Software
Houzz Logo Print
papou_gw

Experts: What is the difference??

19 years ago

I have noticed that while reorganizing one of my beds, I have put Midwest Magic adjacent to September Sun. This was last Autumn. Now just recently, I noticed that both Midwest Magic and September Sun look identical....same size medium hosta..same leaf color and variegation...side by side, they look identical. Is there a difference between these two varieties? I would like to know. Here a pic of each:

{{gwi:1073719}}

Papou

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    Hereafter is a leaf closeup pic of September Sun and Midwest Magic...they look the same to me. How about you?

    {{gwi:1073720}}

    {{gwi:1073721}}

    Thanks for helping me out on this one...

    Papou

  • 19 years ago

    I don't have Midwest magic...but my September Sun looks quite different.


    The big hosta in the back.
    Linda C

  • 19 years ago

    They are very similar. I don't have SS and I just got Midwest Magic this year.
    {{gwi:909117}}

    In checking the Hosta Handbook under Midwest Magic, it does list SS as "other similar types" along with Hoosier Harmony, Paradigm and September Surprise.

    Differences that I noticed in the listing was the vein count 12-13 in MM vs 10-12 in SS with SS leaves being just slightly larger and larger mound size at maturity.

    But very similar in the way of looks. Yours are very nice by the way :-)
    Janet

  • 19 years ago

    I don't have a mature Midwest Magic,so no help there,but my September Sun has a much darker margin this time of year. It is nearly black. I do grow mine in more shade than yours appears to be in,though. Phil

  • 19 years ago

    I'm no expert, but to my eye, Midwest Magic looks glossier and the margin looks more pronounced (darker?) than SS.

    Char

  • 19 years ago

    Char, I took Midwest Magic pic with the morning mist on it. It was early in the morning...the leaf is wet...so this is misleading.

    Papou

  • 19 years ago

    Midwest Magic has different timing in when the variegation shows up. They are very similar but not the same plant. MM is not out of August Moon. You would have to grow them side by side to see the difference. I think in Sept Sun you will see all the leaves on the plant have the color change at about the same time... something is telling me in my head that Midwest Magic has some differences between early leaves and newer leaves showing so that you see a blend of color change from center of the plant to margins of the plant/clump (not center/margin of leaf).

  • 19 years ago

    Is there two MM out there? Mine has lavender/light purple flowers and SS has white.
    Rb

  • 19 years ago

    One thing I can say about Midwest is that it is a terrific grower. I have mine directly under a silver maple and it takes the roots, no problem.

    I have September Sun in a large pot year round and it's starting to peterout after 5 years left alone.

    I agree with Rb, Midwest has the lavender and September the white flowers.

    Deb

  • 19 years ago

    from the hosta library database info

    september sun, a sport of august moon :

    15" tall. Light Shade
    Yellow with dark green margin. Color grows more pronounced later in season. Near. white flowers. Cordage leaves with a yellow center and green margin. Heavily corrugated. White flowers. Fast grower.
    Gold leaf with a lime green margin. Excellent substance.
    This wonderful 3' wide clump (sport of H. 'August Moon') has the same round corrugated golden foliage, but surrounded by a wide dark green margin... one of the finest new hostas in years! In late summer, the 3' spikes of near white flowers top the clump... extremely nice!
    A H. 'August Moon' sport, rounded gold leaves are edged with a wide dark green margin. This one will take a little more sun and has wonderful near-white flowers.
    Green variegated form of 'August Moon'. The leaves are heart-shaped, gold with a wide green margin. Excellent. White flowers.
    Plant is a variegated sport of H. 'August Moon' with yellow center and green margin. There is a high contrast between margin and center. The dimpling on the leaves make for another eye catcher. (Plant 34x22)
    The rounded gold leaves have a wide, dark green margin.
    Large clump topped by near white flowers in July.
    A good grower when given some morning sun.
    The yellow leaves on this beautiful sport of 'August Moon' are edged in dark green. Near-white flowers.
    Green margined, gold centered mutation of August Moon, near white flowers, strong grower.

    midwest magic, a mutation of zounds:

    30" tall. Light Shade.
    Gold center and a green margin. Variegated. Round.
    Slug resistant. Light lavender flowers.
    Here is a new hosta that's going to have everyone talking. H. 'Midwest Magic' (possibly a sport of H. 'Sea Dream') has smooth round leaves of dark gold that lighten as the season progresses. The wide border of very dark green provides the perfect contrast. In early summer, the 30" wide clumps are topped with 30" scapes of light purple flowers.
    A mutation of H. 'Zounds', a gold centered leaf with a deep green margin.
    A sport of 'Zounds' from Q & Z Nursery. The heart-shaped leaves are gold with a green margin. White flowers.
    Irregular green margined leaves has center which turns yellow. The dimpled affect of the leaves almost makes the yellow center irridescent. Leaves are very pointed. (Plant 45x20) Medium, wide gold centered leaves with green edge. Good substance. Pale lavendar flowers in July

    -------->>>>>>

    with such diverse heritage you would think true plants would be quite diverse .... i am still trying to remember to look at mine when i walk out into the oven know as my garden ......ken

  • 19 years ago

    I don't know much about Midwest Magic, although I have a new one. My September Sun is coming along well after several years.

    But I will say this: September Sun is not a medium hosta. It's a very large hosta and a very beautiful hosta. I got mine because I saw a fabulous one growing in the sun at Rice Creek hostas north of the Twin Cities. It was a monster and one of the prettiest hostas I've ever seen. Unfortunately Rice Creek got in the way of some development and has been been demolished. It's somewhere else now, but I assume that September Sun is still putting on a show.