Software
Houzz Logo Print
kdup_gw

Are these tomato seedlings doomed?

14 years ago

I'm worried that my Patio Tomato seedlings have a disease! Their tops look nice and green, but lower leaves are spotted and yellowing.

I have 20 young tomato plants (from a different source) in the ground. Was thinking about putting the Patio tomatoes in pots on the opposite side of the house. (I don't want to risk infecting my whole crop.)

I would hate to destroy these seedlings if they might be OK --- but on the other hand if they will likely die or not produce well, then I don't want to spend money buying pots, soil mix, etc (not to mention the time involved).

Can anyone advise, from my pics?

http://015aea9.netsolhost.com/transfer/tomatopics/plants.jpg

http://015aea9.netsolhost.com/transfer/tomatopics/leaves.jpg

http://015aea9.netsolhost.com/transfer/tomatopics/leaf.jpg

http://015aea9.netsolhost.com/transfer/tomatopics/greentops.jpg

Comments (9)

  • 14 years ago

    kdup's photos:

    {{gwi:2104013}}

    {{gwi:2104014}}

    {{gwi:2104015}}

    {{gwi:2104016}}

    I believe I see a combination of problems here.

    1. Rootbound

    2. Overwatered

    3. Fertlizer burn

    4. Possibly going too long between waterings

    Not disease, strictly environmental. Transplant them - soon!

    Betsy

  • 14 years ago

    Betsy, I am surprised at your response, since the first three photos show what looks to me like a classic case of early blight, in which case the advice would be to remove and destroy infected leaves, then treat the plants with Daconil (or other brand name) to help avoid recurrence.
    Gary

  • 14 years ago

    i really dont see any blight maybe some insect damage. root bound for sure.

  • 14 years ago

    so whats the rootbound indicator? Just the size of the plant vs size of its container in the photos?

  • 14 years ago

    Gary,

    Early blight? Indoors? Really?

    Highly unlikely I think.

    Perhaps if kdup gave us more info:

    How often do you water?
    Have you fertilized the plants?
    How long have they been in those cells?

    Betsy

  • 14 years ago

    Hello and thanks Everyone for the help..... In answer to Betsy's questions:

    I was given these seedlings a few days ago. Not sure how long/often they were kept, watered, fertilized, etc. They may have been kept outdoors, by the original grower and/or the person who gave them to me.

    My own tomatoes are already in the ground (being watered regularly by Mother Nature, as we have been getting daily rain showers). I've never grown tomatoes in pots but I didn't want to put these in my garden because they look a little iffy to me. They're supposedly "Patio" variety, so I assume pots would be fine.

    Blight is indeed a concern for me (both Early & Late). I garden organically & don't use strong chemical controls, so I don't want to take any chances.

    I'm certainly no expert, but these leaves look a lot like the ones that have marked "the beginning of the end" for many of my tomatoes in past years.

    Seems like I may have to do some mercy killing :-( although I will hold off for another day or so, in case folks want to chime in with more opinions.

    Thanks again!

  • 14 years ago

    Gosh, I'm just not enough of an expert at tomato diseases to know for sure. The leaves on kdup's plants looked very much like what I had earlier this season and which I supposed to be early blight (just on the basis of images I've seen of it on the web). But I've never had early blight before and the ones that I thought had it this year were in fact quite stressed for a couple of weeks. So yes, perhaps it was environmental factors and not the disease; which would be a relief. Or maybe the diagnosis was correct. FWIW, my experience here is that Betsy knows far more than I (or many of the posters) here, so it was pretty bold of me to question her judgment in this case. It just came as a surprise.

  • 14 years ago

    This looks similar to what I had. It could be one of several diseases. If it is a fungus, it needs Maneb/Manacosib or if bacterial spot, needs copper.

  • 14 years ago

    Gary,

    It's OK, I am NOT infallible. LOL! I made the unwarranted assumption that kdup had grown those plants from seeds. Silly me. My apologies for snapping back, it was uncalled for.

    kdup,

    Since you are unsure of the history of those patio plants, it is possible that a mercy killing might be in order. That is of course entirely up to you. Personally, I don't think it is necessary. Let me explain.

    The unaffected leaves look nice and green, the stems are stocky and appear healthy. I'd even go so far as to say that the seedlings had probably been hardened off prior to your being "gifted" with them. I suspect the black spots might be where the plants got some sunburn when they were first exposed to the great outdoors. Sunburned tomatoes will turn white, then the area will die and blacken. (Been there, done that.) That could also account for the crispy edges on the leaves, as could overloving with fertilizer.

    The yellowing of leaves is a classic symptom of overwatering, see the link below.

    What I would reccomend if you want to try the plants:

    • First: Get some of those 20 ounce plastic cups, make two or three 1/4" holes in the bottom, and pot the tomatoes up in a quality "soilless" growing medium. Don't use moisture control types, they don't drain well in containers. Make sure it does not say on the package that it is "Not for use in containers" or "Soil".

    • Second: Water well, but don't leave them standing in water more than 30 minutes (I water my baby tomatoes by putting water in the bottom of the tray they are in and after 30 minutes I drain off any that has not been absorbed.) Wait until the cups are fairly light until you water again. It will vary with the size of the plants, the ambient temperatures and humidity. If the leaves start to droop, you waited a tad too long, but they will recover if you haven't waited too long. **Smile**

    • Third: Restart the hardening off process. Give the plants a few days to adapt to potting up, then put them out in the shade for a couple of hours and increase the time they spend outdoors every day until they are out most of the day and spend some of the time in the sun.

    • You can trim off the leaves that have the damage on them if you want to, and you can actually do it at any time, just be aware that if you take too many of the leaves, the tomatoes will be longer in recovering.

    • Once the plants have been in the larger plastic cups for 10 days or so, I would evaluate whether or not they look like plants you want to save.

    That's
    {{gwi:1292219}}

    Betsy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Signs & Symptoms of Overwatering Tomatoes