Software
Houzz Logo Print
kmgard_gw

Do I Need To Cut This Tree Down?

13 years ago

Hey there,

My husband and I know virtually nothing about landscaping, and we inherited everything we have from the previous owners. Everything has basically taken care of itself over the last six years, but now we're getting ready to sell the house and plants are dying. We've pulled out several bushes over the last year, and all of a sudden (within about two weeks), this tree started losing all of its leaves. It's never been the healthiest tree even though we keep clipping back those vines, but this is the worst it's ever looked. It's leaves are covered in these crazy spots, and I'm really worried this is something that could spread to the rest of the yard. Please ignore the state of our house in the photos (it was about to be pressure washed), and please help! Thanks!

Comments (11)

  • 13 years ago

    Leaf close-up photo

  • 13 years ago

    where are you???

    i am not great on ID.. but wonder is this is fire blight on crabapple ... [it has other names also] ...

    since leaves would fall off soon anyway .... there is nothing to do..

    but in fairness to new owner... get rid of it .... obviously its a susceptible variety ....

    ken

  • 13 years ago

    I'm in Sanford, North Carolina. As you can tell by the surrounding trees, we still have some time here before leaves start falling! I can cut it, but I'd hate to if that's not what the problem is...

  • 13 years ago

    if it is a leaf disease...

    and the tree has no leaves.. then what exactly can be recommended to get rid of a leaf disease ...

    i will bet.. within a week.. you will have a leafless tree ... [which you basically have right now]

    regardless.. i didnt expect you to run out there and chainsaw it.. lets see if i am confirmed.. or denied ...

    ken

  • 13 years ago

    The saying is...spots and dots, it's fungus you gots. Trees can usually recover from losing their leaves this late in the season. The time to spray fungicides is next spring and that is probably not necessary anyway. Some years are worse than others. I would just leave it alone.

  • 13 years ago

    Totally agree with kimpa......
    Trees are very tolerant and survive seasonal leaf fungus attacks

  • 13 years ago

    Ok, GREAT! With the dying bushes and now this, I was terrified it was some disease that was killing all of our landscaping. But it's sounding like this tree is an isolated situation from the bushes. Thanks so much! I'll let it go and hope it doesn't scare off potential buyers. I really do think it's a beautiful tree, even if it's been kind of sickly over the years. :)

  • 13 years ago

    Looking at the crotch of that tree would be enough to make me want to take it down. It's bound to split and come down on its own, either from wind or winter weather. I also don't think it looks anything like a crabapple.The disease is definitely fungal, but it might not be the primary disease. In any case, it will be a high maintenance tree if you keep it.

  • 13 years ago

    I also agree with kimpa; it looks like a fungus of some sort. It looks like blackspot ... is that a hawthorn tree perhaps? (Hawthorn is in the rose family).

    Many plant disease are pretty species-specific, so not likely to take out an entire landscape ... unless everything therein is of the same species. That's one reason why diversity of plantings, vs. a monoculture, is a good idea.

  • 13 years ago

    If the crotch of the tree is more "U" shaped, then no problem of it splitting in a wind....if "V" shaped, it may be a problem, but I wouldn't jump at cutting it down.....thousands of trees have V crotches with no problems................

  • 13 years ago

    I would suggest you remove the vine before it chokes the tree.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting