Software
Houzz Logo Print
kentstar_gw

Great Expectations hosta: Worth it?

16 years ago

I am thinking of getting a hosta for a large wine barrel that I have. I've been looking around. I found one that I really think I like called Great Expectations. I like the very large leaves and the variegations. Also, it will have to make it through winters here in the barrel, as I can't lift it! lol

What do you think of this one? and will it survive in the barrel if I plant it now? (assuming that I order that one now).

Thanks

Cathy

Here is a link that might be useful: Great Expectations

Comments (15)

  • 16 years ago

    Good luck with that. I've had 2 over the years. Never kept one longer than 3 years. Fussy, fussy, fussy. They sure are pretty, though.

    Do a search on this forum for Great Expectations and post back what you decide.

    PS: If you buy a not-so-picky hosta and plant now...either in a barrel or ground, it should be fine.

    PPS: You definitely should also do a search for growing hosta in pots, paying special attention to info coming from your zone. I haven't had luck with pots; however, I only did it once when I was not so schooled on the topic. I may try again in the future, but lots of ground to fill before I mess with pots.

    Gayle

  • 16 years ago

    Well, after reading all the comments and seeing how slowww a grower it is, I decided to go with Frances Williams. How's Frances? Will she survive in a big, big pot over winter? Hope so...

  • 16 years ago

    Olive Bailey Langdon is the look alike that grows faster and does not get the spring dissection that FW does.

  • 16 years ago

    Cathy, Jenna's suggestion is good. If you like the look of Frances Williams, buy Olive Bailey Langdon instead. As beautiful as FW is in the early spring, its edges dry up and melt away - even in the shade. From what I read on this forum, you will be much happier with OBL. Compare the photos of each at hostalibrary.org.

  • 16 years ago

    Great Expecations.... tough to grow
    Frances Williams....burns in the spring

    Paradigm would be a great grower, quite tough, always looks great, easy to find, and the price is usually good!

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with melissa. Paradigm is my favorite hosta. Tough, doesn't burn, slug resistant, fast grower and always looks good.

    I put a Great Expectations in at the same time as Paradigm. Great is still small. Paradigm is easily 3' in diameter and it's color is like a beacon.

  • 16 years ago

    I have looked into the Olive Bailey Langdon and Made in the Shade gardens has it, so I am contacting Rob to see if I can get it. Thanks for the suggestion! Although I already purchased FW from Hallson's maybe I can find a real shady spot (I think next to my shed) where she can do what she wants and maybe not burn.
    Do you think it'll be ok to plant in the barrel and leave out during winter? Or is that too risky at this planting time of year? It is a huge half wine barrel, but I've never tried overwintering in a pot left outside here.

  • 16 years ago

    Kentstar, before ordering, check out a local nursery or even the big orange box store. This Spring I picked up a couple Whirlwinds, etc. at the box store for real cheap! Here's a pic of my Paradigm:

  • 16 years ago

    Beware of big box stores and HVX. It is not worth the risk just to save a few bucks. There are many threads on here about this subject. Same goes for Walmart.

  • 16 years ago

    Don't give up on Great Expectations. When it's good it's great!

  • 16 years ago

    I have two pairs of hostas in pots, Olive Bailey Langdon and Alex Summers. The latter is more striking and impressive at the moment.

    I do dig these up and bury them in the winter, a major task.

  • 16 years ago

    Come on, give it another try. Mine looks fabulous this year!

    Great Expectations in 2008

    and this year...

    Tanya

  • 16 years ago

    Well, I ordered all three, Olive Bailey Langdon, Great Expectations, and Frances Williams. I'll pot up OBL and plant the other two next to my shed. lol
    I guess I'll have to plant them farther out from the shed to account for growth. Maybe I can leave some room for burying the other during winter?

  • 16 years ago

    I'm speaking from my zone 4 experience.
    I planted Royal Standard (among the tough-as-nails hostas) in a 1/2 barrel in 2008. It failed to come up in 2009 and the crown had rotted so much it was indistinguishable.

    There are 3 (maybe more) potential issues with overwintering in barrels.
    A. Root ball getting too cold. I doubt this is going to be a problem in your zone 5 garden, but if you happen to have a tough winter, it could be a problem.

    B. Heaving. Having the entire root ball above ground creates a very unstable temperature situation. So, if part of the rootball thaws, it could heave the rest up and a subsequent deep freeze could damage the root tissue.

    C. Crown Rot. Snow will pile onto the top of the planter. When it comes time to thaw, the water can sit on top of the crown and cause rot. Now, that said, I do have 2 friends with different techniques to combat this:

    1. Let the root ball freeze, then turn container and all onto its side. This way, as snow thaws or heavy spring rains come, they're not puddling right onto the crown. This technique is done by a friend, but I don't know if she does it with anything as large as a barrel.
    2. Let the root ball freeze, cover with plastic to keep the moisture out, insulate that with either wood mulch or straw/hay. This is the way a grower handles all of his 100's of 1 gallon pots that he overwinters here in his MN backyard.

    All that said, I think hey_j has a wine barrel or 2 in her landscape. She's zone 5 Ohio.

  • 16 years ago

    Last year I ended up with 3 new great expectations. It's a long story... But 2 (single eye) went into the ground and 1 (triple eye) went into a pot. The one in the pot looks great this year. I moved the pot into the unheated zone5 garage over the winter so it didn't turn into solid ice. Maybe the ones in the ground have too much shade? My only concern is 3 eyes was bought from a big box store, so I don't know if I got anything extra along with it (HVX). It sure looks great.