Software
Houzz Logo Print
asarum_gw

Lilies or not?

19 years ago

I have only 2 lily plants in my yard and these suffer disgusting damage from the lily leaf beetle. This has made me simply bypass lilies for sale. If I see the pest on my 2 plants, I kill it, but I am so busy that it often does extensive damage before I notice. Are any types of lilies less susceptible? Is there any point in being a laid-back grower of lilies or are they now only for vigilant?

Comments (28)

  • 19 years ago

    They are really cool looking insects, but the larvae are really gross. I say this, as I am about to write off my lilies. Last spring, they finally found their way to my garden. My asiatics were devestated and laid waste. Too high maintenance now.

  • 19 years ago

    Unless you are totally organic, or opposed to using any pesticides at all, you still can have lilies without major maintenance.

    Bayer's Rose and Flower Spray, or other imidacloprid products, will kill the beetles and keep them away for a month or so. If applied according to the directions, there is little hazard to animals, including people.

    For a while I was living in NYC and coming to MA every month and a half during the summer. I kept the beetles under control and the lilies were OK.

    Claire

    Here is a link that might be useful: FAQ on lily leaf beetles

  • 19 years ago

    From what I have read (I have no firsthand experience) there is (apparently only) one cultivar that the beetle mostly avoids -

    Black Beauty. (This online catalog entry specifically mentions the beetle's reluctance to eat it, but that wasn't where I encountered that info. I learned that by reading the Boston Globe, in an article where the Univ. Rhode Island researcher Dr. Casagrande (who is looking for a biocontrol for this pest) stated that in his trials Black Beauty was the only lily the beetle seemed to avoid (only minor feeding damage).)

    Black Beauty is either regarded as an Oriental, or the very first (from decades ago) "Orienpet". It gets 7'+ tall if its happy, but doesn't need staking even when that tall and covered with flowers. It has a reputation for being nearly indestructible.

    Of course, you have to like the way it looks. I also believe it's fragrant, although not as intensely so as many of the Oriental Hybrids are.

  • 19 years ago

    I love lilies and planted some bulbs at my mother's place in Pennsylvania...no beetles. I did have three Casablanca lilies that didn't seem to suffer damage, but I did keep my eye on them and picked off just a couple beetles. Still, I'm not ready to go full blown into lilies again. I'm surprised I still have a few that come up and get eaten every year. The Casablancas were planted away from previous infestations. I hate the hassle of spraying all the time.

  • 19 years ago

    I am here in ground zero for these pests and I still grow them. One year I vowed to just yank them all and then couldn't throw them away. I planted them somewhere else. My biggest defense is picking and squishing twice a day - high maintenance and gross. I also tear off the leaves with the larva and throw them away. When the plants get really bad I just cut them to the ground and throw them away. Lilys are really very robust plants. I am sure this is not what they like but I still have them. I notice that when grown in pots on my deck they are unaffected. I have some Casablanca's as well and for me they are also not affected.

  • 19 years ago

    No way could I miss the beauty of lilies! that scent on a heavy, humid, warm evening? UNHUH.

    I have grouped them together and have relocated them to sites where I may easily inspect them and give them the routine spraying that is now required.

    Breaks my heart that something that was always so EASY is now "high maintenance". :(

  • 19 years ago

    Lilies are too beautiful to forgo, yet I vow no pesticides in the yard due to barefoot toddlers and lots of pets. So I struggle with the personal dilema of squishing bugs every day even though Im a pacificist. I spend my days at work saving little furry animals and my sunsets squishing the little red buggars. My wife calls my ritual, the carnage. But a fragrant lily on top of a basket full o veggies given to a neighbor in august is well worth my inner struggle.

  • 19 years ago

    that Black Beauty lily is a real hum-dinger. I was all ready to order it when their basket came up and said they only ship $30. Anybody else want one?

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, Debra, don't if they're charging that kind of shipping! Black Beauty is easy to find.

    B&D Lilies is a reputable carrier. Jung's Seed Co. carries it too. I've ordered stuff from both companies and been satisfied, although I haven't ordered lilies.

  • 19 years ago

    I've also had great success with the Bayer spray. I'm mainly an organic gardener, and also squash beetles and pick off the larvae, but it's really hard to get them all (especially when my neighbors don't even try). Last year I barely had any damage at all, and only got around to spraying twice all season...

  • 19 years ago

    You did not say what type of lilies you grow. I had Asiatic Lilies - the beatles love them too much and I had to remove them from my garden. While they like the Oriental Lilies, the bug situation is more manageable. I start spraying neem oil very early in the season to keep them at bay. My challenge has been about taking control early (I do better some years vs others). In my area the beatles show up as soon as the lily pokes a little green out of the ground.

  • 19 years ago

    I've heard good things about using DE at the base of the plants in early spring. The theory is that it disrupts the larva development.

    Please tell me that works! I don't want to lose my star gazers. I wasn't here last year, so I don't know how they held up, but I've been looking forward to them so much. I've got hundreds of them lining a pathway behind a pond. (or I did. yikes.)

    I'm using DE as a wormer in my sheep for the same reason.

    I hate lily beetles.

    Here is a link that might be useful: My stargazers

  • 19 years ago

    Lisanh, your photos are gorgeous! I had a few that were completely eaten. They really perfume the air. I had them in a bed right across from my front door. Every time I walked out the door, it was heaven. sigh...

  • 19 years ago

    lisanh:

    The first thing that happens in early spring is the adult beetles popping out of the ground. They overwinter underground and emerge about the same time as the early lilies do. I doubt if DE (I assume you mean diatomaceous earth) would hinder the adult beetles particularly, although I'm just guessing.

    The adult beetles lay eggs on plants. These eggs hatch and the larvae do all of their damage aboveground on the leaves. They don't touch ground until they're ready to pupate, so DE would come too late for the first round of larvae. It might stop the pupation, but the larvae have already eaten the early lilies by this point.

    I think you're better off using a soil drench or similar product as the first attack in early spring. This kills off the beetles before they emerge.

    I did that last spring with good results. I saw the first beetles emerge while the lilies were still really small (not much leaf to spray) so I poured the Bayer soil drench product around the plants. A few months later in the season I sprayed when I saw beetles or larvae again.

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    What kind of soil drench did you use?

    I worry about the foliage sprays, because we keep bees, and I don't want to do anything to harm them, even though I may love my lilies more. Please don't tell the bees.

    Here are a couple of articles that promote DE:

    http://www.flower-garden-bulbs.com/redlilybeetle.html

    This powder is reputed to work on the red lily beetle by giving it lots of tiny cuts and the insect dies from dehydration.

    http://www.gardening-tips-perennials.com/Doug_Greens_Garden-mulch.html

    The diatomaceous earth works mechanically to kill off beetles. It works.

    I don't know. I hate to do something that will harm earth worms as well, but wow, I probably have 200 lilies all told.

  • 19 years ago

    I just went down cellar to check the half-used bottle of the soil drench:

    it was Bayer All in One Rose and Flower Care

    With all of the Bayer products you have to follow the label directions - for the spray they say to apply the product either very early in the morning or very late in the afternoon when you no longer see bees and other good insects flying around. Once it's absorbed into the plant there's no danger to bees or people etc.

    The soil drench doesn't say this, probably because you pour it and it doesn't get into the air, so bees aren't exposed to it. I didn't see a reference to earthworms, only that's it's toxic to aquatic invertebrates.

    I'm frankly skeptical of the Doug statements - he doesn't say he's used it himself or give any references (I haven't seen the book, I just checked the site). I also just googled "lily leaf beetle diatomaceous earth" and found a lot of vague references. If you try it and it works, please post it.

    Doug also says:

    "Imidacloprid is a registered chemical for controlling red lily beetles but IÂve heard it isnÂt all that effective; I havenÂt seen any research results."

    Imidacloprid is the pesticide in the Bayer products and there are numerous posts each year on Garden Web from people who have tried it with great success.

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    If Claire correctly describes the life cycle (& I don't know one way or the other) then I think she's right about DE not working. If that's the beetle's life cycle, then it resembles the cycle for Asparagus leaf beetle (another unpleasant pest if you grow your own Asparagus).

  • 19 years ago

    Imidacloprid is a systemic pesticide; it gets absorbed into the plant tissues and any insect that dares to eat the plant gets killed off. It also kills the insect on contact.

    The advantage here is that you don't have to even see the insect to kill it - you've given the plant that defense.

    You always have to consider the possibility that the lily leaf beetle may fly in from next door, or down the street, or it may have overwintered in a different part of the yard. So long as the plant has the systemic in its tissues, the beetle (or larva) gets killed as soon as it eats.

    Speaking as a person who doesn't like to squish bugs, or spray frequently, or use extremely toxic chemicals, this is a gift.

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    Clarification:

    When I said "It also kills the insect on contact." I meant that if you spray the insect directly, you kill it. Once the spray is dried and absorbed, a benign insect like a bee can land on the plant and not be hurt.

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    Has anybody suffered damage to native lilies such as Turks Cap Lilies? I have been growing these from seed in recent years (a patient endeavor :-)) and as they are part of the Lilium family, I am worried about their future. I have given up growing Asiatic Lilies because I can't deal with the constant vigilence required to keep them safe from the lily leaf beetles.
    Ellen

  • 19 years ago

    Dear YORK ROSE,

    Sorry for the late response... Thanks for your tip on B&D nurseries for the black beauty lily. They look beautiful on the web site and you are right - much more economical. I really appreciate a bargain so you and I are now friends for life! hahahahaha. Hope you are having a wonderful summer and most productive and lovely garden.

    Cheers.
    Debra

  • 19 years ago

    Hi,

    I wanted to ad my experiences to the collective knowledge about lilies/lily beetles. I have CasaBlancas that are showing some damage and I have to get a little busier getting them out of there.

    I also have native tiger lilies which they have munched on.

    The best news I have, is that I do have the Black Beauty lily. I actually bought it before I knew they were not a target of the lily beetle. They have thick shiny leaves and I think this is their advantage. It appears that the beetles tried to eat them and couldn't. There are a few marks on them where they tried, but no holes and they must have given up. They still have all their foliage, no holes and the flowers look like star gazers. I have them in too much shade and they did bloom but they are short and leaning. I plan on getting more. I don't know about fragrance, I will check today.

    I am completely organic and wouldn't be any other way. I actually have not bought any kind of product to use as an insecticide, fungicide etc in 25 years. I am stubborn enough to find another solution. [g] There always is one, even if it means growing something else. So far I have not had to consider getting rid of the lilies.

  • 19 years ago

    I am an organic gardener too. I think Lilies are beautiful but won't use sprays so there has to be another way or the lilies will either be moved to an inconspicuous spot or shovel-pruned.

    Last year I waited too long and there was such an infestation I used the "drown in soapy water" method, picking off 2 or 3 dozen at a time. But this year I was a little more timely and tried something new. In the spring when I noticed the first beetles, I scrounged up some cigarette butts and broke up the remaining tobacco and sprinkled it all over the ground where the lilies grow.

    Maybe it was wishful thinking, but this actually seemed to help keep the beetle populations under control. I had a few of the pests but just squished them. There was only a little damage to the foliage this year.

  • 19 years ago

    Hi terrene..that is an interesting idea. I don't know anyone that smokes so I guess I could buy a pack of cigarettes..lol. I wonder if there are other leaves from the garden that might have the same effect if blended and poured around the lilies?

  • 19 years ago

    Very interesting idea indeed, Terrene! If nicotine has an effect, then I wonder if flowering tobacco, Nicotiana species, will inhibit the beetles. This assumes of course that the beetles/larvae would try to munch on them.

    Has anyone grown Nicotiana near lilies? And seen an effect?

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, I forgot to mention that I just did a search before posting and many Nicotiana species produce nicotine as a defense mechanism.

    Claire

  • 19 years ago

    "Has anybody suffered damage to native lilies such as Turks Cap Lilies?"

    My parents have the old fashioned orange with black spots Turks caps lilies and they have been decimated for many years now, at least 7. They are in the Merrimack Valley in Mass. The Casablancas in the same yard, but a good distance away, seem unaffected. These were planted from bulbs, so no dirt was transferred. Maybe they just haven't found them yet?

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, tobacco can be used successfully as a pest control. If you hunt around enough you'll probably even find a commercial supply of "tobacco dust", which is dried, ground tobacco leaves.

    The only caution I've ever read about this pest control technique is that if the ground leaves are infected with a plant virus and you dust the leaves of your plant, it's possible for the virus particles to infect your plant (if the particles are viable and if your plant is susceptible to that particular virus - tobacco is susceptible to several & I don't know which ones can do this, if any). I read this warning once, but don't remember where, so I can't attest that it's a real concern, although I can imagine it's possible.

    And you're welcome, Debra. :)