Software
Houzz Logo Print
snoop92

Best tasting Brandywine strain?

18 years ago

There seem to be many different kinds of Brandywines.

Any opinions on the best tasting color and strain?

For example, I've heard that the Yellow Platfoot strain and the Brandywine OTV, as well as the Pink Sudduth are good ones.

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, try some and see. I've found that the soil they are grown in affects the taste. I always add a couple of shovels of good ol' North Georgia Red Clay to my containers (well mixed of course). It just seems (to me) to intensify the taste. Everywhere and everyone is different. If you try one and the taste is off a bit, make spaghetti or lasagna or tomato juice. Just keep the tomatoes coming.

  • 18 years ago

    If you do a search on this forum for favorite tomatoes or best tasting tomatoes or growing list, you will find threads with many lists of favorites.

    Taste is subjective ie I have good taste and everyone else's taste is questionable if they don't agree with me, lol.

    I too search for the best tasting tomato as my garden space is limited.

    I am growing seven varieties this year and have six different varieties planned for next year with a couple cherry tomatoes. After a little research for sweet cherries, the two I picked are Sun Gold and Sugar Shack.

    Good luck,

    John

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks to everyone for the responses!

    Carolyn, thank you for the wonderful details. Now, I feel more educated about the Brandywine family!

    By the way, I am growing in Northeast Ohio.

    I have no idea what kind of Brandywine I have in my garden because the label just said "Brandywine." Often, there is no further description, so I am always curious exactly what type of Brandywine it is. When I ask the sales people, they usually don't have any knowledge about the plant other than what is on the label.

    We'll see how this one turns out. Last year, I unexpectedly got what I think were Brandywine tomatoes in one of my pots. They were the best tasting tomatoes, but I have no idea what kind they were....kind of an intense reddish-pinkish color with the shape of a Brandywine, albeit dwarfed because it was growing in a pot. Ever since then, I have a real curiosity about Brandywines...(of course along with all the other heirlooms :))

  • 18 years ago

    I'm growing Brandywine for the first time this year. I don't know which strain they are. I bought the seeds last summer when I was visiting Monticello. Supposedly these are Thomas Jefferson heirlooms....I hope that's true! They have set fruit well here in Georgia although they were a little behind my faithful Better Boys. I don't even know what color they are since they are still green....we'll see. I hope they're good, I have half a garden full of them!

  • 18 years ago

    lisalu, Check your seed pack and see if it doesn't say Southern Exposure Seed Exchange b'c for years they've had a seed rack at Monticello.

    And no, for the most part the varieties sold there as seeds are not ones that Thomas Jefferson grew back in the late 1700's and early 1800's. There's a wonderful book by Jefferson called the Garden Book, or something like that which details which varieties he did grow and there were few around at that time anyway.

    Brandywine was not one that he grew.

    Carolyn

  • 17 years ago

    Glicks,Sudduth and Yellow Platfoot

  • 17 years ago

    My 2 cents: grow Red Brandywine (regular leaf). It's more productive than Brandywine Suddith and tastes very good. I grew it two years ago and was impressed. I probably got 30 fruits off one plant, and there was very little cracking and no BER.