Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardener_sandy

Don't like sweet tomatoes

17 years ago

I've grown lots of varieties of tomatoes over the years and the current trend seems to be towards those with the sweetest flavor. Personally, I don't like them. Tomatoes should be tart and have a bit of a bite to them. Sweet and insipid flavors just ruin the experience of a tomato sandwich for me.

So, a question for those of you who agree with me on taste. What varieties do you prefer in both full size and small fruited tomatoes?

Sandy

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    Ill agree on the insipid ones, especially if they are sweet and green. They really are not so much about being sweet but rather the other background characteristics - like Green Doctors unpleasant astringent aftertaste.

    A balance is preferred by me.

    It also depends on how one is eating them.

    I can send you tart tomatoes that can make you think twice about what you are asking. You'll think youre eating jello'd vinegar.

    Just stick to some of the older ones that have been around awhile like the campbells lines or Rutgers. or try some of Jay Scott's Florida lines (he doesnt like Brandywines either).

  • 17 years ago

    Link below is to one of several previous discussions on best acidic/acid tomatoes.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Best acid flavor tomato

  • 17 years ago

    I am like you; I do not care for the sweet tomatoes. Give me a stong bold tomatoe flavor any day of the week. I have found the following to be very good for a strong (not sweet) flavor:

    Mexico
    Druzba
    Zogola

    Next year I am trying:

    Aussie - 82 days: Supposed to have a very bold taste
    Neves Azorean Red - 75 days: This one is supposed to pack a real taste punch
    Sunset's Red Horizon - 70 days: Old-time intense flavor.
    Rutgers - 75 days: supposed to have that old-time classic flavor
    Cherokee Chocolate - 80 days: It has been getting good reviews for being a great tasing tomato.

    I'm still gonna grow Cherokee Purple, Paul Robeson, Marianna's Peace, Aunt Gerties Gold, and Goose Creek as well. My family and neighbors love these as well. So, I plant a few other varieties to keep peace in the house and neighborhood.

    Even though Cherokee Purple is not a real bold taste, I still like it in a salad. But for a BLT or other kind of sandwich give me that old time strong, fullbodied, rich out-of-this world tomato flavor.

    That is what I have for now. If I hear of any other varieties that strike a chord with me I will give you a holler.

    Tom

  • 17 years ago

    I disagree. I don't think the current trend is towards the sweetest tomato. I think the trend is toward complex flavors, and new ideas. As for insipid flavors, no one likes them. (not here anyway)

  • 17 years ago

    Sunset's Red Horizon - 70 days: Old-time intense flavor.

    *****

    Just a comment, but the SRH sold by Tomatofest is not correct for the variety and Gary knows it. The first two years he offered it was fine, a large red beefsteak that had great taste, but something went wrong re seed production somewhere and now it's a small red heart.

    The variety is really Rostova which Gary renamed to Sunset Red Horizon. I sent the last of my True Rostova seeds to Linda at TGS who also is listing the wrong variety, so hopefully in a year or two she'll have the correct variety as well.

    As for more agreesive taste varieties I didn't reread the link given by Dave b'c I'm too darn lazy this AM but if it's a non-sweet more aggressive taste you prefer then you might consider any of the earlier commercial varieties such as:

    Rutgers
    New Yorker
    Valiant
    Break O Day
    WI 55
    Sandpoint
    Tigerella ( aka Mr Stripey. a small red with gold jagged stripes) not commercial but very zippy taste
    Gold Ball

    ...... and heirloom varieties such as;

    Druzba
    Cuostralee
    Zogola
    Red Brandywine ( the true one)
    Neves Azorean Red
    Bogatyr
    Aunt Gertie's Gold

    ...... for starters.

    And if you have courage you can try:

    Noire des Cosebeauf
    Purple Calabash.

    Taste is individual and perceptual so what one person experiences as taste is often not what someone else experiences.

    For instance, above mulio said he experiences an unpleasant astringent after taste with the cherry green when ripe variety Green Doctors, but some others I know who have grown it haven't experienced that at all.

    I don't like the taste of Green Zebra at all and find it to be astringent but many love it and say it's sweet tasting. And on and on it goes.

    Two folks growing the same variety a mile apart may experience different taste results due to many variables such as soil, amendments used, how they grow their tomatoes and on and on. And at sites such as this one you've got folks from all areas of the country making suggestions and just think of the variables inherent it that.

    So the only way you'll know what appeals to you is to grow some out, different ones year after year, and see what does best with your soil, your amendments, your weather, etc.

    Carolyn

  • 17 years ago

    When it comes to beefsteak type tomatoes, I definitely prefer less sweet and more bold flavored tomatoes. If it's a cherry tomato, I usually like it sweet. But not on a sandwich.

    Indian Stripe and Caspian Pink are two good flavored beefsteak-type varieties I'm growing this year, but both are a little on the sweet side. Not too bad, though, they still make good sandwiches.

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio