Software
Houzz Logo Print
booberry85

Disease resistant & High yields

18 years ago

I'm looking for recommendations for 4-5 different tomatoes and 2 different cherry tomatoes to grow that have great disease resistance & high yields. I'm not picky about hybrids or heirlooms nor am I picky about determinate or indeterminate. I live in upstate NY, zone 5. Thanks for your advice.

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    I'm looking for recommendations for 4-5 different tomatoes and 2 different cherry tomatoes to grow that have great disease resistance & high yields. I'm not picky about hybrids or heirlooms nor am I picky about determinate or indeterminate. I live in upstate NY, zone 5. Thanks for your advice.

    ****

    Boo,I also live in upstate NY, that's true upstate, not Westchester Co and not Western Ny, LOL, and I have to think that when you ask for disease tolerant varieties that you're talking about foliage diseases. We don't have the many systemic diseases that folks further south have.

    And the bad news is that there's no variety, hybrid or heirloom, that has any significant tolerance to foliage diseases. There are a couple of exceptions, but they're of use only to a commercial farmer.

    The good news is that you can put your plants on a rigorous spray schedule with a good anti-fungal and that works well. It doesn't do anything against the two major bacterial foliage diseases but the fungal ones progress much faster anyway.'
    So if I take disease tolerance out of the picture why not indicate what colors/shapes you prefer and for what use b/c that will make it easier for others to make recommendations, which I will as well, when you give us the criteria to work with.

    I've successfully grow a couple of thousand varieties in our area so I hope to give you some good recs depending on what you really want.

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    I'm a canner and make my own salsas and sauces. I'd like 3 good red tomatoes for that purpose. The other two, I like to experiment with, so a color other than red and any shape is fine.

    In the past, I've had good luck with: Celebrity, Rutgers, Big Beef, Mortgage Lifter, Jet Star, Supersonic, and Tangerine Dream.

    I have not had good luck with: Early Girl, 4th of July, Health Kick, Juliet, Brandywines, and Romas (I have a bug that looks like a house fly but its half the size. It devours the Romas the second they show a blush.)

    I'd also would like two cherry type tomatoes. In the past I've grown Supersweet 100's, heirloom Red Cherry, and Yellow Pears. I like the novelty of the Yellow Pears. They are very prolific. However, the Supersweet 100's always crack late in the season. The Red Cherry was ok (skin was a little tough, not as prolific or as sweet as the Suppersweet 100's).

  • 18 years ago

    The Romas were Big Mama (Burpee). Come to think of it the Early Girls, 4th of July, Health Kick, Juliet and Brandywines were all from Burpee!

  • 18 years ago

    Supersonic is my favorite main crop. Sungold is everyone's favorite cherry tomato though it does tend to crack in wet weather. For an early tomato I use Stupice. And for sauce I was very happy with Opalka but this year am going to try Amish Paste. A gold/yellow tomato I would not be without is Kellogg's Breakfast.
    And I use Daconil for ealy blight which is my biggest disease problem.

  • 18 years ago

    If you are a canner you must try opalka.

  • 18 years ago

    >>"I'm looking for recommendations for 4-5 different tomatoes and 2 different cherry tomatoes to grow that have great disease resistance & high yields. I'm not picky about hybrids or heirlooms nor am I picky about determinate or indeterminate. I live in upstate NY, zone 5."Since you aren't picky regarding hybrid or heirloom, you might want to look at Cornell's list of recommended tomatoes for New York home gardens. Note on that page that the authors say:

    "Tomatoes were originally desert plants. So they don't naturally have strong resistance to plant diseases that thrive under our generally humid conditions. Fortunately, many hybrids have been bred specifically for disease resistance, and some open-pollinated varieties tolerate certain diseases."

    But it seems Cornell currently recommends the following cultivars for main season:
    Basket Vee
    Better Boy
    Big Beef
    Big Boy
    Celebrity
    Jet Star
    Mountain Fresh
    Mountain Spring
    Sunbeam
    Sunrise
    Supersonic
    Ultra Sweet

    Looking at that list, Big Beef, Celebrity, and Mountain Spring jump out as resistant to a number of common diseases ... whether in New York or elsewhere. If you like Celebrity, you might explore Carnival which is very similar but has added resistance that may or may not be applicable to your area.

    For paste, Cornell recommends:
    Classica
    La Roma
    La Rosa
    Nova
    Plum Dandy
    Roma
    Viva Italia

    Apparently, Cornell also maintains a page that lists gardener's comments and ratings about various tomatoes grown in New York HERE

    You may also want to consult your local county extension agent about what tomato diseases are of concern in your area and which varieties prevail under local conditions.

    Bill

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks so much for the recommendations everyone. Thanks Bill for reminding me about Cornell's website. Somehow between June & now I had completely forgotten about it. I'll bookmark it!

Sponsored
Franklin County's Heavy Timber Specialists | Best of Houzz 2020!