Software
Houzz Logo Print
ilovetogrow

Plugs/liners

When ordering from a grower which is the best way to buy? I am a second year grower and have only purchased from local stores so far. I was reading earlier in the year about the liners people were getting and some looked liked awesome deals. Or is going full price for a mature plant better? As I look at the alphabet of hostas my wish list is getting longer and longer and wallet smaller I am wanting to make wiser decisions. I am wondering on how you started yours. I am a patient gardner and will be container growing. Thank you for all your help. Paula=^..^=

Comments (7)

  • 15 years ago

    i tried liners once ... and 90% of them failed .. as i could not give them the TLC that ultra babes needed ...

    these were the 2 inch type ... and i did not have the greenhouse/shadehouse.. watering and fert'ing systems in place to nurture tiny plants ...

    frankly.. they were no bargain ...

    unless you are in the trade.. and want to grow them on for profit .... i dont know why you would mess with them ... [meaning you order 100 of them.. and expect 50% to fail .. but will make it up on markup] ...

    as a relative newbie.. i suggest you stay with the bigger stuff .... not necessarily the local greenhouse stuff.. but not liners and plugs .... look for 2nd or 3 year plants ....

    ken

    ps: here is how it works ...

    if they come out of TC toady ... they will be plugs this winter .. and liners by next spring/summer .... or.. first year plants ...

    once the plug/liner is grown next year.. they would be 2nd year plants the following year ... etc ....

    just let the pro's deal with them .. IMHO ...

  • 15 years ago

    I bought a lot of liners. It is a great way to save a ton of money if you are willing to give them a little extra TLC the first couple of years and you have the patience. I would avoid the slowest growing varieties such as the Toks, Great Expectations and any other super slow growers.

    Getting in on the Secret Swaps is another way to get more but they are usually single eyed divisions.

  • 15 years ago

    It is a great way to save a ton of money if you are willing to give them a little extra TLC the first couple of years

    ==>>> so frank.. lets be a little clearer ....

    you can do it ..

    DO YOU THINK A NEWBIE can do it????

    or would you agree that perhaps a newbie ought to learn more.. before they go into the 'hard' stuff

    thats the premise isnt it???

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    I bought some plugs in my first year and I will not be doing it again. The failure rate is too high, IMO... all to save a few bucks? not worth it, IMO.

    Something else to consider is as a newbie, try to keep your eyes off the newer and more expensive hostas. I managed to put over 400 varieties in my garden without having to mail order... those were all local.

    Also consider, you are in FLORIDA. Hostas need a good cold period to survive the winter. Also, in FL, since you've told us you've had success in the past, we know that hostas do not grow as large as they do up here in the tundra. So, if you start with a (nearly) microscopic hosta, you may be LUCKY to get it to grow to be a 1-gallon equivalent plant after several years.

    So, my vote: Order good size plants from someone in the south! I believe Silvers Ebert is in the south. Not sure if they do mail order or not.

  • 15 years ago

    ken, Oh no! WOULD I WANT TO is the question. I did that with daylilies. Tied me up for a few years with so/so outcome.(Ugly flowers) I am more of a collector. I went outside and got out some of my 2", 3" and about 5" pots. I thought about all these rug rats running around and maybe someday if I get to retire I may give it a go for the heck of it. I started my gardening career (lol) at about 5 with a 'Punch and Grow' cactus garden. Mass growing at a young age.

    I am going for the mature plant. It does fit my needs better. Let them do all the early work and I can reap the benefits. Have a great day everyone! Thanks ken!

  • 15 years ago

    Hi thisismelissa, I am 40 miles from Georgia line so not really in Florida. I get very cold weather from the end of December to the beginning of March. To some degree I winter in Georgia and I summer in Florida. I started with the store plants to see how they would do here. The first one's from Kmart and second years from Lowe's and the famous noids from Walmart. I put some in the ground and some in containers. I will be replanting the ones in the ground back into pots as I could not get them enough water with this beach sand we have here. The size was so much smaller in the ground. I have been a container gardener most of my life.

    I 'ohh and ahh' at the northern grown plants but look at those surviving in NC heat right now. I am planing on posting my 'wish list' to get comment on my choices. I leave the expensive high maintenance girls to those who can afford them. I wish to look into a healthy group of plant with minimal upkeep but total joy. Yea I am dreaming . LOL. Now I have to go and water. Paula

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with Ken, liners are a lot of pain. For more certainty that you will only have to wait 3 or so years to get a good size plant buy plants with large leaves and several eyes, in a pot or bare-root. Do not buy from general type nurseries via mail, they might ship one year plants, a slug might eat it in one evening and you will have to wait many years to come a little closer to maturity. I have some plants sitting around, supposedly to become over 30 inches tall, are still only 6 inches after 2 years. I am growing hostas for 20 years.
    Good luck!
    Bernd

Sponsored
The Steele Group
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars1 Review
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio