Software
Houzz Logo Print
milwaukeeboy

Soil choice for gallon pots

17 years ago

Hi All,

I know that this is touching on a hot topic, but I have made up my mind and I am potting up to gallon pots this weekend.

I am at least 3 weeks away from planting out myself and my friends and family are more like 4-5 weeks out (they being more the shade tree set).

Here is a typical (not my biggest and not my littlest) specimen from my plants; there is no doubt in my mind that I am potting up. The roots are 'fixing' to coil and I am not going to wait another week, at least with the biggest ones.

Viva Italia

So here is my question; what soil should I use for the next stage? I am leaning toward using 3 types in an experiment of sorts: topsoil, potting mix (typical potting soil, not starting mix) and miracle grow mix (either moisture control or not).

I can hear the northerners yelling "miracle grow" and the purists shouting "chop em off and start over."

What do *you* think?

TIA,

-alg

p.s. Last night, my 9 year old co-conspirator proclaimed that are plants are "starting to look like the ones that you buy at Steins." I was beaming.

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    Top soil in any container is a no no. The regular Miracle Grow potting mix is what I us. I believe Walmart sells a store brand potting mix for a couple of bucks less than MG. I'd stick with soil less potting mixes no matter what. I always pot up to 1 gallon containers before planting out. There is a 2 cubic foot bag of MG in my garage as I right this. That's for next year's plants.

  • 17 years ago

    Any soil-less potting mix will do fine. No dirt - the risk of damp-off isn't over by a long shot. If you review the many 'potting up' discussions here you'll find only soil-less growing mixes recommended. Brand recommendations are also included in those discussions.

    I have no objections to potting up - do it regularly myself - but I can't say I'd agree with jumping all the way up to 1 gallon containers. That's a lot of unnecessary potting mix expense.

    I can hear the northerners yelling "miracle grow" and the purists shouting "chop em off and start over."

    May be just a bit of misunderstanding if those are the conclusions you have drawn. ;) Miracle Grow soil-less potting mixes are just one of the many recommended brands. Use whichever one you wish. And cloning suckers and growth tips isn't the same thing as chopping them off and starting over. Next year, just don't start them so early.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I prefer Sta-Green potting mix (Lowe's house brand, I think) because I find that it clumps less, absorbs water more evenly and drains better than Miracle Grow. Some people swear that MG is better, but if you read the labels it's probably because MG contains more fertilizer. I'll go for the cheaper Sta-Green and add my own choice of fertilizer. Just the regular mix, not the moisture control variety.

    I also agree with Dave that you do not need to pot up to gallon size containers with just three weeks to go. Won't hurt, but it does seem like overkill a bit.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the answers, I'll stay away from soil.

    I just got back from bying sixty Elite 300 nursery pots (.75 gal) and 2 bags of Metro Mix 830 soiless mix.

    I hear what you guys are saying about gallon pots but since its really at least 4 weeks for the ones that I am giving away I just don't see anything smaller buying that much time.

    The one thing that I am really happy about now is the amount of roots that I have for the foliage size, the plants are growing very compactly which seems like a good sign.

    I may start a whole 'nother batch from seed tonight now that I have the process down ;-) (I may be kidding).

    I'll keep pictures going on my blog.

    -alg

    p.s. I was trying to be funny with my chop em off comment, sorry if it didn't come across that way.

    Here is a link that might be useful: My Blog

  • 17 years ago

    MWB

    I don't think anybody would say it's "wrong" to put up your plants now in gallon containers. That advice is mainly to point out that it's cheaper not to do it.

    That said, if you have several more weeks before they can be planted out, you might consider putting some of them in deeper cups. I can't tell the size of those but I think the 16-oz cups are larger. You can also use 2-liter plastic soda bottles with the top cut off and drainage holes. They're even deeper. Either larger cups or 2-liter bottles would give the roots more room to grow but not take up so much planting soil or space!

  • 17 years ago

    Two liters bottles are a great idea, I wish I had a good source.

    One point is that size 300 pots aren't really gallon, thsy are 3/4 gallon (~3 liter).

    One more question, I have 2 kinds of potting mix, the metro mix that I mentioned above and some miracle grow (with moisture control). I bought the MG while I was still under the impression that Raybo was still using that in his earthtainers. I could lug that back to the store and exchange it for non moisture control and get about a buck back but that is too much work for me. Anyone see anything wrong with using moisture control if I have it?

    -al

  • 17 years ago

    The moisture control is a good thing to have if you were going to pot up to qt. containers and you didn't want to water the plants every day for the last week. In your situation it won't help much but it won't hurt either. If you are going to the larger pot I'd mix a teaspoon or two of osmocote into the gal of potting mix to get some longer range nutrients in the immediate root zone.

  • 17 years ago

    mil,

    Every eco-system will react differently. In the SWC container, I found the MG with Moisture Control was too good at retaining moisture, and instead elected to use the plain MG potting mix. 25% cheaper - - and it wicked at a more appropriate rate for the EarthTainer metrics.

    Raybo

  • 17 years ago

    Yea...stay away from soil & any mixes with sand in them. A lot of people (including myself) like the MG products. I personally use MG Moisture Control for my maters (sometimes with a little compost or mulch type additive).

  • 17 years ago

    Hi all,

    A follow up on my plants. Its been about 2 weeks since I posted this thread. I potted the first of my plants up to 3 quart pots last week (on Wednesday the 29th).

    I am really happy with the state of the plants; they have been out during the day and in at night up til now. Tonight I am letting them sleep outside since it is only supposed to get down to 50.

    Here is a picture from today of one of the plants. I have 22 in bigger pots now.

    I agree that it is a more expensive way to go but I have no regrets at this point.

    -al g

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting