat the abundant berries from invasive shrubs. Certain pollinators love the flowers on these same shrubs. However, as the majority of native plant species decline in number because they are overrun by invasive plants, overall biodiversity will suffer.

    Even if native fauna DOES use the invasive flora, and in some cases show a preference for invasive flora, could that detract from the survival of native flora? Below is a link to a study of Bumblebees that discovered they have a preference for Purple Loosestrife, even with other wetland plants present. The scientist said "This preference for purple loosestrife or other exotics could threaten reproduction of native plants and have devastating effects on ecosystems."

    Here is a link that might be useful: Flight of the Bumblebee: Researchers Find that Flower Choice Matters

  • 17 years ago

    Please understand I am not defending purple loosestrife, but I want to share the thoughts of a master beekeeper (not me,) With the great diminishment of natural habitat and large orchards, loosestrife has become a major source of bee forage. Bees love it and it is widespread and available. It blooms lateish in summer, when bees need to build their honey stores for the winter. This is also when beekeepers harvest their honey, with plenty left over for the bees.

    When large scale removal and control of purple loosestrife is effective, honey production decreases. Of course beekeepers know this invasive must be controlled; but it does put them in a quandry.

  • 17 years ago

    Just wanted to report, I bought "Bringing Nature Home" last week, and have finished it. Excellent read! Douglas Tallamy (Professor and Chair Entomology and Wildlife Ecology at U Delaware) warns that biodiversity all over the world is gravely threatened by human activity and yet we all have the ability, no matter how small our yard is, to do something positive for the wild critters by planting native plants, even just 1 native tree. One theme that he reiterates, in a soft-spoken way, is the fact that the Nursery and Landscaping industries are guilty over and over again of introducing insect pests that are devastating our native trees in North America.

    I will never look at insects quite the same way either! Mr. Tallamy explains very well the importance of insects in the native ecosystem. For example, 95% of terrestrial bird species raise their young on almost exclusively insects, many of which are "insect herbivores". These insect herbivores almost exclusively eat native plants, because these are the plants that they co-evolved with for thousands of years. There is little evidence as yet that these insects are adapting to eating non-native plants.

    Easy to read, very enlightening book. Bring on the caterpillars! :)

  • 17 years ago

    There is not doubt that some alien invasives support some native wildlife. They just support far less than native plants do.

    I think that the commenters here who defend purple loosestrife, for example, have not read Tallamy's book, much less the rigorous scientific studies he cites. I suggest that people do so before they dismiss his ideas.