Software
Houzz Logo Print
kterlep

BER! Where can I get calcium

19 years ago

well yesterday I developed BER on one plant. What can I buy (at ace hardware or walmart) to help my plant?

Comments (28)

  • 19 years ago

    you might try lime. But BER almost always goes away after the first couple of tomatoes.

    What was the variety wil BER.

  • 19 years ago

    Good, even, regularly scheduled watering can often prevent BER. Water the same amount, even the same time of day, being consistent with your watering. Don't skip days and don't let the plants ever wilt. You can add all the calcium in the world and still get BER... it's not necessarily a lack of calcium but often the plant's inability to move it effectively inside the plant to the fruits.

  • 19 years ago

    Unless your soil is devoid of Ca++, which would be rare, then as Korney said, addition of Ca++ will do nothing b'c the problem is not one of uptake, it's one of maldistribution within the plants.

    And stress to a plant that is suceptible to BER can induce it. And the two major indicers are uneven water distribution, where mulching can help, or too much N which causes rapid plant growth and is a stress to the plant.

    But too hot, too cool, too wet, too dry are also inducers.

    As plants mature they are better able to withstand stresses so BER usually disappears.

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    ALL BS. Water & time does not and will not help BER. At least from my expierence.

    If you have a local nursery it's best to ask them and they'll give you something right there.

    Otherwise you need Calcium in your soil. Here's some tricks you can try but be consistant.

    ~ I used Lobster Compost (link below) which has lots of calcium in it. I'll let you know once my fruits apprear.

    ~ put egg shells on the soil around the plant! That worked for my pots last year.

    ~ Try Calcium Chloride

    ~ Maybe Bone meal? Your walmart will have that but this one I'm not sure of.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Lobster Compost

  • 19 years ago

    ALL BS. Water & time does not and will not help BER. At least from my expierence

    *****

    I think the key words above are "from my experience".

    And it's not All BS.

    I invite you to go to Google and research BER and you'll find that the old situation of recommending addition of Ca++ to soils is pretty much a thing of the past. Look for the University related links.

    Over the past 10-15 years much research has been done on BER b'c it's a multi million dollar problem for the vegetable industry, not just with tomatoes, but with squash and peppers and cabbage and even more.

    It's going to take generation at least to get out of books and magazines the old recommendation to add Ca++ to help prevenmt BER and also for home gardeners and farmers, and yes nursery folks, to learn about the new findings. Sure, if the soil has no Ca++, which is very rare, then addition of Ca++ is needed. And if soils are acidic that also is a problem b'c then there's competition between Ca++ and other minerals for uptake. But that situation of too acidic soils can be remedied by raising the pH of the soil, and again, it's a rare situation.

    Again, a tremendous amount of research has shown that BER cannot be prevented by addition of Ca++. If it were that simple commercial farmers and others would not have the BER problems that they still have.

    There are so many stresses that can induce it as I and others above have noted, that it's a problem not easily solved.

    So please, before you say it's all BS find out for yourself by doing a bit of Googling. I think you'll be surprised. And if I remember correctly there's also a FAQ on BER at the top of this first page which says pretty much what several of us have said.

    I hesitated posting but I just could not sit back and have others think it's all BS when indeed it is not.

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    Posted by naturalstuff Z6 / CT

    ALL BS. Water & time does not and will not help BER. At least from my expierence.
    ***********************************************************

    Here's a bit of advice for you.

    Making statements such as the one above isn't going to win you any friends on this list.

    "your experience" is just that. Unless you personally have been involved with scientific studies for the past twenty plus years using control groups and have conducted these studies all over the USA, then "your experience" is likely limited to that little patch of soil in your own backyard.

    If so, that's hardly the basis for telling others on this list that their words are nothing more than "BS".

    If the true cause of BER was known, then more likely than not, the garden centers would be carrying a product that would absolutely prevent it from occurring.....GUARANTEED. The chemical companies would jump all over such formula and commercial tomato growers would be buying that product every season.

    Now, if you actually know of such a product by name, then please inform the list because there are plenty of us that would be happy to buy it in order to put an end to our BER issues. But if you don't know of one, then perhaps you should consider an apology for the words chosen by you in your post. A little humble pie is often good for the soul. LOL

  • 19 years ago

    Probably the biggest mistake that has not been mentioned is sideressing with ammonium forms of nitrogen (urea), which is by the way what you are doing when you hit them with the Miracle Grow "blue kool-aid".

    Urea inhibits movement of calcium into the plant and out to the fruit.

    Instead, use nitrate forms of nitrogen.

  • 19 years ago

    OK, I have a timer on the soaker hose, but I had disconnected it to let the soil dried out because I had set it for 2x/day 15 minutes and I think I was overdoing it.

    I switched it to 15 minutes every other day. I think maybe I might want to move it to 15 minutes every day but turn down the power of the hose a little?

    I'm not sure what kind of tomato it is, I bought a batch of heirloom seeds and they were varied and unmarked. I took pictures but my husband fumblefingered the cable and I can't download the pictures now. grrrr. It's a regular leaf and the tomatoes are globular - not rippled. I was thinking maybe they might be black krim.

    Yesterday I took that bunch of tomatoes off (they all had it or were showing signs. On Wednesday, it just looked like someone had dipped the end in soy sauce (like on the surface), but yesterday it was brown.

    I also mulched with straw this week.

    So if I get the watering schedule fixed, (any suggestions) and apply some bone meal (although I looked at it and it didn't say "calcium" on it even though I thought it would), and save up some eggshells and...what just stick them on top of the dirt? poke a hole and stick eggshell powder in, then everyone should be happy and also my tomatoes will be fixed, right? :)

  • 19 years ago

    I add eggshell to the hole (probably more for good luck than anything :) and I always use bonemeal for any plant (yes, current trends seem to be to NOT amend the hole when planting but I ain't messing with what obviously works for me).

    ANYWAY, I'm wondering about comments made above about even watering. How do you folks deal with rain? Surely a few good soakers would play havoc with such tightly controlled schedules. This also goes for advice to water from below, rather than sprinkling on the leaves. Is that because of minerals in the tap water?

  • 19 years ago

    I think I will just turn off the hose until the ground dries up a bit if we get more rain...it hasn't rained for a bit here. We tend to get it in downpours (I'm in corn/bean country in Northern Illinois)

  • 19 years ago

    lol, sorry if I pressed some buttons. When I read about watering and removing some tomatoes I had to call BS because it didn't work for me. I can only say what worked and same for you guys too.

    Didn't mean to press any buttons. lol

  • 19 years ago

    I hope these Earth Boxes solve the problem of water, how much, what's too much.....if these do the trick for me this year I might never plant inground again at least not for tomatoes. I thought soaker hoses might be the solution but reading "kterlep's" situation even those can be troublesome. I just want what works.

  • 19 years ago

    As long as we're "speaking from our own experience" ...

    From time to time I've had BER on a few plants like Roma in the past and Silvery Fir Tree more recently, but nothing serious or longterm. Yes, they seemed to grow out of it.

    The only time I have experienced wholesale BER was when I tilled too close to the plants while they were developing green fruit. That was in a large, open cultivated garden, sandy loam soil, lots of direct sunlight from sun up to sun down. I had ammended with Epsom salts and bone meal in the planting holes and 9-12-12 side dressing.

    Everything was hunky dory until a few rain showers and a short vacation led to rampant weed overgrowth which I addressed with a roto tiller followed by heavy straw mulch. BAM! BER on all my first ripening fruit ... across the board ... Indian Stripe, Wisconsin 55, Aunt Ruby's German Green, Ramapo, Brandy Boy, Djena Lee, beefsteaks, canners, whatever and all else but the cherries.

    My theory in that case is I tilled too close to the plants and broke too many feeder roots thereby interupting calcium uptake. Yes, I should have used a sharp hoe and deftly sliced the weeds at the surface as my father trained me to do ... but it was hotter'n blue blazes, and I can always conveniently blame my laziness on my heart condition.

    Hey, I'm sure there are other causes of BER, but I think they too are related more to uptake and distribution of calcium to the developing green fruit rather than calcium deficiency in the soil.

  • 19 years ago

    sunsi

    What variety of tomato are you growing? Some tomato varieties are just more prone to BER than others. Romas/paste tomatoes seem to be the worst, while cherry tomatoes don't seem to develop it. You might check out the Manalucie Tomato variety. It's listed as being BER-resistant, and not many varieties are listed that way.

  • 19 years ago

    There is just something about BER that pushes our panic buttons. Each year we are so eager for those first tomatoes, we watch them set and begin to grow, we can almost taste them! And then we discover that black rot on the bottom of the first few fruit! Presto! PANIC! and we start frantically looking for a quick fix.

    Or we try all sorts of things and when it goes away (all on its own), we convince ourselves that we discovered the cure for BER!! ;)

    We have to learn to NOT panic. To recognize BER for what it is - a natural response of the plant to some stressor we likely can't even ID much less prevent or control. Best we can do is to test our soil and then amend as needed before planting, stabilize the watering as much as possible, not plant too early when spring weather can cause it, don't till too close to plants, hope for rain but not too much of it, mulch well from day 1, avoid the BER prone varieties, avoid high N fertilizers, and then cross our fingers and tell ourselves - "I will not panic if I get BER on the first few tomatoes because it will go away and the rest will be fine". I tell myself that every year - mutter, mutter - as I am pitching BER tomatoes off into the woods for the squirrels. ;)

    My fingers are crossed for you and your garden.

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    I use Skim milk at planting time for my calcium. Since I dont plant that many plants it's convenientand cheap. Don't know if it works but I live in the PNW and I don't get BER even though it can be wet up here.

  • 19 years ago

    Hoosier,

    Root pruning definitely causes BER!

  • 19 years ago

    BER.... Wheres G-Fish when Ya need him? Comon bring in the General.....Geeze Ber always happens to my first June pickins......then it settles down after that.

    What ? never had it before? well fine and Dandy.....but just suck it up and Grow on....

  • 19 years ago

    Here's my two cents: When I grew tomatoes in the ground, I had a lot of Ber problems. I suppose I just believed it wasn't necessary to water every single day. Bad mistake. Since I started using only vertical gro bags to grow my tomatoes, I've had zero Ber for three years. Using vertical gro bags forced me to realize that container-raised tomatoes, whether ground containers or hanging gro-bags, have NO access to ground water. Now, when my tomatoes reach mid-size to mature, with lots of tomatoes, I water every day. Since doing this, no more Ber. I now firmly believe that IRREGULAR WATERING is THE RECIPE for developing Ber. I agree completely with what some of the other writers are saying here, in order to get the calcium out of the soil and into the plants, REGULAR WATERING is the key. Sure has worked for me.

  • 19 years ago

    I have also had BER problems early and it went away after June (after my plants were taller than 24"... As a result I pick all of my blossoms until the plant is at least that high. I figure why waste time growing rotton tomoatoes when the plant could be using its energy to grow taller???...

  • 19 years ago

    I grow in DIY E-Boxes. Never had any BER Problems until two seasons ago. I guess I've lost 10% of fruit and it persists through the season. I top off the water reservoirs every other day. I amend with one cup of dolomite lime as per instructions. After eliminating the obvious, I 've come to the conclusion that the salinity of my well water is the most likely culprit. We've been in a drought for the last two years and as I live on a barrier island, I may be getting saltwater intrusion. The conductivity of the well water has gone from 680ppm to 970ppm. I'll be planting a fall crop after our usual heavy summer rains. Hopefully the well water conductivity will drop to more acceptable levels. We'll see. Garaj

  • 19 years ago

    This is my 2nd yr. in sw VA. In TN I never had a BER problem, but up here, it is common. Our nighttime temps are often in the 50's throughout summer. We WILL have a greenhouse before long, but meanwhile my tomatoes are taking forever to ripen and then getting BER. I am growing cherries, Abe Lincoln, and another variety (?) - 4 nursery bought plants. All plants are bearing satisfactorily, even heavily, but the BER is discouraging.
    My soil is rich and dark, teeming with earthworms thanks to my pony's well-composted contributions. It was all originally an acidic rhododendron thicket (cleared with roots pulled out entirely) to which I have added soil, compost, and aged manure. As far as the tomatoes are concerned, something is evidently lacking. Lime? Bonemeal? Any other Appalachian gardeners with a good solution? Thanks. I do love it up here - no ticks or chiggers!!! Heaven!

  • 19 years ago

    I have an Earthbox, a homemade clone EB and a 5 gallon plastic bucket and five different varieties of tomatoes. I experienced a limited amount of BER in all during a period of unusally wet and cloudy weather here in Wichita Falls, TX, usually hot and dry. The self-watering EBs have a constant moisture level in the potting mix and the bucket gets watered daily and drains. In my situation the variable was cloudy damp weather. Fertilizer was 10-10-10, dolomitic limestome added per EB instructions. When the weather got normal the BER went away. Seems to me many things or combinations of things can cause BER.

    cushman

  • 19 years ago

    I used to get some BER back in my old chem days. Maybe Timmy is onto something here about the blue stuff???

    I seldom get it now. None this year or last year at all and I've harvested about two hundred pounds of fruit so far this year. I use fish/kelp as my fertilizer very early in the season. That's all the fert my plants get. By late May they get no more fert the rest of the season. Compost and more compost. Raised bed, soaker hose, good mulch. Seems to work here great...:)

  • 19 years ago

    I just did a little reading on what timmy posted above about the blue kool aid making it more possible your plants will get BER. I found this at UMASS:

    When sidedressing nitrogen, the nitrate forms (such as calcium
    nitrate) are preferred over the ammonium or urea forms. This
    reduces the chances of blossom end rot to occur on the developing
    tomatoes. Avoiding excessive levels of soil potassium
    will also reduce chances of blossom end rot.

    To read the whole article go here:

    http://www.umass.edu/umext/ipm/ipm_projects/vegetable/nevmg_tomato_field.pdf

    My only interest here is curiosity. Please don't think I'm some organic nut trolling for converts. Each of us makes our own decisions and we must respect others if we wish them to respect our own. All I know is BER went away when the blue stuff did here in my little corner of the planet.

    I hope one of our resident scientists chimes in on this. I went to some education sites and had no idea what i was reading...LOL

  • 19 years ago

    from what I have seen of BER over the years, BER is most likely caused by the weather. You can put a whole bag of calcium around a tomato plant, and water it religiously, but if mother nature wants you to get BER, you will certainly get BER!!
    I tried the variety called Beefy Boy this year for the first time. Big mistake. From 8 plants, I have been able to only pick a dozen or so that did not get BER. And Beefy Boy has an inferior taste too.
    All the tomato growers in this area are having a bad problem with BER this summer, with various varieties. I have ten different varieties of tomatoes......most have BER; Beefy Boy is just awfully prone to it here.
    Whenever people tell me lack of calcium or water is the cause, I just look at them and shake my head at their ignorance. I get my opinions thru years of experience, not by reading a book written by someone that doesnt know what they are talking about.
    Just my two cents worth......scorn if you want!
    My advice: plant varieties you have found to be resistant to BER in your area. and grin and bear it.

  • 19 years ago

    Hopefully it should not take an insult useing inferred vulgarity to spark a lively discussion.
    Especially to one of the most experienced tomato experts in the world. Namely Dr.C.
    I suggest an apology from "naturalstuff".
    In my limited experience, our maters experienced severe stress midway thru, lack of consistant water,and bent over plants.
    The fruit set from that point experienced BER. As the plants recovered with correct watering schedule, the fruits from then on are all "perfect"

  • 19 years ago

    BEST WAY TO GET RID OF BER: DON'T GROW BER SUSCEPTIBLE PLANTS!!

    Only from my limited experience of course, but have grown 50-60 varieties over the last 3 years, and the only varieties that have had ANY fruits get BER have been Green Zebra, Purple Russian, and Wapsipinicon Peach. All of these plants in all areas of my garden in both years that I grew these varieties had plenty of BER. No other variety got it. Got rid of all 3 this year, no BER. Too bad, I loved the flavour of all 3, but had to throw away at least 50% of each variety.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions