Software
Houzz Logo Print
narcnh

Assessing the Damage

20 years ago

After all the rain and with the warm weather now here, I did a survey of my gardens. Even though it wasnÂt a harsh winter with respect to temperature, as we all have noted, it was a tough one in the sense that there was little snow cover, at least up here, and a lot of freeze-thaws. I lost a number of plants, some of which surprised me. A partial list:

Most of my basic coreopsis. I thought these were indestructible. A couple of clumps have small patches of survivors, but most were a complete loss. The exceptions were a couple of small Coreopsis Domino that somehow made it. I have more coming.

All of my artemisia  Powis Castle, David Choice and Silver Mound. The PCÂs were quite large and were real focal points in the garden last year. I put in three silver mounds this spring, but I think I am giving up on perennial Artemisia here. Oddly enough, they did great at my old place in Zone 4.

Most of my foxglove, just a couple of survivors. I have more on the way.

Most of my delphiniums.

Several hollyhocks, another plant I thought was pretty much indestructible. More on the way.

Several salvia, another tough plant I thought would do better.

Several coneflowers. These were getting squeezed by the coreopsis last year, so might have been stressed. More on the way.

Survivors that surprised me:

All my Munstead lavender. Some lost a lot of branches, but they are filling in.

Two smoke bushes. These were naked sticks that I planted last summer and which I was sure were goners. One has new shoots on the stem and one is coming up from the root.

All seven of my fancy peonies. These were planted two summers ago and two already have buds. I thought they took several years to bloom. One I accidentally stepped on last summer and I assumed was dead, since nothing came back up. This year it has one tiny stem with one leaf about one inch above the mulch. Go figure.

An anise hyssop that I was sure bit the dust. It looks great.

Plants that seemed to weather the winter well:

Rudbeckia  an enormous number of what I assume are seedlings.

Campanula, several varieties

Gaillardia  several varieties

Veronica  several varieties

Platycodon  they look like asparagus coming up

Sea Thrifts  some lost a lot of leaves, but they are coming back

Scabiosa

Helenium

Phlox  creeping and tall summer. These seem to be impervious to everything short of a direct nuclear hit.

Hostas  same as phlox

With the exception of one buddleia, all the shrubs in and around the garden survived: spirea, azaleas  evergreen and deciduous, rhodies, variegated willow, rose of Sharon, etc.

With each passing year I hone my selection, planting more varieties of the survivors and passing on anything that looks at all marginal. In 50 or 60 years I should have it all figured out.

How did everyone elseÂs plants fair?

narcnh

Comments (10)

  • 20 years ago

    It really was surprising, what survived and what failed, here in one 6 (now officially zone 7!).

    Did unexpectedly well: crape myrtle, franklinia, some tender salvia (have to wait til they bloom to find out who they are), carolina jessamine, ... I'm sure the list goes on.

    Bit the dust: 3- or 4-year-old agastache rupestris (apache sunset?), many old common thyme, some very low-growing glossy thyme, reliable old tunica (though it threw a nice number of seedlings), a half dozen or more mature lavenders of all types.

    >With each passing year I hone my selection, planting more varieties of the survivors and passing on anything that looks at all marginal.

    My first thought was, wow, that's not the way my mind works! If something I really like dies, I buy twice as much of it and give it another go. Then, I re-read your list of losses, and I see that you're replacing 3 out of 5 of them.

    Tsk, tsk, narcnh! At this rate it will take more than 50 or 60 years to get there. I'm happy to see that you are just as incorrigible as the rest of us.

  • 20 years ago

    I'm surprised at the Artemisia losses. I grow several Artemisias and they all come back reliably year after year. Coreopsis I have given up on.. I think a common yellow would do okay, but I had some fancy ones that lasted only the one season. I surprisingly lost a hardy Geranium 'Splish Splash'. Also a miniature Aruncus I was sorry to NOT see. Erodium chysanthum bit the dust, but it rarely lives more than 4 years here. I love it and it is not easily replaced. Some of my evergreen daylilies struggled to come back. They had mushy crowns from the lousy weather over winter. I used to poo poo the theory of evergreens not doing so well in the North, but my concepts are evolving. What else? Japanese primrose does not seem to like my garden. Some things I planted way late in the season didn't come back, but I don't think it would be fair to list them as I didn't give them a fair shake. I've yet to see my perennial hibiscus (H. moscheutos), but I've heard it is late to show. How late is late? I got 3 last year. Also lost a Linum. Veronicas and Salvias did fine. Almost lost one hosta because somebody chewed most of the roots off. I put it in intensive care and it looks to be recouping.

  • 20 years ago

    DITD: My variation on an old phrase: 'Do I do as I say, or say not what I do?' Or something like that.

    I guess I should have qualified my statement, but my posts are too long as it is.

    For the most part the ones I'm replacing were either surprise kills, like the echinacea, that I was already planning to increase with new varieties (this year Magnus and Rubinstern) or kills that I thought were atypical, like the coreopsis, (and I really wanted to try some other varieties than the plain old standard, anyway). Foxglove and hollyhocks have always done well for me, so I put them in the Âatypical death category. Foxgloves were about a 75% kill, hollyhocks about 30%, so not a total loss. For the silver mound I have no excuse other than stupidity. I actually knew it was a dumb idea, when I placed the order. At the time I had not idea that the Powis Castles had all died. They were pretty impressive last year. Had I known that, I probably would have nixed them. Another group that got virtually wiped out was my dianthus, except for Siberian Blue, which is very hardy. Of course, I ordered three more (Desmond) earlier this year, before I knew they didnÂt make it.

    By the way, in another post I commented on my herbal losses, too, especially the thymes, which took a terrible hit. The good news is they are coming back.

    Gata: I donÂt know why my luck is running so bad with artemisia. I really like them, but they just donÂt do well here. I was really bummed about the Powis Castle. They were two years old and really well established. Ah well.


    HereÂs a question, do plants that survive by throwing lots of seedlings, like foxglove and coreopsis, have a tougher time in a mulched garden? Do the seedlings have a tougher time getting started? If crabgrass is any example, I guess the answer is ÂNo.Â

    Well, I am off on another week-long road trip tomorrow, this time to Israel. Have fun yaÂll.

    narcnh

  • 20 years ago

    My sympathies, narcnh. That is quite a bit of losses for such a mild winter. I remember worrying over the fact that we had no snow cover, but it never got quite that cold enough to do damage (so I thought).

    I think in a winter with no snow cover, a lot of the shallow-rooted plants take a hit. The thymes, coreopsis, artemesia--2 years ago in that very cold, snowless winter, many people around here lost their Shasta daisies of all things.

    I lost a lot of my thyme. Some of it looks 95% dead with just a sprig or two greened up. Other than that, everything else seems to have made it, except my biggest disappointment--a caryopteris. I'm really surprised. I bought it at the end of season last year during a sale. This was going to go in yet-to-be-constructed rose garden, so I buried the pot in a protected place to overwinter it. I keep looking for signs of life, but it's dead.

  • 20 years ago

    I was shocked to lose both the Eupatorium coelestinum (Hardy Ageratum - not!) that I planted last year. They are hardy to zone 5 which confirms my suspicions that we are more of a zone 4 here.

    Also lost a Gaura, plus all the Mexican Hats I planted last year. Also all but one of the Coreopsis I grew from seed.

    Everything else came up fine though - and I planted a lot last year!!

    Every spring is a big mystery here - seeing what makes it and what does not..

  • 20 years ago

    I don't find Artemisias particularly easy, either, and I'm in a zone 6. I think they are very tough plants but I think they prefer a drier environment that I can offer them. I lost a Powis Castle the first year, too. I planted it in full sun, in the leanest, best drained soil I have... but freeze/thaw and winter rains "cooked its goose". I had Siver King for several years, too. But the soil was too rich, the site not sunny enough, and it flopped (as well as "ran") and I yanked it out, replacing it with Vinca minor. I persist on keeping Stelleriana, because I love the color, shape, and creeping character. But I struggle with it.

    Peonies laugh at the cold, and as long as the soil is reasonably well drained they will grow anywhere. Fabulous plants and EASY, they only get better with age!

    I'm surprised by the loss of Echinacea, though. They are natives of the prairies (where weather is variable and life can be tough). Mine do best in sites where the soil isn't that great; they came from friends who ran a nursery in zone 4 for many years.

    I lost my Foxgloves, too. Don't "do" Alcea (the "rust" ruins the show for me), Delphiniums, Salvia (don't have the sun and soil for it).

  • 20 years ago

    I didn't really lose anything this particular winter. As a matter of fact, I think my only losses were 2 or 3 pots of things that overwintered in the garage (out of about 280 pots). Oh, and about 5 roses (also in the garage).

    I also had several annuals overwinter *outside*. I've got salvia Victoria coming up all over two beds, and I know it overwintered (as opposed to seeding) because the original stems from last years plants are still there.

    My problem time was last summer. It was extremely dry here, and I lost a forty foot long, five foot high slope of creeping phlox. Only two plants left. I also lost lamium, sweet woodruff, and other stuff last summer.

    I'm actually kind of surprised that I didn't lose anything this winter. In previous winters I've lost gaura, perovskia, and I've been know to lose rudbeckia - several times - and other "indestructible" no-brainer plants. Go figure.

    Sorry for everyone's losses. I know how disappointing that can be.

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    I lost two azalea bushes to a fungus. My woodruff isn't doing that well either, but it could be dieback from last summer. A couple years ago I lost tons of stuff, no snow and cold. Lavender doesn't seem to last through the winter either. You notice the stuff you lost as in Dee's case where you had a blanket of phlox, then there is just a few plants left. One year I lost many mum plants that were here when I bought this house. The plants formed a big mass. It was hard to fill in the holes. Then of course there are always those aggressive types that take over such as my Lily of the Valley that was also a plant that was already here. I just pull it up or dig it out to plant something in its place.

  • 20 years ago

    Most of my losses where herbs. The crazy parsley that my kids gave me for mothers day in 1995 and came back every year is a no show for the first time. Of course I didn't save any seeds from it last year. My thyme, oregano, tarragon, also bit the dust. But then again that section of the yard was a swimming pool with 9 1/2 inches of rain on it and geese having a good time. (first time I've ever had that happen in 26 years). Also lost a dwarf coreopsis that I've had for 10 years and my blue boy rose bush looks pretty sick with just one stem. Also lost my clematis duchess of edinburg, that one hurts as have had it a long time. Funny too, cause the sickly clematis firworks made it through the winter and is growing slowly, but quite nicely. Hope it blooms for the first time this year.
    My major damage was to my WS seedlings. All that water has bred lots of slugs. For some reason they are hitting all my zinnias and dahlias, leaving me just a few to hope for but not touching any of the several hundred other seedlings I WS. Finding lots of those nasty things as I pick up containers, nothing else being touched by the slugs, even the hostas and i'm not finding slimy stuff on the plants, but their telltale damage is seen.
    On the survival side, the one thing beside the weeds, especially dandilions, which sure look healthy this spring,
    that not only survived but looks wonderful are the burning bush that hubby and I cut down to the ground early last spring. Those things just won't stop regrowing. We got so desperate that we used the real strong roundup on them and they still keep regrowing. Now I have tons of really healthy looking seedlings growing all around where the 5 original ones where. Have sprayed them all again and they still look really healthy.
    Narcnh, seeds need to make contact with soil to be able to germinate. I have mulch all around all of my plants and in all of my beds. Have never had a plant reseed, even cosmos and morning glory because of the mulch.

  • 20 years ago

    My gardens are in the front of the house, the only part of the yard that gets full sun, but where they are exposed to brutal winter winds. I have to be careful about making sure things are hardy, and I mulched the tender perennials ( like butterfly bush) pretty heavily over the winter.

    This winter wasn't too bad - the Coreopsis Early Sunrise I planted two years ago only had a couple little straggly shoots come back in one spot, but it did that the year before too. I thought Coreopsis was supposed to be hardy to zone 4??

    My creeping thyme also suffered a lot of dieback, with only a few shoots coming up around the edge. I think I am going to dig most of it out.

    I also lost one Penstemon and one liatris.

    But on a happy note, the two Black Knight butterfly bushes (planted last spring) are sending up all kinds of shoots, even the one I moved. The Pink Delight was almost killed the winter before, and it is still hanging on, kinda pathetic. I am thinking of replacing it, but I keep hoping it will take off.