Software
Houzz Logo Print
cath41

Condo Mangoes

16 years ago

I started a mango seed last year and it's about 18" high. It put on less than 6" this year, but is flushing. I put it out in April and in full sun so it has its reasons (This was before I began reading this forum). I have been reading this forum the last few months and you all have convinced me that my life will not be complete until I buy a mango or two or... Now then, be merciful and help me choose. The mango(s) will live in a pot forever. I like intense, tangy, sweet and sour tastes and fruity fruit. Coconut is OK but I wouldn't seek it out. I do not want to deal with anthracnose. We have had it some years on the dogwoods, usually in August, and so I know it's around. In the most recent posts Duncan sounded like a winner; son of Edward (which may be the best tasting of all) and a dwarf. Where would I get it? Pine Island doesn't have it and since it would have to be shipped to Dayton, Ohio, that rules out many of the other nurseries. Oh yes, I would like to have 2 to 4 mangoes that produce at different times so that I can span as much of the year as possible. Any guidance whatsoever will be greatly appreciated. I know taste is a very individual thing but I have never eaten a labeled mango. I don't know mangoes and you don't know me but surely we can work something out.

Cath

Comments (30)

  • 16 years ago

    I would consider a Carrie. It can be kept as a condo mango an has a fairly 'on your face' taste.

    It's too early in the Am for me to remember what other condo/dwarf varieties i have tasted, maybe a little later in the day I will wake up a bit more :)

  • 16 years ago

    I live in Z6 as well, about 150 miles SW of you in WV.

    What I did was look through the Pine Island web site as well as the mango threads here.

    I finally decided on Mallika and Carrie as the two mangoes I purchased earlier this summer.

    The trees were healthy, well packaged and reasonably priced. I paid $87.50, shipped for two.

  • 16 years ago

    i recommend Pickering to anyone container growing mango, i tasted one recently, excellent full mango flavor. the coconut flavor i detect is usually more of an aftertaste note, mangos like Julie have that smooth finish. the tree is dwarf and one of the most productive i have witnessed from pictures.

    use a well draining potting mix and a diluted liquid fertilizer like fish emulsion

  • 16 years ago

    Carrie and especially Mallika share traits of Indian cultivars, creamy complex mango flavor and susceptible to some anthracnose. both excellent mangos.

    Rosigold and Fairchild would be two excellent Asian like varieties. they have a more simple sweet sour flavor, more resistant to fungus.

  • 16 years ago

    You will be hard pressed to find a 'late season' "dwarf".

    I highly recommend Fairchild though. Doesn't have anthracnose problems, is very productive, and is delicious.

  • 16 years ago

    ice cream and mallika are probably the latest mid season dwarfs.

    i wouldnt recommend ice cream as its not a typical mango flavor and is a shy bearer

    Rosigold is a real early bloomer

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you all for your prompt and thorough responses. Where does Cogshall fit in the mix?
    I am not decided yet but am leaning toward a Carrie (for flavor), a Pickering (instead of a Fairchild, because of production and I infer a more powerful flavor) and either Malika or Lancetilla for the later season. But several of you have recommended the Malika and so it will probably be that. Still, I am curious why you favor the Malika.
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    I don't own a Cogshall, but from some folks around my parts that do it's a a mid season and somewhat of a shy bearer. I tried one for the first time this season. It was delicious and I almsot bought one, until some local folks told that they consistently get few fruit.

    With the Malika I would most highly suggest that you try before you buy. It's the only popular cultivar that I have tried and just did not want to finish eating it. It has a rather different taste which obviously appeals to many, but my fiance and I both voted it as our least favorite. It would be frustrating to spend money and time to find out you are the same way.

  • 16 years ago

    Cogshall is not a shy bearer at my house. Its not prolific either. I would put the crop at "average" in most years. This year with very few trees setting fruit, my tree set about 12 fruits. For the size of the tree (8 x 6), that wasn't too bad....especially compared to so many others that were fruitless this year. I would say the fruiting season for this mango ranges from the later part of the early season to the early part of mid-season. Overall a very nice mango which colors up beautifully and grows with a very nice short internodal habit. Very size manageable.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you Budershank, mgk, mango kush, squam and Harry for your valuable advice.
    Did no one recommend Dot and Duncan because they are difficult to obtain, new and not enough experience with them, or do they have undesirable qualities? We have family members expected to move to Fort Walton Beach where we expect to visit and so may eventually be able to get to, say, Excalibur. After all it's only half a state away. LOL So undesirable qualities are relevant for the future. Also, regarding Lacetilla, I can only find that the fruit is quite large and the tree, although listed as a Condo mango, is largish. Any more information available as to taste and pot culture?
    Anyone willing to comment?
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Duncan is a good tasting, productive mango with a medium-to-small growth habit. It can be difficult to find though. I recently sold a Duncan tree to one of the board members.

    Dot might be a little more common but I would not classify it as a 'condo mango' (a term I find to be a little dubious on its own). I haven't tried Dot yet but everything I've heard about its flavor suggests its outstanding.

    Lancetilla is another variety that got the 'condo mango' label even though the trees I've seen don't look like dwarfs. Have not tried the fruit on them either.

  • 16 years ago

    Dot was once thought to be unsuitable because of its anthracnose susceptibility which is really only a problem with juvenile trees IMO. Frank Smathers promoted it and grafted his stock.

    Duncan mango is a patented variety by David Sturrock of Palm Beach County, its a medium upright canopy tree resistant to anthracnose, maybe Harry can chime in in its productivity?

    to me a Duncan tastes a little more like a Carabao then an Edward making the assumption it is Edwards x Pico very believable.

  • 16 years ago

    Cath:

    Dot and Duncan are both excellent mangoes. Duncan is the smaller grower of the two. Duncan also produces larger and more consistant crops. Duncan is more disease resistant than Dot....but, if you'd ask me which I would plant if I only could have one, it would be Dot. The flavor is really special...very complex and delicious. However, if you are planting in a pot....Duncan would be preferable.

    Lancetilla is a good mango. The fruit are huge. They are very meaty with a nice flavor. Not my favorite, but definitely worth growing. I would not attempt to grow it in a pot. There are too many other varieties that will do much better for you in a pot. I would say Pickering, Cogshall, and Fairchild are excellent starting points for a "to be pot grown" collection.

    I hope you know that from Fort Walton Beach to Lantana, where Excalibur is, the drive will only be about 600 miles and about 9 3/4 hours. Just a short hop, skip and a jump...but worth the trip.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Harry, I didn't know the distance but guessed it would not be trivial.
    Thank you one and all. These replies have been a gold mine of information for those of us up North who are confined to pot growing and who are without much access to labeled mangoes.
    Thank you, thank you,
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Well, I just ordered a Carrie and a Pickering from Pine Island. No telling where this madness will lead. Thank you all again for your time, advice and expertise which you give so generously.
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Mangoes came today in late afternoon, well nigh instant gratification. They were large and beautiful too. It reminds me of when I first began ordering plants by mail in the 70s (except those were small and $20). So much pleasure and anticipation and learning ahead for such a modest amount. Just don't tell Pine Island I said so or they'll raise prices!
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Best of luck in your efforts to grow these new additions. I hope you don't need any help with them, but if you do, we're here for you.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks so much, Harry. I've raised a lot of plants but never mangoes before and may well need the help. These forums are so good because they enable us to learn and improve even on the things we have been doing for a long time.
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Cath, Congrats on your new mango trees(my most favorite fruits)! When you get a chance we would love to see pictures! This is definitely one of the best forums on GW...lots of great, friendly members always willing to help one another. Best of luck with them!

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Nanci,
    My favoriter fruit too! Well, between mango and cherimoya. I wanted to tell ya that I "pugged" my Maha Chinook about a month ago. Took me awhile to cut it back. I wasn't sure if I could do it or not, but now I have about 12 buds growing all over. I also did the same to my cogshall. I think it was anthracnose that was all over it. I had black spots all over it and now that I have removed most of the damaged/diseased growth, I will use the copper fungicide that Harry sent me. Thanks Harry! I hope you enjoy your new mango that you got from Puerto Rico!
    Cath41,
    I know you will enjoy your trees and you have come to the right place for help or questions. Good luck with your new purchases!
    Andrew

  • 16 years ago

    Puglvr, BTW I am a Collielvr and so I understand, I haven't learned to post pictures yet. I don't even know how to take pictures with the digital camera. My husband calls me a Luddite but this is not true. I love modern conveniences. I just hate to take the time to learn when I can be growing plants and doing other things I like more. I know this has drawbacks. For instance, I know that I will not exist until I post pictures. OhioJay has said so. BTW I am in Ohio too - near Dayton.
    Question: I started two Manilla type mangoes this Spring. They were coming along nicely and so were each transplanted into a 2 gallon pot. This site had said to pinch out the strongest shoot and so I did. They promptly died. Was the pinching too soon or should I look for another cause. Also what is the timing on root pruning? On the mango that I started last year, monocarpic type, I knew that I did not want a tap root and so I cut it off a few inches from the crown at the end of its first summer. It didn't seem to harm it exactly but may have caused a pause in growth. What is the timing on tap root pruning?
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    I meant to say monoembryonic, not monocarpic. I'm somewhat distracted cooking dinner.
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Andrew, great to hear you're getting new growths on the Maha Chinook that you pugged...always great news!

    Hi Cathi, I will let the experts help you with your questions, I know very little about growing mango from seed. BTW, Collies are great dogs too...I love them!!

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Andrew, I am very interested in hearing how your Lancetilla works out, both flavor and size once it has a little age on it.
    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    I am glad to learn of this groups success at growing container plants which actually bear fruit. I have been considering a greenhouse to extend the variety of fruits I can grow successfully.

  • 16 years ago

    I just purchased a Fairchild, Nom Doc Mai and a Cogshall over the weekend and are wanting to keep them in pots to move them in when too cold. Is now to late to repot them if I'm wanting to flower/produce this year? I read that if the plant I bought is somewhat rootbound, roots growing in circle around pot that I can cut through the roots a few times to fix it. What do y'all think?

  • 16 years ago

    aliciagrower a potted tree will inevitably become rootbound, its only a concern when you are planning to plant them out in the field. i would have them permanently end up in 25 gallon containers, this is what i grow citrus in.

    cath41 youve made an excellent choice, those are two of my favorite mangos, if you get the bug for one more go with an Asian variety like po pyu kalay or nam doc mai.

    Im glad you guys caught the mango bug, its a very rewarding hobby. Im not sure if early, mid and late seasons will really have that much of a significance in your situation, I know people growing mangos in California often have odd harvest seasons.

    keep us updated, if you want later season fruit i would highly recommend growing sugar apple, like Kampong Mauve. unlike mango those do come relatively true from seed, i should have some kampong mauve seeds available within a few weeks you are welcome to for a few bucks shipping

  • 16 years ago

    Mango kush,

    Thank you for the additional information and the kind offer of seeds. I shouldn't but I probably will. Please let us know when they are available.

    "Caught the mango bug" is right. I have them started by seed on top of the refrigerator, over the washing machine and dryer where they are under lights and out in the yard (must bring them in SOON). A few days ago one seed fell out of the refrigerator freezer when I opened it. It must have gotten knocked off of the top of the refrigerator and into the door shelves. But it IS fun.

    I had been thinking of Rosigold and Neelum to stretch the season and Dot (because Harry made it sound irresistable) for next possibles but they have to wait until I get organized and find room. And now you make the Lemon Meringue and Nam Doc Mai sound irresistable as well!

    Cath

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you MangoKush!
    So it is fine to go ahead and repot them now? I love reading how the maddness makes you want to buy every great variety, that is where I'm at!! Returning to the nursery this weekend to pick up some more trees, I can't help myself! :D

    Cath good luck on you're trees! They all sound so irresistable don't they!!

  • 16 years ago

    Alicia,

    I posted you something yesterday but it didn't "take". The trees do indeed all sound irresistible. And do let us know what you get at that nursery.

    Cath

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County