Software
Houzz Logo Print
ken_adrian

why did your crosses fail

i don't know... but i would like to discuss the reasons ...

please address the following.. and add your own ....

in other words... you plant scientists .... why do crosses fail ...

would it be true that if the two plants are so genetically different ... that the genetics themselves may defeat the attempt?? in other words... can momma simply reject the daddy pollen????

which would lead to the question of whether you researched the heritage of your cross .. actually thought it all out.. or did you just run around the yard doing whatever struck your whim .... lol .. which is what i probably would do ... lol

if it is too hot for a bee to do his work ... is it possible it is too hot for momma to accept the pollen .... maybe the bee is smarter [or lazier than we think] ....

i am trying to use the simplest words i can .. so novices can understand ... and i am using momma and daddy .. because i would think that genetics is genetics.. and it shouldn't matter if its human or plant .... we all know more than we think .. if we can use words we know.. we wont get lost in the technical jargon ....

ken

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    Heat was my problem. During the hottest days, even the bees couldn't get the pollen to take. I could almost track our temps from either no seed pods on the scape to lots of pods on the scape.

  • 19 years ago

    Ken, I did 592 crosses this year and I taged them and logged all of them so any crosses that didn't take I logged that also. I had around 20% success overall, with some super performers and some low performers,and some complete failures, lots of open pollenated pods, the bees succeded where my efforts failed. but I learned a lot and wrote it down I have had a lot of help from Ron Livingston. and the Boys at Naylor Creek.I'm germinating under lights now and what is coming up is about as successful as my pollination efforts, but I'm seeing some real winners already and some really nice people have sent me some of their hybrid seeds to germinate. I hope I can double my crosses next year. some of my hopeful breeders didn't flower, because they were too young. and I'm increasing my collection to include more parent stock. good luck to everyone else on their hybridizing, Jim King

  • 19 years ago

    Highjack is right on. During the week of our 100 degree plus days, none of my blooms set seeds. The scapes were barren toward the middle.

    Great subject, Ken. Next, you want to delve into why my streakers don't bloom?

  • 19 years ago

    Heat must play a role here. If I can get to the flowers as they open in the early am, even if it is hot, above 87 degrees, they still will take, but not always set seed. It just swells up and then the flower will fall off. I think if it were not for the heat, that those swollen flowers would set seed. Almost any pollen I use early in the late spring, before the humidity sets in will take and produce seed pods. I like using the streaky seedlings that have been growing over winter because they flower very early, and I get a lot of streaked seedlings from my seedlings every year.
    Mary Ann, my named streakers did not flower this year well either. I think it was because they were moved last year, and I am hopeing for some bloom from them next season. If not, I am cutting back tree limbs for more sun. The only streaked seedlings I got were from Liberty Bell, a streaked NOID from Foxwillows, and my streaked seedlings from 05/06 winter seed starting.

  • 19 years ago

    Ken,

    I have a copy of a program that Stephen Zolock gave at a Michigan Hybridizers meeting back in 2003. In the program it talks about crossing a Diploid with a Tetraploid will result in a Triploid (which are sterile). An example of this would be to cross Sum and Substance (Dip) with Niagara Falls (Tet), would result in a Tripoloid. The article goes on to talk about ways of converting Diploid into Tetraploids through the use of chemicals, which from my understanding is how some have crossed Dorothy Benedict with Sum and Substance.

    So to your comment of momma rejecting daddy pollen, in some cases the answer is yes, according to this research.

    BTW I had several people tell me this was one of the most informative programs ever given to the group.

    Regards
    Jerry

  • 19 years ago

    jerry ...

    all i remember about the chemicals converting Diploid into Tetraploids ... is that it can do the same to the applicator ... meaning you .... THEY ARE EXTREMELY DANGEROUS CHEMICALS .... ergo ... i ignored the suggestion that I need to fool with them ....

    maryann .. streakers.. which are moving away from solid green ... are inherently weaker .... ergo ... they take longer to mature .... [which means if you move them they recover slower] and that they probably need more sun to overcome the white tissue [but not too much or they will burn] ... etc ... i really cant say why yours didnt flower this year ...

    ken

  • 19 years ago

    Ken,

    Agreed the chemical to transform from Di to Tet are some nasty stuff. I'll never use them, but some have, with the desired effect.