Software
Houzz Logo Print
colokid

Does it help to talk?

18 years ago

Does it help to talk to the tomatoes? I dont talk to mine, but I find myself handling them , like placeing branches back it the cage etc every morning. All most petting them. I think you are not supposed to do this cause it spreads problems, but I have the best and finest I have ever raised.

Kenny

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago

    I would talk to the toms. IF it does not help the toms it will certainly help you. But always remember you and your toms are ONE. thus you are simply talking to yourself. I do it all day long.

  • 18 years ago

    Talking to plants helps because when you lean close to a plant and talk to it, you exhale carbon dioxide right by the stoma so it can get sucked into the leaves.

    I would say it also helps because it helps you forge a connection to your plants, therefore you notice problems earlier, and you are less likely to neglect it.

    But who listens to me, I'm a loony who talks to her plants. *grins*

    As for petting it, as long as you are being super gentle, then it shouldn't be too bad to the plant. And if it helps you forge a connection to the plant, then it's a good thing.

    To get something to grow, you have to love it.

  • 18 years ago

    You got to be kidding! Or you all need therapy.

  • 18 years ago

    Isn't stroking the leaves supposed to be good for them? Makes the plants stronger or something.

  • 18 years ago

    drtomato;

    Human beings have relatively helpless infants who survive only because adult humans feel compelled to love them and care for them. Parents will do things that annoy them and cause them stress to care for these helpless creature, because of their love.

    Connecting that ability to love something is actually one of humanity's best survival mechanisms. Through that connection we have motives that aren't just dependent on being intellectually aware.

    Example: I love my cucumber plants. I go out and talk to them every day. "Well aren't you growing like a champ! I'm so proud of you!" One day I noticed vine borer eggs on them, because I was spending time with the plants everyday and looking at them. Because I have a ritual every day that I enjoy that brings me into contact with the plants, I don't ever forget to water or weed. I breath on the plants, and they use the carbon dioxide--and anyone who has ever grown plants in a terrarium knows carbon dioxide is good for plants.

    I don't think the plants respond to the love because they can hear me, or through some mystical connection. I think they respond to the extra care that love makes me give them.

    But it does make my plants flourish and it makes me happy, so who the !#@$ am I hurting?!

    Oxytocin--the chemical we release when we feel love--is a very powerful thing.

    -Diane

  • 18 years ago

    ~~~ Does it help to talk to the tomatoes? ~~~

    Um, that would sorta depend on if you expected an answer or not :-)

    Anything good for the gardener should be good for the plants. I don't quite call horse races like someone admitted to but I cuss and praise and everyday say good morning to my ladies while I give their blossoms a thumpin and check for problems or other maintenance needs :-)

    A sign of joy rather than drudgery?

  • 18 years ago

    Hey, I talk to our chickens. On the brain scan scale, that is equivalent to talking to a tomato. If it floats your boat, go for it! I personally have almost daily conversations with my roses.

  • 18 years ago

    gardenkitteh-

    We're talkin bout "TOMATOES"

    Lions eat their young.

  • 18 years ago

    "Isn't stroking the leaves supposed to be good for them?"
    Yes, I seem to recall something about that too. I think it was something I read about employees at a nursery walking by tomato plants producing bigger, stronger, healthier plants.

    I don't know of any scientific data that supports talking to tomato plants helps them. Music is supposed to have a positive affect.

    If people want to talk to their plants and think it helps then why not? Plants talking back might be cause for concern. :-) Personally I hate it when they do that. :-) Spouting off their crazy political ideals and stuff. :-)

    When I talk to my plants it is more of a threatening nature. Like "you'd better start growing or you're going to the compost bin".

    Randy

  • 18 years ago

    Drtomato;

    Yes but humans are the ones growing the tomatoes. What gives us a motive to grow the tomatoes, is what's important.

    Lions don't eat their own young--the males eat the young of other males when they take over a new pride of females.

    But that's completely irrelevant. The fact is that humans are not lions and humans are really dependent on one another. A human woman who is pregnant in the later trimesters, or nursing an infant definitely needs the help of another human being or she and her baby will not survive. A young, healthy person can live on their own in a place without technology, but if they get sick, then they are gone.

    Humans mostly survive through communication and cooperation. We survive best when we have a group of people to depend on. Because we need people, we develop bond off affection that help us enjoy what we need.

    And that is why it's good to develop a bond of affection with out tomatoes. Because it takes what could be drudgery and makes it enjoyable to the humans. It is good for tomatoes to be talked to because it encourages the human to take good care of the tomatoes.

    But I majored genetics and biochem, so I tend to look at everything from a biological/psychological standpoint. *smiles*

    I could be wrong.

    Dave1nm2;
    My tomatoes are all boys, for some strange reason. My cucumbers switch genders. My squash are girls. Beans, always boys. I have a weird transsexual garden.

  • 18 years ago

    Gardenkitteh,

    Tomato vines are curvy and the fruits, luscious, definately female.

    We should stop there, this is a kids show :-)

  • 18 years ago

    I stand corrected. Wouldn't that make the cucumbers male?

    I thought of them as boys because the little unripe tomatoes resemble. . .

  • 18 years ago

    Hey, you can talk to them because they are talking to each other:

    (from the Dailymail,UK)
    "Injured tomato plants can even 'talk' to other plants by releasing a chemical warning signal into the air.

    Any tomato plants in the vicinity respond to the signal by releasing their own chemicals to deter attackers or attract insect predators."

    Here is a link that might be useful: Talking to plants?--you're not crazy

  • 18 years ago

    Great link, Farkee!!! Good information, especially now that I have to brush against some of the tomatoes since they've grown so. Sometimes I play opera music when I'm in the garden. Not loud, just enough to hear it and enjoy. Madama Butterfly today. Tomorrow some Hawaiian. After that some Van Morrison. My garden friends are eclectic you see.

  • 18 years ago

    Mythbusters, the show on the Discovery Channel, did an experiment on talking to plants, playing music, etc.

    Here's an exerpt:

    "Seven small greenhouses were set up on the M5 Industries roof. Four were set up with stereos playing endlessly looping recordings (as having the Mythbusters actually talk to the plants could contaminate the samples with their expelled carbon dioxide): Two of negative speech, two of positive speech (Kari and Scottie each made one positive and one negative soundtrack), a fifth with classical music and a sixth with intense death metal music. A seventh greenhouse, used as a control sample, had no stereo. The greenhouses with the recordings of speech grew better than the control, regardless of whether such talk was kind or angry. The plants in the greenhouse with the recording of classical music grew better, while the plants in the greenhouse with the recording of intense death metal grew best of all."

    LOL at the last sentence!

    Here is a link that might be useful: Mythbusters Experiment on Talking To/Playing Music To Plants

  • 18 years ago

    ummm, so they like death heavy metal ?

    well I sure would do anything for my tomato plants

    check out the catchy tunes on this CD :)

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:1342823}}

  • 18 years ago

    I would listen but it is after midnight and I don't want my daughter to wake up from nightmares. Maybe when I am alone in the house. :-D

    Plants and animals, unlike alot of people I know, tend to give as good as they get. My roses respond to their love and the people who are indifferent to what they are growing... it shows. (except weeds of course)

  • 18 years ago

    I don't talk to the tomatoes, but I do apologize to the weeds before I rip them out. I tell them that they're going to the Great Compost Heap and that in a circular cosmos all things come back again.

  • 18 years ago

    I have a book by Rev. Franklin Loehr titled: The Power of Prayer On Plants.

    One of the first prayer plant experiments of the Religious Research Foundation prayer circle was this two-pan corn planting. The prayer seeds on the left. Outgrew the no-prayer seven to three.

    A photo shows the plants.

    Karyl

  • 18 years ago

    Over my lifetime, I've talked to any and all airplanes, failing electronics, bugged computer software, un-caught fish, misbehaving golf balls, and anything else that served any purpose. I really think plants can "feel" when they are loved and cared for. Do I talk to them? Yeah!! I thought everybody did.

  • 18 years ago

    Have you ever wondered how people could walk by a plant that is crying to be watered, and give it no attention? You can just feel the plant trying to get you to water it. Some people are not aware it seems.

    Karyl