Software
Houzz Logo Print
kathi_rogers

Any OK wintersowers?

17 years ago

I am new to Oklahoma and hope my GA gardening techniques have not killed the gardens I put in this year - Thanks for all the great tips here - especially the one about watering in the winter!

Anyway,I want to know if anyone wintersows and what is the best time to do it here? I am planning on the week after Christmas but wanted to check first.

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Welcome to Oklahoma, Kathi.

    I don't post often on the OK forum (I'm always on the BF forum), but I read the posts. I have started my WSing already. But, anytime between now and mid January is probably a good time. I think a lot depends on how long the seeds need to be exposed to the cold for germination.

    There are some very knowledgable people on here and I've learned a lot as a "lurker."

    Sandy

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am also new to wintersowing, but plan to do a lot this winter. I plan to start in early January, but it will probably take me awhile to get it all done.

    There are at least three others that read this forum that I know wintersow and are good at it. I am sure I will be contacting them for advice.

    I will mostly be doing flowers using the wintersowing method, but thought I might also try a few really cold hardy veggies.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm a long time winter sower. The week after Christmas would probably be fine for really early things or seeds that need a long time. We get really odd weather, up and down, until January. Honestly I never start before February...but that has more to do with my procrastination :)

    Lisa

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Kathi,
    I'm a winter sower located not too far from you. December, January and February are fine for almost everything cold hardy. March and April still work well for seeds requiring little or no stratificiation. After April 15 is better for tender annuals. I use Tom Clothier's germination database and the T&M website to determine if anything needs an extra long period of cold.

    I believe the Clothier website was originally designed to help greenhouse people create the proper germination conditions in the off season. Greenhouse people need to force blooms at odd times to improve sales.

    I use the database as a thumbnail gauge to determine the range of earliest to latest in planting seeds. For example, the entry for Asclepias exaltata is as follows: "Asclepias exaltata , incarnata, and tuberosa, Sow at -4 to +4C (24-39ºF) for 4 wks in moistened sand, move to 20ºC (68ºF) for germination" I would therefore make it a point to sow no later than mid February, to ensure that it got 4 weeks of 24-39. I would also feel just fine sowing it in December, knowing it would get the minimum 4 weeks of cold stratification and would do just fine sitting and waiting all winter for 68.

    The entry for Aquilegia atrata, on the other hand, says "Sow at 18-22ºC (64-71ºF) for 2-4 wks, move to -4 to +4ºC (24-39ºF) for 4-6 wks, move to 5-12ºC (41-53ºF) for germination " That tells me I should sow it in the fall when I can get that initial exposure to 64-71, leave it out all winter, then let it warm up naturally to 41-53.

    Most of all, don't let these guidelines make it complicated. Use them as a thumbnail approach to coordinate with nature. They help you know if it's too late to get enough stratification, or if you even need it at all.

    Generally speaking, if you sow anytime after 12/21 you will dodge unseasonably premature warm spells. (She said, remembering Christmas Day 1993 when she washed her car in the driveway in 78 degree weather!)

    The Thompson & Morgan website gives product specific germination info as well. tmseeds.com Again, I use it to coincide with nature.

    Enjoy your time sowing! And welcome to Oklahoma!

    Seedmama

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I want to learn more about winter sowing vegetables. If anyone knows about that, please post for those of us interested.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Good morning mulberryknob! I'd invite you to read the FAQs in the wintersowing forum. They are a tremendous source of knowledge. Note there is a special link for WS vegetables. Beyond that, I don't recommend corn. It's taproot doesn't transplant well, no matter how fast you move it after germination. Cucumbers, melons, squashes and pumpkins work well, but need to be transplanted quickly or you lose much of the benefit over direct sowing. I must admit I really enjoy transplanting the cucumbers, just for the olifactory sensation! However, I'm scheduled for close to 500 gallons of perennials this year, so I'll be direct sowing those four, just to skip a transplant somewhere! Broccoli, cabbage and asparagus have been great wintersown sprouters for me. And I definitely recommend wintersowing okra. The warmth of the mini greenhouse gives okra a good headstart. After I transplant it I place 2 liter cloches over the plants to speed along this heat loving vegetable.
    New to me this year will be asparagus peas and snowpeas. I'll be wintersowing them right after the Christmas tree is put away. If you have moisture retentive soil, you may like sowing radishes, lettuce, spinach and other greens directly. I however, garden in what used to be very much like beach sand, so I benefit from wintersowing these things because they need consistent moisture for germination.
    The debate for wintersown tomatoes rages on. In favor of wintersowing them, there is no light set up and no trouble with damping off. It also does away with space limitations associated with indoor set ups. The plants are known to be vigorous and healthy.
    On the other hand, I want a fresh tomato as soon as possible. When I start plants inside and move them into walls of water, I consistently have first harvest on May 1. With wintersowing, my harvest is later than that. This year, time permitting, I'm going to try a hybrid method, putting my wintersown containers inside walls of water. For the trade off of not having to set up inside, I might be able to live with a slightly later harvest.
    Herbs are ideal candidates for wintersowing, and I interplant them with veggies and perennials.

    Hope this helps,
    Seedmama

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I did wintersowing last winter and I had mixed results.

    I used mostly milk jugs, some 2-liter clear pop bottles. Wasn't at all pleased with the pop bottles. The soil dried out too fast. Milk jugs were OK.

    Had a little trouble finding the right kind of soil to use in the jug. Seed starting soil got expensive. Potting mix developed a crust that made it look like the soil was wet when really it was dry. Finally started digging up my good composted soil out of the raised bed, baking it for an hour at 300-350 degrees in the oven and using that.

    About the right time to start setting things out, my back went out and I couldn't get things in the ground very fast. Lots of things didn't make the transplant, and then we got rain and more rain and more rain and lots of transplants drowned.

    This year I plan to do it a little different. I'm playing with the milk jug to try to figure out a way I can plant directly into the ground and still protect and identify what I've planted. Think this'll work?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Ilene. I'll share my thought on the challenges you faced with winter sowing. Perhaps these suggestions will help someone else be successful. Seed starting mix is not the recommended medium for winter sowing. It is indeed expensive, and it dries out too fast. A good quality potting mix will not crust over. A rule of thumb for choosing good quality are to choose something that feels very light for its size. Compacted bales can throw a kink in that guideline, but it holds for bags. A good mix will list peat moss, wetting agent and vermiculite as ingredients. Composted soil, or for that matter soil of any kind, is also not the recommended medium for wintersowing.
    I'm not sure I follow exactly what you are telling us about transplants and drowning. If you are telling us seedlings drowned in their containers before they could be transplanted, it means your containers didn't have enough drainage holes, a problem which may have been compounded by an improper medium. If you are telling us your seedlings drowned after you put them in the ground, that isn't a winter sowing failure.
    Did you have an opportunity to discuss your challenges with members of the WS forum? They are a friendly helpful group who will offer assistance with most any difficulty presented.
    The wintersowing method, as prescribed, has a huge following for many reasons. The main one, in my opinion, is that is it successful. I'm sorry it wasn't the right answer for you, but I feel I must encourage newbies to check out its merits for themselves. "You can't win if you don't enter."

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Seedmama, thanks for your reply. The transplants that drowned were transplanted into the ground, not in a container.

    I did not intend for my post to sound as if I was trying to discourage anyone from trying wintersowing. To the contrary, I am more than willing to try all kinds of concepts that are new to me and I recommend that everyone try things at least once. I thought it was obvious by my post that "stuff happened" that was beyond the realm of the winter sowing method. I certainly don't blame the condition of my back or the weather on winter sowing. ;)

    I did find myself babysitting my milk jugs quite a bit when the Oklahoma weather was hot one day, cold another, as too much sun without adequate venting, or icy winds with the venting left open can mean damage or death for the seedlings. I think it's important to mention that, since newbies can lose stuff easily if they are not vigilant. Early spring is not the time to go away from home for a few days if you are doing winter sowing.

    I still maintain that potting soil that contains peat moss does develop problems when we have the kind of torrential rains as we've had in my part of Oklahoma the last two springs. There is a fine line between the drainage holes being too big for when there's normal rainfall, and too small for when it's a gully washer. During times of heavy rain, the jugs do hold water long enough for the peat moss in the mix to float. When this happens, and then drains and dries out, I'm just saying it then develops a peat moss 'crust' on the surface and the color of the surface can fool you into thinking that the soil is wet when in fact it has dried out and is in desperate need of watering -- another point that's valuable for newbies to know. :)

    I am curious as to why good loamy composted garden soil, baked to kill weed seeds and insect larvae, would not be satisfactory for winter sowing when it is the exact same soil that I direct sow into with good results? Plus it's free and, being right in the back yard, is convenient and available regardless of the time of year.

    I am aware of the huge following winter sowing has, but really, what are the main strengths? In my opinion, they are that the milk jug or whatever is used adds protection to the seed from birds eating the seed or animals digging or walking in it, and keeps the seed moist for longer periods of time. To the seedling it offers protection from sudden cold blasts, and from the gardener accidentally digging it up while weeding due to forgetting what was planted there. But there is a small window of opportunity for setting out the HOS (hunk o' seedlings) before the roots need to go deeper than the dirt in the container. If you have to wait longer because you are sick or hurt, then it's another opportunity for loss, because the bigger the roots get, the faster they drink up water and the more easily injured they are by the transplanting process. It's important for Newbies to know this, too. Since I never know when or if my back is going to go out, and there are others who come here that have health issues as well, I am just trying to expand on the idea so that the seedlings will not need to be transplanted.

    Those who know me well, know that I have no ulterior motives. I'm not trying to sabotage anyone. I'm here to learn and to share what I have learned. I come to this forum and a few others because the people who frequent them have that same attitude. --Ilene

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ilene, I was pleased to see your reply. One of the great things about winter sowing is its adaptability. (See my reference to tomatoes above) Gardeners tweak the method all the time and have great results. However, when the results aren't so great, it's worth revisiting the method as prescribed, to use as a diagnostic tool of how better results can be achieved.

    My purpose is not to disagree with your experience, but to offer solutions for challenges. I have found that using potting mix that contains "wetting agent" sufficiently addresses the crusting of peat moss. I have also found that keeping my containers consistently moist is much more effective than waiting until they clearly are in need of water. I must agree that once peat moss dries out, it takes some degree of effort to get it moist again. Last year I was unable to secure my beloved ProMix. I mixed my own amateur peat based mix. As a wetting agent, I used a small amount of dish soap in the water I used to moisten the mix. The dish soap acts as a wetting agent, making the peat more receptive to moisture.

    Regarding drainage issues, I have learned that a whole lot of smaller holes work better for me than a few large ones. I also found I was more likely to experience a wash out in a container with a large surface area, such as a roasting pan, than with a milk jug or soda bottle.

    Good, composted garden soil may in fact be satisfactory for winter sowing, or it may not. It's just not part of the prescribed method, which takes us back to diagnotics. If it works, fantastic. If it doesn't, my thoughts would first go to drainage. In nature, there are no plastic containers preventing water from draining sideways. I suspect one of the reasons container gardeners prefer potting mix is its good drainage.

    Winter sowing is not for everyone, or every situation. In years past when I had very few seeds, I winter sowed things like cucumbers, pumpkins and squashes. I thoroughly enjoyed the experience of handling the seedlings. This year I have more seeds available for loss, so I'll be direct sowing them, making it a one step process to free up time for my winter sown perennials. I'll add that before I learned about winter sowing I used the top two thirds of 2 liter bottles as cloches to start seeds directly in the ground. It gave me okra much earlier than my neighbors.

    On the other hand, last year winter sowing gave me a head start. I expanded the size of our family during the late winter early spring months. My physical condition left me unable to bend over, so sowing into milk jugs sitting on a bar stool was ideal for me.

    I am a big fan of experiencing all that life has to offer and encourage anyone to try almost anything once. My friends often say, "why would you do that?" (make your own compost, grow your own food, build your own house, sew your kids' costumes, clean your own pecans, etc. --all things they would just buy) The answer is easy. Because I want to learn things and know more. We learn by doing. Our reasons for frequenting the forums are quite similar.

    I did not read from your post that you had ulterior motives or were trying to sabotage anyone. However, if I had been someone sitting on the fence trying to decide whether to try winter sowing I might very well have put a check mark in the column of "doesn't work, not going to try it." To restate, my purpose was to address challenges by returning to the home base of knowledge, and to suggest workable solutions to things that didn't turn out so well for you. I truly wish you the best.

    Seedmama

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting