Software
Houzz Logo Print
cleo88_gw

anti-deer sachets

17 years ago

I ordered some organza bags but they turned out to be too small for bagging blossoms, so I turned them into anti-deer sachets (and I am bracing myself for the nothing-disuades-deer-you-are-doomed responses).

Inside I put:

Hair from the family's hairbrushes

Cat hair

Half a clove of garlic

Cut up chives from the garden (which are growing at the base of the tomatoes anyway)

Then I tied them at about deer nose level to some of the plants on the perimeter of the garden.

So far, we've spotted deer in the yard but they have not touched the tomato plants; I felt like it was only a matter of time before they got interested.

Any improvement suggestions are welcome!

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    Any improvement suggestions are welcome

    ****

    Well, you could do some control sachets and place them all at one area of the periphery of the garden so that you know if your deer sachets actually work. ( smile)

    Just stuff the control sachets with something like toilet tissue or some other non noxious stuff.

    I'm a big believer in doing controls so that one knows if something is working, or not.

    Carolyn, who has her own personal herd of about 12-15 deer who hang out in the area of her home but they've never eaten anything but the roses, to date. And living in the most populous deer county in NYS I can assure you that if something has been touted as repelling deer, it's been tried and........well, you didn't want to know the results, so........(smile)

  • 17 years ago

    Have you tried putting bars of ivory soap around your garden? My mom was having problems with them eating her sweet potatoes to the ground. She put about a dozen bars of ivory soap on top of stakes around her garden and now the deer no longer bother anything in her garden.

  • 17 years ago

    Carolyn,
    I've read on other posts of yours how the deer do not bother your tomatoes, and I say you must have been born under a lucky star. My sister, who lives in a thickly settled suburb where deer are not usually too much of a problem, had her tomatoes eaten to the ground by a large buck who had plenty of other choices in her yard. There were yummy hostas (deer candy!), every kind of shrub and flower - yet he chose to leap the chainlink fence and stick his nose through the tomato cages and eat the plants to about six inches from the ground.

    In addition to her store-bought Brandywines and Sweet 100s, I gave her some of the coolest varieties that I started from seed: Earl's Faux, Cherokee Purple and KBX. Big bummer!

    Jeremyjs: I will try sticking some pieces of Ivory soap around - can't hurt! Thanks.

  • 17 years ago

    Cleo, the deer have eaten my tomato plants when I was growing them elsewhere, at a place where no one was around most of the time, so I know what they can do. Amd I've seen the damage up and close and personal, but you're right, I'm lucky b'c here at my home they've only eaten the roses.

    BTW, the soap I've seen suggested most often is Irish Spring, and it doesn't work either. Maybe a bit initially, but they get used to almost anything that's put out and then just ignore it. Deer are NOT dumb!

  • 17 years ago

    My son is a deer hunter, so the deer eats some of the plants and we eat some of the deer.

    A few years ago, my wife discovered that the deer had eaten a lot of her choice plants and flowers. She asked my son if he knew anything that would repel them. He replied that deer were universally intolerant of human scent. You should have seen all those dirty socks, undershirts and clothes my wife left around the flower beds. What a sight, but it worked! They did have to be changed often though. (around the flower beds) LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Here is my experience with deer and human scent, et al.

    I have a herd of "walk through the yard twice a day in daylight, eat plants on the porch at night" deer, so I did a little experiment. I planted some of my left over seedlings at a couple of places out at the edge of the property and tried a couple of things, and found out that:

    1)Human urine deters deer from eating tomato plants, but they have no problem eating the plants right next to the ones you pee on.

    2) Around here deer do not like reaching through fences so tomato plants in cages are not bothered (as much). I can even put a little supermarket wire cone cage next to the plants and the deer will leave it alone and go after other nearby uncaged plants.

    3) Killing a deer and putting it next to your garden as a warning does not work for long. One of these test patches is right next to the remains of a deer that died of natural causes a year ago spring. The deer stayed away from their dead friend for a month or so but then resumed their usual habits, even though the remains stank. They now step over the bones to eat a peed on tomato plant the day after it rains.

    Deer walk through my garlic/onion patch to eat other things including strawberries inter planted in the garlic. If you are making a hot pepper extract adding garlic affects taste and the scent warns deer that they are going to get a mouthfull of hot.

    Wild deer are going to be much more jumpy than deer that live their lives foraging through back yards. In residential areas there is always going to be someone who is feeding the deer = human scented corn/goodies (and noone that is trying to kill them), so human scent is probably not going to work.