Software
Houzz Logo Print
garlicgrower

You experience with campanulas?

20 years ago

Hello Folks:

I picked up a Campanula "Bowl of Cherries" and am wondering if any of you have experience with this particular cultivar.

What is your experience with Campanulas in general?

I've tried a few off and on over the years and they seem not to like any of the locations on my property that I have chosen....and I've tried all variations of sun, semi shade, loamy, gravelly, dry, moist, etc.

Any suggestions on what type of location to plunk this one down in?

(I picked it out of the benefit sale I was working at so I know it's local, grown just a fewmiles from my own house.)

Thanks for any input you can offer

Cheers

Maryanne in WMass

Comments (12)

  • 20 years ago

    I made the mistake of planting Campanula "Cherry Bells" in my garden, in part shade and pretty dry soil full of rocks and roots (fierce competition from a Norway maple and a burning bush). It spread EVERYWHERE!! Now I'm trying to rip it all out, but in the end will probably resort to Round-Up. It was absolutely taking over this small bed, despite the fact that it didn't even bloom especially well for me. Never again...

  • 20 years ago

    I planted "White Chip" and it is everywhere - the garden, lawn, woods,... It spreads by runners and is easy to pull but it speads faster than I can keep up with it. Save yourself, plant it in a pot to contain it.

  • 20 years ago

    I have several varieties in my garden, and so far, in their third year, they are very well behaved. Garden is in full sun with sandy soil that dries out quickly, so that might help contain them. In fact, I lost a few in the first planting. Also, they are competing with plants like coreopsis and rudbeckia, which spread a lot, too. I really like campanulas, because they provide some height, nice blue color (especially against the yellows and oranges/reds of the coreopsis and rudbeckia) and rebloom.

    narcnh

  • 20 years ago

    I love blue chip campanula. My experience is odd I think. For some reason, it would be going great for a few years and then fail to come back. This of course ruined the look of the border of my garden. I have no idea what kept getting to it year after year but when I tried a different variety at our new house, the same thing happened. However the taller bellflowers did well for me. 8 years later, they're still blooming in my former garden.

  • 20 years ago

    I love the look of campanula - have tried clustered bellflowers, blue chips, peach-leaved bellflowers to name only a few and they don't come back the next year. It's as if their roots have disintegrated. It's frustrating!
    I read somewhere that the campanula family like soil more on the neutral to slightly alkaline side and I know I have acidic soil, even after trying to adjust it with lime, it always reverts to the acidic. Do roots actually disintegrate because of acidy soil? I had thought of potting some campanulas in containers just to have them in the garden and then putting the containers in the ground when time to overwinter.

  • 20 years ago

    Just a thought; From my experinece, and that of people I know, campanula are voles' FAVORITE THINGS. It's like a hot fudge sundae to them and if there is even one vole wandering about he or she will eat the roots of your campanula. Even if nothing else is gone in your garden, it seems that they will take campanula. Unless you have callirhoe (prairie wine cups, poppy mallow) then they will eat that first...it's like creme brulee. Echinacea and rudbeckia come in third, they must be like delicious cookies.

    Could be something else, of course.

    Patty

  • 20 years ago

    Patty's experience seems to agree with mine. I have voles by the gazillions since we no longer have a cat. I find the campanulas' roots get eaten and they rarely last more than a few seasons unless I plant in a rock wall. If I plant in a wall, they seem to do well and will spread slowly, but not invasively. I do love them, though in the past have planted a few that I regretted due to their tendancy to seed prolifically. I didn't buy 'cherry bells' because I read here on gardenweb that they were one of the invasively seeding varieties. You could try planting it where it is surrounded by pavement (like in a small dooryard garden) to hopefully contain its seeding tendencies.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks Folks:
    That's quite a range of opinion and experience there.
    Well, I'll pick a spot and plunk it in.
    Perhaps I'll be able to report next year on the outcome.
    This "Bowl of cherries" cultivar is quite a pricey thing on some of the websites I checked.

    Wish me luck

    Maryanne in WMass

  • 20 years ago

    This "Bowl of Cherries" seems to be different from "Cherry Bells". I had been looking at the "Cherry Bells" in the Bluestone catalog.

    Claire

    Here is a link that might be useful: Campanula Bowl of Cherries

  • 20 years ago

    Campanula glomerata has very fleet feet! Give it an inch and be prepared to suffer the consequences. Now, that said, I think it is a wonderfully useful plant... but you have to site it appropriately. Give it a place you need "filled in" and make sure it can't infiltrate more sedate plantings. This is a wonderful plant!!! in flower it is truly magnificent; it's foliage is nice and it makes no demands. GOOD FILLER. But don't put it in a more defined, constrained setting because it's too rank and "contained" isn't the character that best suits this plant, or will agree with the gardener (trust me on this). Looks great with Hostas and Hemerocallis in a more remote, "wild" setting. Treat it the same way you might treat Monarda. "Mass" it.

    I am only now beginning to understand the "peach leaved" variety. Which grow like gang-busters in my garden, too! It is more controllable, though. Totally cool plant, THUSFAR (lol).

    When the most elderly cat and her now deceased brother were on the wane, voles ate the Campnula carpatica. Its loss saddened me, but I've not replaced it; in spite of 3 "new" rodent control units (nearly 3 yrs. old now). Perhaps I ought to reconsider...

  • 20 years ago

    I don't know what to think, but this year persicofolia sprouted out of nowhere from the base of the phlox about 30-35 feet from the place where all my persicofolias grow.
    I don't have a heart to kill it now, but in a fall will attempt to transplant it where it belongs.

  • 20 years ago

    I livin norther california (in an area that get really hotin the summer 100+). Two questions:

    1. do you think that campanula latifolia would grow well for me?

    2. do you think it will be agressive in my garden (that's what I want).

    3. we have voles. do you think they'll eat it up?

    Thanx,

    joyce