Software
Houzz Logo Print
salthart

Tomatoes for juice- revisit

14 years ago

I wasn't clear in my last "Juice" post and so I thought I might try again.

I like a strong tomato flavor but what I'm looking for are tomatoes that are the exact opposite of paste tomatoes. Juicy ! LOL

Thanks

Comments (7)

  • 14 years ago

    tomatoes that are the exact opposite of paste tomatoes

    Think of it this way. According to USDA nutritional analysis all tomatoes, regardless of variety, are 85 to 95% water. 85-95% of the mass of any tomato is water.

    Paste-type tomatoes are on the low end of the scale (the 85%), beefsteaks are the other end of the scale (95%). So the over-all juicy difference is minimal but if it is liquid you are after then clearly the bigger the beefsteak tomato the more juice and the more productive the plant the more juice you get per plant. Here is a link to lots of different beefsteak varieties if growing from seed. If using store-bought transplants then the commonly available varieties are Brandywine (not a big producer), Delicious, Beefmaster, and Mortgage Lifter. Depending on where you live you might also be able to find Bradley (not a true beefsteak but close), Rutgers (same), Big Boy (same), or Goliath.

    That % of water can be affected to a small degree depending on how they are grow, ie: dry-cropping vs. grown in containers but it is a +/- 1% effect.

    So since the "juicy range" is so small, that brings us back to flavor as the component to be sought. That's discussed in your other post on this subject. I linked it below so others can read it if interested.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tomatoes best for juice

  • 14 years ago

    I have been on a quest for bold tasting, juicy tomaotes for my sister. I find catalog descriptions just throw adjectives like, "sweet" "jucy" and "old time tomato flavor" around at will. Based mostly on descriptions from other growers I am trying Box Car Willie, Thessoloniki and Break 'O Day for her this year.

  • 14 years ago

    Think of it this way. According to USDA nutritional analysis all tomatoes, regardless of variety, are 85 to 95% water. 85-95% of the mass of any tomato is water.
    I assume that the relative %'s of water content in statement is accurate. However, there is a practical issue in this mix when actually extracting tom juice... at least using methods to which most can avail themselves. It seems to me that the texture of the "pulp" is a factor in what % of the total juice is readily able to be recovered... depending upon the juicing method used. So for me, I would not use "paste" toms for juicing because they are a bit small and with that you get a greater proportion of skin to deal with (unless you remove it before juicing) and their "texture" to me is not conducive to good juice production compared to most non-paste cults... greater tendency to plug the sieve openings of the machine that I have.

    Reggie

  • 14 years ago

    I have made juice from "paste" tomatoes. Roma in fact and I did so just last summer. I dip the tomatoes in boiling water and then core it and a little squeeze is all it takes to slip the tomato from the skin.

    The result is to thick for juice IMO and to bland as well though you can cook it down some and build the flavor enough for pasta sauce etc so it wasn't a total waste. BTW, Buying Roma's wasn't something I set out to do. They were simply all that was left.

    I have now spent hours reading write ups about tomatoes. I have asked questions and while I haven't yet replied to everyone please know that I have heard whats been said.

    I have plans laid to add compost to the soil as per Dave in another thread. I will try more varieties this year than ever before. I have a list and the number grows most every day. Finding a seed vendor who carries most of them is a bit of a challenge. (last time I ordered seed online I was billed 15 bucks S&H for less than an eighth ounce of seed ! Don't know if that is the norm of if I was taken but the thoughts of trying to order seed from 4 or 5 places ? ! ! ! )

    At any rate, After much reading I have about made up my mind that the tomato I loved as a kid would almost have to have been a local cross of some sort. It was a beefsteak type as I could take one slice and make two sandwiches from it. And while it would seem that all the beefsteak I have found info on are said to be mild or sweet as well as most of the orange tomatoes I have read about, This was orange and tart.
    Now factor in the flat oval shape and the turned up ends, The scalloped shoulders that seemed almost never to lose all the green-? I have read that the green shoulders can be caused by heat and I wonder if this had bearing on the tart taste. Chances are this tomato was a fluke and I'll never again see its like.

    But for now at least, I'm gonna keep on trying !

    Many thanks to all of you for all your input. I can imagine its hard dealing with one such as I who knows next to nothing..

    Please keep the names of tart, juicy tomatoes coming. I hope to try them all before I'm done !

  • 14 years ago

    I agree with you salthart that Romas and other paste types can be used in juice and it is one of the faves for making a V8 vegetable juice blend. That thickness really helps off-set the water from the other veggies added to the blend.

    But roma types, with a couple of exceptions, have never been noted for their taste.

    Not to add to your list but take a look at Persimmon tomatoes. That is the one I thought of when reading your description above.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    salthart, here are some sources for good tomato seed which have inexpensive S&H; seed prices vary but some are quite cheap and one is free! Most have quite a selection; I think TGS is the only one offering many hybrids.

    Tatiana's Seeds. S&H is free if you order 8 packets, and $2.00 for less than that.
    Order info is on the left; the catalog can be accessed on the right, about 1/4 of the way down the page.
    http://t.tatianastomatobase.com:88/wiki/Tatiana%27s_TOMATObase_-_Heritage_Tomatoes
    Be sure to check out the TOMATOBase itself: the best English-language database for open-pollinated tomatoes.

    Marianna's Heirloom Tomatoes: S&H is $4.95.
    https://www.mariannasheirloomseeds.com/

    Tomato Growers Supply: S&H is $5.25 per order.
    http://www.tomatogrowers.com/
    They also have a paper catalog.

    Sample Seed Shop. Shipping is $3.75 up to 20 packets.
    http://sampleseeds.com/?page_id=65

    WinterSown's Your Choice offer. 6 seed packets; you list your preferences, but there may be substitutions. Send a SASE business-size envelope with two first-class stamps. No other cost.
    http://wintersown.org/wseo1/YourChoiceTomatoSASE.html

    Sand Hill Preservation Center. Free for orders over $10.00; for smaller orders, S&H is $2.00.
    http://www.sandhillpreservation.com/catalog/seed_menu.html
    They also have a paper catalog.

  • 14 years ago

    Yellow Pear