Software
Houzz Logo Print
thelma662

suggestions regarding my order list

18 years ago

Plan to order from Jim's. These are the ones I'm considering. Help me? Need small blue that stays blue.

1. Savannah Supreme 10. Green Eyes

2. Flambuoyant 11. Fantasy Island

3. Warwick Sheen

4. Mont. Aureomarginata

5. Touch of Class(I have June)

6. Frosted Mouse Ears or Holy Mouse Ears(which one?)

7. High Society

8. Liberty

9. Linda Sue

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago

    Nice list, I wonder about streaked plants unless you want to hybridize. Green Eyes a gift to me from Herb Benedict that is very nice and very small. Don't you NEED frosted and holy?

    I don't have Linda Sue but some have raved!

  • 18 years ago

    Hadspen Blue is a nice blue that stays blue in the shade.
    Mouse Ears - both are neat. Haven't had them long enough to say one is better than the other. have a couple of subs in mind in case something is sold out. He'll email you before shipping if something is sold out.
    Pam

  • 18 years ago

    blue jay is a nice blue

    flamboyant is not the best seed producer if you want seeds ...

    sav sup is fragrant[i think]... MAYBe your z7 will give you enough time to get ripe seeds .... plantiginea.. blooming now.. usually get frosted dead, before the requisite 90 days to ripen ...

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    EO,
    Why do you wonder about streaky hosta?Are they hard to grow?
    More info. please.
    Thanks,
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    streakers are usually double.. triple.. quadruple the cost ....

    streaked mothers.. give streaked seedlings.. which lead to new hosta .... versus plain old green ... if you grow seeds ...

    if you have no interest in seed growing ... you really have no need for a streaker.. if budget is an issue ..

    unless you just like the weird look.. which i do ..

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    Savannah Supreme is Fragrant, I have Savannah (white edge). Not fertile unless you get extremely lucky.

    Good small blues are Blue Ice, Blue Moon, Blue Chip, Dorset Blue.

    If you just want fine streaks, but not for breeding, you could get at a reasonable price Ani Machi (Geisha), or Inaho(Kisuji). Korean Snow is streaked, and is fertile.
    Spilt Milk is sort of streaky.
    Coarser Streaking is usually expensive, although Savannah Supreme is not bad.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you Ken and Dave,

    It is on my list to get a few more streaky ones,only ones i have so far are,Charlettes Web,Athena,Monty Python and Cajun Sunrise.

    Would you plant these all close together?I do not know a thing about Hybridizing(spelling?)but, i may study up on it for next year,just want to be prepaired.

    Any advise you can offer me will be greatly appreciated.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Carol,I have Korean Snow,and it usually looks best in early spring. Later on,it turns more solid green,but always comes up streaky in the spring. I already have several seedlings from it,and some of them appear streaky. We'll see next spring. A pic from when it was planted in 2006. Phil

    {{gwi:943897}}

  • 18 years ago

    EO,
    Why do you wonder about streaky hosta?Are they hard to grow?
    More info. please.
    Thanks,
    Carol

    I'm not so wild about streaked plants simply from appearance point of view, my opinion doesn't matter. LOL

    Often streaked plants are expensive, the question is what do you want. Many streaky plants grow like weeds, not as large as all green or blue but that is not a reason to avoid.

    Now, if you want to hybridize then you want streaky plants.

  • 18 years ago

    "Would you plant these all close together?"
    Carol

    EASY HYBRIDIZING
    One of the brightest hosta people ever and a mentor of mine, Jim Hawes, did no intentional crosses but did plant many streaky plants in a group and selected the seedlings that appeared.

  • 18 years ago

    Thelma,
    Touch of Class is a beautiful hosta! High Society, new to me this spring, is also really nice. Both of them, like June, are bluish in color. Liberty is also a gorgeous hosta though I don't think of it or any of the rest of the list as being blue. I have both Frosted and Holy Mouse Ears (new this year) and they are cute as can be! (sturdy little things as well)
    I have had Savannah Supreme for a few years and it is a great grower. So far it has kept its streaky coloring and I have not had to divide it. Montana Aureomarginata is a really nice hosta, though thinner substance and more apt to be a meal for the slugs in my garden.Fantasy Island is another with thin substance, but a nice little hosta.
    I do not have Flamboyant, but the description sounds like it needs to be divided often to keep the streaking. And like others have mentioned, there are better plants for seedlings if that was your thought.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks EO and Phil,

    I did buy a few more today(streakers),i am getting interseted in hybridizing,gotta keep my mind busy.

    Good luck Phil with your seedlings.Maybe next year you can post a picture?eh

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Carol
    I sent you an email
    Pam

  • 18 years ago

    Well, you are already buying some expensive streakers, those are good ones.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Pam for the info.
    Much to learn for sure. :0)

    Dr Dave,
    Do you hybridize?What streakers do you have?I also just bought,H.'Pony Tail'
    H'.Rotini and'
    H.'Topo Gigio'
    My plan is to just get them planted this year and see what happens next year,while i study up on the subject,they have already flowered,so i don't expect any thing for next year.
    What do you do?

    Wanna see some pictures?
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Where are you finding all these cool streakers at this time of year?
    Pam

  • 18 years ago

    Yes I hybridize and grow from seed since about 2003. Being pretty frugal, I didn't buy any streaked plants for about 4 or years into my hybridizing.
    I found you can get really cool solid plants. About 3 years ago I got some seed from streaked plants from friends, and most of my breeding with streaks is using those seedlings or seedlings from those seedlings. The ones I have best luck with are seedlings from Neat Splash, Whoopee, Splish Splash, Galaxy, Christmas Tree Gala, and William Lachman. (NOT the original plants, but their offspring).
    I have Neat Splash which is very fertile, but not great substance. I got a gift from a garden visitor in 2005 Yellow Splash but it has never flowered. It should be as fertile as Neat Splash. I got Korean Snow a few years ago, it is very fertile but not consistent with passing on streaking, and the seedlings all look just like it, which is not my goal. I got Ice Age Trail but it died before I ever got seed.

    Many seedlings are not fertile, have lousy substance, or lose their streaking, but I have about 10 good streaked breeders now, out of maybe 40 or 50 plants that I grew. By good, I mean they are fertile.
    Thanks to Ken I have Breeder's Choice, Sally and Bob, Diane Gray Dalton but none have flowered yet for me to use.
    I bought Splish Splash but it is not very fertile for me this season (my first) compared to the seedling of Splish Splash that has taken just about everything I have pollinated it with.
    Christmas Tree Gala, I split to get nice streaking but then it did not flower this year!

    So in summary, my best plants are not streaked, but solid. Cool colors size, shape or fragrance.
    The streakers are confusing to my eye, and make it hard to see unique character. My approach is to develop cool forms, and then try to cross that pollen onto streakers to get the variegation with my good form.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,i only understood about half of what you just said,but i find it sooooo interesting,i wish i was younger,and more educated, :0)
    I wonder,can a person learn all this with out a collage eduction?,or does one HAVE to study biology first?
    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    1. Savannah Supreme -- good grower, not a good parent, doesn't require division as often as other streakers
    2. Flambuoyant -- don't have
    3. Warwick Sheen -- don't have
    4. Mont. Aureomarginata -- don't have, but this one is a classic
    5. Touch of Class(I have June) -- one of the must have hostas (I have June too)
    6. Frosted Mouse Ears or Holy Mouse Ears(which one?) -- don't have either so I can't help
    7. High Society -- always liked this one but never got around to getting it
    8. Liberty -- must have -- one of my favourties
    9. Linda Sue -- don't have

    1. Green Eyes -- killed this one twice
    2. Island Fantasy -- must have -- much better than Island Charm

    Carol -- you don't need to have a graduate degree in botany to be a good hybridizer. You need to read alot, get info from other hybridizers, and be able to analyze the results of your hybridizing efforts. Hybridizing is a lot of trial and error. If you can learn from other hybridizers, you will be ahead of the game. The other thing I've learned is that you should be hybridizing with what you consider the best plants.

  • 18 years ago

    Hybridizing is something I love to talk about, so if you want to take any of my post and divide it up into digestable parts, I'll be happy to respond.
    There are a lot of hybridizers here who can contribute.

    Maureen is right, you just have to have good observational skills and have an idea what you could get by crossing two cool plants. You want the best features from each parent.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Maureen is right, you just have to have good observational skills and have an idea what you could get by crossing two cool plants. You want the best features from each parent.
    Dave

    What Dave says is true, BIG AND you can just make crosses and see what you get. It is simply fun how ever you do it.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert