Software
Houzz Logo Print
ikea_gw

How effective is Serenade against early blight?

16 years ago

I have the onset of early blight on my tomato plants. I bought serenade and have been spraying them weekly for the past few weeks. In the long run though how effective is Serenade against early blight?

Comments (17)

  • 16 years ago

    In my experience, not very. I can't say whether it's better than nothing as I have not done any careful comparison. But it's never done more than slow (at best) the spread for me.

  • 16 years ago

    It would be better to alternate between different products. Actinovate would be one and Regalia would be another. Ami

  • 16 years ago

    I used it year before last and was not impressed. I have had better results from Daconil, corn meal soak spray, potassium bicarbonate, Actinovate, and 1/2 strength (1.5% hydrogen peroxide) sprayed on at dusk. Not all of above mixed!!!
    Use a different spray material every couple weeks. Don't mix
    other materials with the hydrogen peroxide!

  • 16 years ago

    I assume Actinovate is also organic and can be used on vegetables? How do you make corn meal soak spray?

  • 16 years ago

    I guess another question is how long I can hold off early blight so that I get a decent production out of my tomato plants. Right now there are only a couple of yellow dead leaves. All the other blight leaves I pulled off had just 1 tiny little dot of blight. I assume those will grow into larger circles if I hadn't pulled them off. My tomatoes are setting fruits but they just started doing that. I feel very torn between organic and the chemical solutions. I think I can live with a lower production as long as it isn't more than 30% lower.

  • 16 years ago

    I've used Serenade, and Daconil in the past, and serenade is effective, but requires frequent spraying - Daconil does as well, but I feel you need to apply Serenade more often to get the same efficacy.

    That being said, it does seem to work if used often enough and I prefer it to Daconil since I prefer to stay organic. I'm not a commercial farmer trying to scrape every last penny out of my harvest, I just want to get a decent harvest of organically grown tomatoes. I don't need perfect plants, just want to help them along a little.

    I may try Actinovate next since I've heard good things about it, but I currently don't have a local source for it.

  • 16 years ago

    homegardenpa, yeah that is how I feel about Daconil as well. I know it works but I just can't bring myself to using it. I am willing to take some loss to stay organic. I bought Actinovate online from Amazon, so it will be here next week. I will alternate that with Serenade. How often do you spray Serenade?

  • 16 years ago

    You can get Actinovate from Amazon.

    And the price has dropped now, too.

    Cindy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Amazon

  • 16 years ago

    I've used Serenade and found it effective. I have not tried
    Daconil as the Serenade worked well enough for me (except
    last year against LATE blight). I do agree that you
    probably have to spray more often but you should be using
    a spreader-sticker to reduce that requirement. I sometimes
    alternate with copper soap and my crop is normally fine.

    By the way, you can get Serenade much less expensively if
    you buy it in a larger quantity from the manufacturer's
    rep. I don't remember who that is and am not repeating the
    research just for this post. If there is a lot of interest,
    I'll see what I can find out. Last year, I bought a 7 lb.
    bag for $70, free shipping. That's so much that I gave
    away a few pounds here on the forum. Compare that with
    Gardens Alive, where they get about $50 a pound. Also,
    Serenade can be stored and will last, according to the rep,
    for years. I sealed it in clean peanut butter jars and
    put it in a dark cabinet.

    I use about two teaspoonsful of powder in a gallon of
    water. The bag come with instructions for a large area
    (per acre) but smaller areas can be figured from that.
    You really don't need much.

  • 16 years ago

    sneezer2, what is a spreader-sticker? I plan to spray once a week and more often if the weather is wet. Sure hope it is enough.

  • 16 years ago

    Spreader-sticker is a material you mix in with the spray. It
    will be called just that though it may be of various brands.
    It consists of a surfactant to aid the solution in wetting
    the leaves (spreader) and a resin to keep the active
    ingredient there longer. A "good" garden store "should"
    have it but few do. Farm suppliers mostly have it and you
    migjht find some on the internet. Bonide makes one.

  • 16 years ago

    Would anything like baking soda or other household ingredient serve the purpose of spreader-sticker? I will check the local garden store to see if they have any.

  • 16 years ago

    Do you think baking soda has any surfactants or resins in it?

  • 16 years ago

    Spreader stickers are usually petroleum based. They make sprays cling to leaves instead of run off leaves. Think of watering cole crops like broc & cauli & how the water beads & rolls right off the leaves. Spreader stickers are supposed to prevent this, in theory at least.

  • 11 years ago

    Could neem oil be used as a spreader-sticker?


  • 11 years ago

    Priscilia,.. I don't know what " spreader-sticker" is but:
    Neem Oil spray is both a fungicide and pesticide.
    It is Organic equivalent of Daconil as fungus prevention and it also repels some insects.

    Sey


Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting