Software
Houzz Logo Print
harlgr8dane

timing for dividing

19 years ago

Even with the mild "fall" we are having, I'm assuming it is too late to divide hostas? Right?

Also in general is it preferred to divide in the spring or the fall?

Thanks!

Comments (12)

  • 19 years ago

    in my z5 ... i completed all digging about 9/15 ....

    i would not divide into small pieces at this time ... due to winter heave .... unless you take full precaution for such... as in deep mulch ...

    hosta can be divided all spring and summer ...

    IMHO .. its too late .... but they are hosta.. and i am sure someone is still doing it...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    I divided and moved about 8 hostas this time last year and they did great...

  • 19 years ago

    z7 isn't z5 ,,,

    bottom line ... hosta come up on energy stored in the crown and the roots. ... hosta grow roots in July ...

    divide in spring .... and they will do fine.. and grow new roots for the following year ... that is why a lot of sellers divide in June ...

    divide now.. and you can interrupt the cycle .. IMHO ...

    its too late for z5 ...

    but they are hosta... and they probably don't care.. presuming they dont heave out of the ground for lack of roots holding them in ....ken

  • 19 years ago

    I've divided and moved hosta 12 months of the year but I would advise the middle of winter or the middle of summer. It is true that they come up from energy stored in the roots so a dormant hosta has everything it needs in the roots.

    Ken is dead right about heave, which can be eliminated with mulch then comes the spring freeze/thaw problem that is also fixed with mulch. Dividing in summer then they need water period but particularly before they have established themselves in the soil and can in fact take up water from the soil. Freshly planted hosta in spring or summer may be in moist soil but cannot access the moisture.

    No water in the fall or winter and lots of water in spring and summer with newly planted or divided plants.

    Don't take the mulch off in the spring until the plants come up and then don't take it off, in fact don't ever take it off.

  • 19 years ago

    oops I would not advise the middle of winter or summer!

    Who's in charge of proof raiding?

  • 19 years ago

    raiding?? lol!!!

  • 19 years ago

    In the Detroit Michigan area, from the 1950's to the 1990's the last date for dividing/planting in Madison Heights was the freeze date. We tried to limit further plantings due to winter heave, although that never killed the small divisions as long as you had some snow cover. I recall whole rows of small roots laying on bare ground when the snow melted - as soon as the ground thawed we replanted with no loss.

    In Delaware we divided and planted up until Thanksgiving, due to later warm ground temps and frost dates.

    In the mountains of far southwestern Virginia where I live today, I just finished my last dividing and replanting last weekend. The frost date at home is Sept 28 but as of today 10/22/07 still too warm. Rain supposed to be coming today finally.

    I think the condition of the planting beds is critical: good loamy soil with adequate moisture will help the transition even if they are dormant. I have been watering my beds/trees due to the drought; would also recommend watering unitl frost, if still dry.

    The winter heave again can be managed without mulch, if you are diligent in Spring about repositioning the roots and crowns as soon as possible.

    Proof reading - a thing of the past!

  • 19 years ago

    raiding?? lol!!!
    adamink

    Wondered if anyone would get it, of course I'm not sure you count because you assume a twist to anything I writ.

  • 19 years ago

    i am sorry Bruce ... but on my sand.. if it heaves.. its dead.. no available water to save them ... sans snow cover ...

    no water.. winter sun.. winter wind ... equals one dead freeze dried hosta... period

    with 50 or 60 odd years experience.. Bruce is going to get away with a lot of things i probably wont get away with.. let alone what a newbie will get away with ...

    i will stand by my statement.. a newbie should not be dividing now.. unless they are prepared for total failure .... it probably wont happen.. but why risk it.. even if they are hosta ...

    now if we are talking about moving a clump .. or just cutting it in half ... go for it.. if you are going to divide it into 100 single divisions ... don't ...

    Bruce... was Pauline dividing hosta before you were born ... and were you born in the hosta patch... ... lol ...

    take care.. ken

  • 19 years ago

    All that Ken and Bruce says is true but don't discount the value of mulch to protect the plants in winter, spring, summer and guess what else, fall.

  • 19 years ago

    Ken, I understand your comments about sandy soil - reminds me of southern Delaware where Clarence "Beets" Landis and Alex Summers would water every day, especially heavy in the summer and no water would be left in the soil.

    They had to water their hostas so much because of the sand - Alex built a big pond just for watering his garden. Beets pumped from a creek.

    Things you can't do easily anymore, but had to if you wanted to garden in the summer Delaware heat and sandy soil.

    No, my mother started dividing hosta after I was born. Not yet 60 years I might add....

    Comment on mulch: Alex held the view for years (arguing with Pete Ruh and other old hosta hands) that mulch caused more problems than it cured. I know he used it very sparingly, mainly because of southern blight, house fungus attacks (the projectile black fungus) and slugs.

    I don't recall my mother using any mulch as well. We composted leaves to enrich the soil yearly, to hold moisture.

    Winter heave does need some snow cover for wind protection - of course us diehards who daily walk their gardens all winter can't resist re-planting them as they fight their way up out of the soil.

    Bruce

  • 19 years ago

    "Alex held the view for years (arguing with Pete Ruh and other old hosta hands) that mulch caused more problems than it cured. I know he used it very sparingly, mainly because of southern blight, house fungus attacks (the projectile black fungus) and slugs."
    Bruce

    Alex Summers used tree trimmings liberally as mulch and southern blight has no relation to mulch, it is a soil borne fungi. Also slugs are not influenced by mulch in any way, they find some place to go during the day so the only way to effect where they hide during the day would be to have no debri in your garden, IÂve never seen one of those gardens.