Software
Houzz Logo Print
caliloo_gw

For anyone obsessing about nematodes...

18 years ago

I have no personal experience using THIS product, but I have used many other products from this company and been very pleased with the results. It sure sounds a lot less traumatic that bleach, boiling water, etc that is recommended for treating nematodes. The worst that will happen is you have a plant that still has nematodes.

BENEFITS OF CRAB SHELL 2-3-0 Ca23

Neptune's Harvest Organic Crab Shell is an excellent dry organic source of NPK, Calcium (23%) and Magnesium (1.33%). It will also help with nematode and fungus problems. Here's why: Crab Shell is high in Chitin (Kite-en), which promotes the growth of Chitin eating bacteria in the soil.

The exoskeletons of fungus and nematode eggs are high in

chitin. Crab Shell when added to the soil helps to create a hostile environment for the fungus and nematodes by feeding the biological life that eats chitin and chitin based organisms.

Here is a link that might be useful: Neptunes Harvest

Comments (19)

  • 18 years ago

    If I read the ad correctly it has to be mixed with the soil.
    Oh, there's got to be an easier way to get rid of these worms!

  • 18 years ago

    You can just sprinkle it on and water it in.

  • 18 years ago

    I was just wondering if you could just leave the infected hosta in the sun for a few days,roots bare and all?
    Would that help get rid of the little buggers?
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you for posting this link. I always interested in organic ways to treat plants if need be. Most of them stay healthy anyway but sometimes little help needed. Some of my trycirtis developed brown spots on their leaves and I think it might be same nematodes that mark hosta leaves as well. I hate adding any chemicals as my soil is full of worms- years of adding compost to flower beds are paying off...

  • 18 years ago

    Interesting Alexa. I'm going to look for more info on this. I'm thinking its a cure for the root knot nems, not the foliar variety.

    I used the soap concotion last year that I developed and a lot of the infected hostas are nem free this year, but I still have a few that have the tell-tale brown streaks. Life has been sad and tough this year, I haven't had time to garden as much let alone treat for the tiny worms. So, I'm glad they've diminished as much as they have due to my actions last year. I should put on one application before the winter, that may help minimize their spread next year.

    PIM

  • 18 years ago

    I thought this was a good idea too and decided I wanted to use it as a precautionary measure. Called Agway to see if they carried the Neptune line. Stupid question because it did not result in the answer I needed. I made the long trip and they had every product in the Neptune line except the Crab Shells.

    I think I'm going down to the beach. I was there about a week ago and there were lots of tiny crab shells washed up. What if I just plant a dead crab under each hosta....

  • 18 years ago

    I thought the foliar nems overwintered in the root/crown below the soil line? If I am correct, then I would think this would help with them too..... even when the ground is snow covered and frozen, the little bitty guys aer still doing their thing!

    Sorry about the wild goose chase buff - but if you ever have a need for any of the products you know where to find them LOL! And yes, I bet if you wait for the next few hurricanes to go past there will be LOTS of dead crabs on the beach! I would certailny give that FREE option a try too!


    Alexa

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not sure what overwinters is the actual worm or the unhatched eggs.. and I thought I'd do a little Googling to try and find out. It would appear as if the nematodes survive the winter by moving deeper into the soil and live on fungi, only to come back up again in the spring when the soil warms up again. I have linked below to the article in question.

    Nothin' in there about crab shells...

    Here is a link that might be useful: OSU nematode research

  • 18 years ago

    ... and I found a bit more information... see link below...

    Here is a link that might be useful: more Grewal research info

  • 18 years ago

    hope you don't mind my asking this question again?

    What if you dug the hosta up, and left it out in the sun for a week or so, roots exposed and all?Has any one ever tryed this?
    Seems like it Might work--maybe?

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    I ain't no scientist -how do you like my grammar thus far- but it seems to me that when you dig up the plant you haven't done anything about the nematodes in the soil. And they have to be of concern to you as well since they can survive in the soil by living on fungi.

    I must admit to not having given nematodes any thought until I actually got them in a trade last year. I'm glad indeed that I was -and am- pressed for space and I simply potted up the plants I received to grow on and be planted out later. Having them in pots allowed me to focus on dealing just with the worms in the plant tissue and whatever little might have migrated into the planting medium in the pots was removed when I disposed of that in the garbage. With nematodes becoming seemingly a worse curse than HVX it might be good practice to pot up any new Hostas and keep them in relative isolation for at least a year until such time as you are comfortable you didn't get any nasties. You'll see that nematodes need plenty of moisture to survive if you read the article in the last link I posted but I can't help but feel that if you left the plant out long enough for the nematodes to die off due to a lack of moisture you might very well have done the same thing to the plant: it needs that same moisture.

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, i see.

    Tough little buggers are they not?

    Thank you for answering my question.
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Carol, you asked,
    "What if you dug the hosta up, and left it out in the sun for a week or so, roots exposed and all?Has any one ever trid this?"

    I almost forgot all about what happen to me in 2006.

    I had hostas that showed nematode damage that were planted at a campground where we had our camper parked.
    I decided to dig up 5 of the Gold Edgers that
    were affected and take them home to heat treat in a 130 degree water bath.
    Well, I dug the 5 plants up, put them in a black plastic trash bag, put them in my black car and forgot about them for over 2 WEEKS!!!!!!
    (I never put my car in the garage in the summer)
    Those 5 hostas sat in a hot black plastic trash bag, in a hot black car and sat out in the hot August sun for over 2 weeks.
    When I finally discovered them I had very little hope that they'd even survive, but I planted them anyway without doing the water heat treatment.
    Last fall, 2007, one of the 5 plants showed nematode damage.
    I treated it last year with Zerotol and waited.
    This past June I treated it with Merit Granules.
    So far. I've seen no damage on any of the 5 plants.
    The 5 plants are very stunted. All the plants that I've ever heat treated with water have become stunted too.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks sassy,
    I was also wondering if,once you remove the infested hosta fron the planting hole,did the hot water treatment,and potted it up in a new pot,What if,you did not treat the open hole,but you placed a black garbage bag over the hole and left it there for the next summer,would that kill the worms(nematodes)yet,not harm the good guys?

    Very interesting what you did sassy,do you think they will regain their growth?And they are fine this year?

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    "placed a black garbage bag over the hole"

    Google soil solarization. It is used to combat some soil/root dwelling nematodes. The trouble is soil is a good insulator and the solar heat isn't enough to heat the soil very hot or very deep. Like all the other options we have, the population is reduced, but not erradicated.

    Mark Zilis has done some experimenting with this concept by placing "bubbles" over entire plants. The heat just didn't penetrate deep enough into the crown and soil.

    Here is a link that might be useful: soil solarization

  • 18 years ago

    Hummmmmmmmmm,isn't that interesting,but it did say over a 6-8 week period of time it killes the nematodes,using a clear plastic,and reduced the infestation.
    So much to learn,i enjoyed that artical, thank you.
    I also wondered if a really strong garlic soluation would work?
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    PIM,what soap concotion did you use?
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Carol,

    The hosta that were heat treated in 2006 really suffered stunted growth in 2007, but this year they are growing well.

    ~SASSY~

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Sassy,
    So i guess what we all need is a black garbage bag and a car!
    Does it matter what kind of car?lol
    This is way easier that all the other methodes.And you have proved it worked,nice job!

    Carol

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations