Software
Houzz Logo Print
madeira_gw

They taste like... nothing.

19 years ago

Sorry if this has been done before.. the search isn't working for me (comes up as 'post a message')

My strawberries tasted like.. nothing. Now, my tomatoes are acting similarly. I made a new lasagna garden this spring, so the soil should be OK. I have 4 varieties of tomatoes. The plants themselves are healthy, topping 4 feet now (maybe too big?), and the fruit are a good size. But no flavour at all. Is it the weather? It's been a cold wet summer.

Comments (25)

  • 19 years ago

    Wet conditions certainly doesn't help regarding taste. They can get watery and bland. Do other's agree with you that your tomatoes have no taste?

  • 19 years ago

    With the information at hand, I would simply be venturing a guess. Many things may have a bearing on taste or flavor, the weather, as you suggested, too much water, and/or lack of nutrients that the plants need.

    A new lasagna bed just made this spring probably has not had time to get well established and break down the materials that you put into it enough to make all the plant foods that the plants might want. Given the opportunity, the amazing root systems of tomatoes would probably grow down into the soil beneath the bed and find nutrients there, especially if the bed had been there long enough to leach them down into the soil and help make it fertile.

    Like I said, I am just surmising and do not know if doing some fertilizing or foliar feeding with a well rounded and balanced product would help your plants and the resulting taste, or not.
    Just my .02
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    Hope I'm not double-posting here.

    Yup, all agree that there is very little flavour.

    I was worried about giving them extra fertiliser, as the beds were new. (Nothing raw, though, all aged compost and newspapers) I gave them a bit when it wasn't raining buckets, but it's been raining hard most of the summer.

    Ah well, the herbs and flowers are all doing great!

  • 19 years ago

    I agree that it is a combination of the new bed (herbs and flowers require much less nutrients) and the weather most likely. What varieties are you growing? While taste is very subjective, to many of us some varieties are naturally just...tasteless. ;)

    Dave

  • 19 years ago

    I went to a tomato tasting event held after a week of rain and out of 80 varieties many, many tasted bland to me.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree -- too much water. But too much fertilizer can affect taste negatively as well.

    Two data points (anecdotes, not proof).

    I grew Pink Ping Pong tomatoes last year, as did another person at my organic community garden. We both used only homemade compost and mulch. I watered once a week; she watered every other day. I got 3-4 fruits a day at best; she got dozens. My plant was sparse; hers was a jungle. However: mine tasted complex and wonderful; hers were bland (she claimed she tasted a hint of peanut butter!).

    Earlier in the spring, another person at the garden mentioned that her snow peas tasted bland. I had just picked some, so three of us tasted hers and mine. Mine were sweeter. We both seemed to water the same amount and probably grew the same variety. The only difference seemed to be that she used an organic fertilizer, and I used only homemade compost.

    I've also grown varieties that were bland, though. What are you growing?

  • 19 years ago

    I have cherries, romas... and two 'table' varieties.. can't find the tags. (Oops) The BBC said that summer is coming now, so maybe the next batch to ripen will taste like something.

    Thanks, all!

  • 19 years ago

    Sunshine and heat are needed to develop flavor. Absent proper climate, there isn't all that much you can do. If you get a warm spell, the tomatoes should improve.

  • 19 years ago

    I just tried my first costoluto genovese of the season and am really disappointed. Like the original poster lamented, it tastes like nothing, pretty much. We have had a very wet summer here in Chicago. I think my soil is pretty good. Should I chalk up the lack of flavor to the wet summer or is it the variety?
    Thx!

  • 19 years ago

    Skipphin,

    It's the VARIETY. I really detest Costoluto Genovese. My plants were loaded with big tomatoes. I would take a bite, spit it out and toss the tomato I far as I could across the yard like a baseball. Then I would do it all over again (and again).
    Hope yours turn out better.

  • 19 years ago

    habitat_gardener Quote:
    "(she claimed she tasted a hint of peanut butter!)"

    rofl, allow me some amateur sleuthing does she have children perhaps. That is too funny!!!

    To the original poster my fiance lives in London also and has mentioned how much rain you are getting there certainly not great for gardening, poor thing. Like someone said hope for some warmth and sunshine and it may turn in your favor once again. Good luck. :)

  • 19 years ago

    I planted Mortgage Lifter for the first time after many good reviews. It's producing large, beautiful fruit but I am so disappointed with the bland flavor and mealy texture. It has very few seed pockets (where I think most of the flavor is) and lots of flesh, beautiful color but really bland. Very disappointing, I had such great expectations for this variety. Other tomatoes, garden peach and german pink from the same garden patch are superb.
    Sometimes I think the plants aren't what the label says they are. J

  • 19 years ago

    farkee,
    thanks for the info. I'm glad I only planted 2 of them!

    figtreeundrgrnd,
    you give me hope - my german pinks should be ripening soon.

    At least I have my sungolds to tide me over. The black cherries are coming in now, too, but I haven't tried them yet. Here's to hoping for flavor!

  • 19 years ago

    Madeira,
    Last summer was extremely wet in Vermont, and my tomatoes tasted like...water. Cherokee Purple, Pruden's Purple, Black Krim & and even the hallowed Brandywine. My peas & cukes, however, did great. This year's weather has been more balanced & the tomatoes have been great- same varieties plus Taxi, Bonnie Best & Jaune Flamme (sp?)

  • 19 years ago

    My Kellogg's Breakfast are a huge disappointment. This is my first year growing them. They are really pretty with very few seed pockets, but they have no flavor. Also, the texture is rather mushy. Since all my other varieties of tomatoes have great flavor, it can't be too much water. Either I got bad seeds or this variety is just not for me.

  • 19 years ago

    Well, I tried my first Juliet and Black Cherry of the season and both were very disappointing, too. Both had very wan, barely discernable flavor. My Sungolds are absolutely delicious. Could it be too much water, considering the sungolds are great? Have other people enjoyed their Juliets and Black Cherries? Maybe they'll improve - I hope so. My excitement for these tomatoes is starting to wane - 3 strike outs (I posted earlier about tasteless costoluto genovese) and 1 success. I really want a BLT and sungolds just aren't the perfect tom for that! Again, what do y'all think is to blame for this lack of flavor? Water? Variety? Something else?

  • 19 years ago

    Even though all the nutrients play a role in the development of a tomato I read that potassium (K) is considered particulartly important to flavor. (And no you are not supposed to just pile K on because that would imbalance everything else. It is just something to think about.) My soil is deficient in potassium so it is something I am always trying to remedy.

    ((I also did not care for Kellogg's Breakfast or Black Cherry--I will grow both again but not sure when.))

  • 19 years ago

    I like Red Oxheart for flavor/size combination. Recommend you give em a try. If you like a gentler, fruity taste......try Hillbilly or Pineapple.

  • 19 years ago

    Juliet, bleargh! Zillions and zillions of cute, red, completely flavorless tomatoes. The year I grew these was the one and only time I just stopped picking them and let them rot on the vine. Horrid, horrid, extremely prolific (did I say horrid?) tomato. Yuck.

    My votes for best flavor are: enough sunshine and some heat (October tomatoes don't taste anywhere near as good as August tomatoes), good varieties (yellow brandywine is my runaway fave) and...and...the rest is voodoo to me. Brandywines taste fab whether I use Miracle-Gro or my own homemade compost, Celebrity is boring whether I water weekly or never.

  • 19 years ago

    Ugh. I'm 1 for 4 so far in selection of tomatoes. Note for next year: No more cosuluto genovese; no more juliet; no more black cherry. The Sungold is a keeper. My German Pinks and Mexico's are looking huge and beautiful and will hopefully ripen soon. The Aunt Ginny's Purple is looking ok - hope remains for it, too.
    Thanks for the comments. so far. If anyone else has any thoughts on these varieties, I'd love to hear them.

  • 19 years ago

    I feel the same way about yellow pear that Reginacw does about Juliet.

    I can't understand Juliet--years ago I really loved it but seeds or purchased plants today just don't seem as good. It was good fresh and incredible dehydrated.

  • 19 years ago

    Add me to the list of those that do not like Black Cherry. Once growing it was enough for me. I did not like the taste nor how easily it split with the least provocation.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    We've had hot, dry weather for the past couple of weeks - a simmering 93 degrees today. Just ate my first Supersonic of the season - incredibly good! (with a sprinkle of Penzey's peppercorn dressing mix) I like the Stupice that I've been picking for the past two weeks but there is nothing, but nothing like a good main crop tomato. As for Kellogg's Breakfast - for a solid, almost seedless golden tomato, it's hard to beat but it doesn't have the juicy acidity that I enjoy in Supersonic. Still,I grow them both - they're good mixed in a salad and look great too.

  • 19 years ago

    skipphin, often I find the first tomatoes of the season unpalatable for some varieties. Sometimes I pick them too soon, sometimes there's just not enough heat for the flavor to develop... I don't know. This year, the first few crops of Sungold made me wonder why I planted it, but now, over a month later, I like them again, though I still think it's an acquired taste.

    I grew Juliet a couple years ago. It was ok, but not good enough to take up space in my garden again.

    I've grown Black Cherry in 2 different gardens for 2-3 years, and loved it every time. The only reason I don't have any this year is because the seedling that was labeled Black Cherry wasn't. It's Black Plum, which is prolific and which did not develop good flavor until a day or so ago.

    I grew Aunt Ginny's Purple last year and it was one of my favorites -- rich and luscious. It didn't produce many tomatoes, though. I'm not growing it this year because I like to try different large-fruited varieties each year.

    Sunsi, the friend who mentioned the hint of peanut butter in her Pink Ping Pongs does have a teenager. However, once she mentioned it, I tasted it, too, though it seemed to be more like "off" flavor to me.

  • 19 years ago

    I live in a cool climate that is usually dry in summer but every once in a while we'll get a good summer rain. Some tomatoes, particularly big-fruited, soft-skinned types, are prone to getting watery after weather like that. Smaller, firmer tomatoes are more resistant.

    I think lack of Potash will make tomatoes bland too. I think they can't create sugar when they don't have enough. I like to use a long-lasting source of Potash like Jersey Greensand. The fact that the strawberries are also bland--and strawberries are VERY easy to ripen--makes me suspect that this is the most likely problem.

    Some varieties of tomato are bland. Generally early varieties--such as are common in the UK where it is hard to get tomatoes to ripen--are the blander ones. It takes a while to build up enough sugar for more intensely-flavored ones, which tend to be late, less productive varieties.

    Also, generally, commercial varieties tend to be less flavorful than "backyard varieties", because commercial growers pick tomatoes quite green and hard, and artificially ripen them at the last minute with a little ethylene gas--so there was never any pressure to breed commercial varieties for flavor since they are bound not to have any.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting