Software
Houzz Logo Print
windclimber

Correctly monitering tomato plant moisture

18 years ago

I guess we all have our ways ..... from high tech to the finger poke at the base of the plant.

Then there are drip irrigators,... timers... soaker hoses,.. estimating the time from the last 1" rainfall,... meters,.. watching the plant leaves....

This has been such a different kind of season somehow. We have finally broke into summer here in this part of the midwest after near perfect rainfall amounts, spaced about a week in between to soak in deep and great temps for tomatos.

(Remembering our stuggling neighbors from the spring floods tho, hope you are all doing ok!!)

We have yet to water our mater garden, the plants just keep getting larger, lusher, with fruit and flower set just popping everywhere.

Under the straw the soil is still moist as far as I can reach with my finger....... Over watering concerns me.

Wondering how to gauge the exact time to pour the water to 'em. I think rainfall in the copious quantities has subsided, so from here on I can gauge it weekly , but how dry can I let them get without stressing them big time?

Are there ways to measure the plant levels internally in some way?

Tom

not really with that much time on his hands to dream up this stuff

Comments (22)

  • 18 years ago

    There are alot of factors that come into play when it comes to watering. I myself, dont water until the palnt tells me it really needs water. I hold back water as long as I can. I dont care if the fruits turn out smaller, its the taste that counts for me. I consider myself lucky to have lots of clay soil in my garden tilled together with healthy amounts of organic material better known as compost. So to answer your question, I water as little as possibble, but deeply.

  • 18 years ago

    I pretty much agree with sprtsguy - water as little as possible and only when the plants tell you it is absolutely necessary - slightly droopy plants early in the morning is a good sign that water is needed. Droopy/wilty plants mid-day to afternoon is NOT a sign that water is needed.

    I firmly believe that most gardeners way over water - even container plants tho they do need more than in-ground plants. Used to do it myself and the overall plant health and production is so much better now it is difficult to describe. Had a call from a neighbor today about all his tomato problems (BER, blossom drop, pests, yellow leaves, few ripe fruit, no taste, etc. He drove by our one roadside garden and wanted to know why my plants looked so good? Did I have rotting fruit, etc? Had to tell him no and explained once again about mulch and reduced watering - especially with all the rain. Will he listen? Likely not even tho I gave him a sack full of tomatoes. ;)

    But most do come around, once they can force themselves to take that first step and hold off on the water.

    But before we can convince folks to cut back on the water we first have to convince them to heavily mulch their plants. ;)

    Dave

    PS: Similar discussion over on the Vegetable forum. I linked it below.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Watering Basics

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,

    What do you use for mulch?

    I don't have leaves or pine tags but can buy hay.

    John

  • 18 years ago

    I use hay since we mow our own and it's free. Straw is great too but hard to get here.

    Dave

    {{gwi:10965}}

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,

    BEAUTIFUL PLANTS!

    Too little/irregular water can lead to cracking, mushy texture and some say watered down taste.

    With plants like that, you mush be doing something right.

    I will mulch with hay or straw next year.

    John

  • 18 years ago

    Too little/irregular water can lead to cracking, mushy texture and some say watered down taste.

    Actually John, I find it to be just the opposite - rather than too little it is too MUCH water that leads to cracking, mushy fruit, and watered down taste.

    Excess water/rain is the most common cause listed for cracking and watery taste.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Yes very easy to over water. We have been in a severe drought. I try to mulch heavy. But didn't have as much on earlier and the temps reached the upper 90's and 100's and was watering once a week and that was too much. I usually try to let the plants tell me but with my job that is not always possible. Going at least ten days now but have finally got some rain so haven't had to water much. Since going to mulch and drip irrigation I have cut my water bill 60% and the water prices have went up. I use whatever I have and can get free. I use all the loose hay around the stacks. Then straw when I can get it and grass clippings from the local recreation department. They all work great. JD

  • 18 years ago

    Good stuff and thanks for the link Dave

    Learned early on in the seed starting stage that letting the medium dry out completly was better than too much H2o.
    Thought perhaps as the plant started produceing, things could have changed in the uptake needs.

    I am kinda the sort that hangs on the tried and true methods, and checking early in the day for drooping along with the finger method sounds good.

    How would you check 6" down in the root zone tho without damaging the system? Is it like when they are seedlings?
    as you can rough em up quite a bit without it hurting too much?

    And is there a way to check the moisture level uptake in the stem, just to be haveing some more fun?

    Tom

  • 18 years ago

    Wally world has a really inexpensive moisture meter, that will get you in the ball park.

  • 18 years ago

    rfonte :

    Thanxs .... I'm sure a moisture meter would tell me the soil condition .., and close to six inches down as not to disturb the roots.

    I have seen them in the local owned stores and can discern the quality etc. online ( I don't patronize WM for any reason unless I am in a small town in my travel, and such in those cases the local business has been driven out of existence, and it is the only source of supply.)
    Tom, thinking the star on WM stores should be red in deferece to truth in advertising.

    Is it a practiced scientific method to check the uptake of moisture in the stem?
    I, not being a microbioligist (but if I can learn, I can learn big (smile), know that certain disease can interrupt the flow of nutrients and water up the main stem.

    Is the only way to check after the plant is pulled ?

  • 18 years ago

    Windclimber, I can't believe that the word "turgor pressure" popped into my mind. From 60 years ago college course...I must have been awake part of the time. If I remember, they had no way to measure it then and wanted a way. Pressure inside the cells. Can't find the little moisture thingeys in local stores . Have a "four way" tester from E-bay that I don't know if to trust or not.
    Kenny

  • 18 years ago

    I'm the same as a few above who only water when the plants tell me they need it.

    Dave, my two experiences using hay as a mulch, on my perennial beds, not my tomatoes, convinced me to never use it again.

    Salt hay is an alternative but hard to get and where I live straw is also hard to get and overpriced.

    Don't you have weed seed problems or do you just have superior weed free hay? LOL

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    Kenny-
    Thanx for the lead, think I could find a way into turgor pressure to measure the levels?

    Already started research... Alrighhht a mission. :)

    Carolyn........... I hope all is back to "normal after what had to be a frightening lightning strike earlier.

    Tom

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,

    Please respond to Carolyn's question about weeds and hay mulch.

    Would wheat STRAW be more weed-free?

    John

  • 18 years ago

    Soil water at six inches isn't going to tell you much if the roots go down three or four feet the way they do in midwestern prairie soils. Many of us have a natural clay hardpan that stops root growth at 8-12 inches, while others have an artificial hardpan at about the same depth from using a rototiller year after year, or left over from the original construction of the house (thin layer of top soil spread on the compacted construction site sub soil). I have garden plots with 8", 14", and ~unlimited soil depth (three feet of loam over sandy water table soil), so a water meter reading at 6" is going to mean very different things for each of these plots. I guess what I'm trying to say is that you need to understand what is available to the plant (under the plant) rather than try to second guess by what others do.


    Aside from water stress in dry soil, nutrient availability is affected by drying soil. Most nutrients are in the top foot of soil (less depending on how deep you mixed granular fertilizer, or maybe deeper if you used water soluble crystals like miracle grow). So for early season growth you do want to keep even moisture in the top layer, but that is when nature usually helps out.

  • 18 years ago

    So am I over watering?

    I have 2 container plants, the containers are probably 5 or 6 gallons each. I did read somewhere not to over water, so I reduced my daily watering when the plants started to flourish more. I was watering every other day, then I started watering every two days. Saturday I got up and looked out the window and the leaves were completely wilted. The tomatoes were still firm and the stems were still wet, but I watered them anyway.

    Help!

  • 18 years ago

    Forgot to mention, that as soon as I watered the plants with the wilted leaves the leaves perked back out almost immediately. I guess it's just confusing to have firm fruits and stems but wilted leaves!

    I am a newbie so still learning the ropes of watering, etc.

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, my two experiences using hay as a mulch, on my perennial beds, not my tomatoes, convinced me to never use it again. Don't you have weed seed problems or do you just have superior weed free hay?

    Carolyn - nope, no weed free hay. ;) And yes, I'd prefer straw if I could get it. There are some weed seeds in hay, how many depends on when it was mowed, eg. third mow hay is relatively seed free. But no, I honestly don't have much weed problems in the gardens regardless of the mow I use and the benefits far outweigh the problems.

    The secret, if you will, is to crack open the bales, spread them some outside the garden area, and expose them to the spring weather. Then fork the hay well as you are laying it in the garden. Most the seeds fall out before it reaches the garden bed. Lay it on THICK - 6-8 inches deep. Any weeds that sprout are easily pulled because they are very shallow rooted. As the hay ages it weaves and mats down preventing deeper weed germination and I just add another layer on top. It smothers the few weeds that have sprouted.

    Wheat straw is more WEED seed free but not wheat seed free. But it does have better insulation benefits because of the hollow core stems.

    Soil water at six inches isn't going to tell you much if the roots go down three or four feet the way they do in midwestern prairie soils.

    Spiced ham - I agree strongly with you that you have to know your soil and how it works (we can discuss the hardpan effects of tilling some other time ;).

    But if the soil at 6 inches is still moist then I figure the soil below that is also still moist and water isn't needed. Granted if it is dry at 6" it may still be moist deeper down but all the fibrous and adventitious roots at the 2-8" level that provide most of the water and nutrient migration for the plant may still need some water even if the tap root 12-16" down doesn't.

    I have personally never found a moisture meter that was accurate much less worth its cost and have tried several of them over the years - tho none recently so they may have improved. But if you want to try one please do other types of checking/comparison studies with it rather than relying exclusively on the moisture meter.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    green villegal-
    Not quite clear on " the stems were still wet "

    I don't do a lot of containers , but as with DW flowers , and what I gather from the container experts , as with raised beds the moisture content of the soil reduces drastically compared with inground.

    The sides are exposed to air and heat and so it goes with evaporation. It sounds like you have almost hit on the schedule your plants are requireing. If and as the thread evolves we may both learn some new things!:)

  • 18 years ago

    greenvillegal 7 - you don't mention the type or variety of your plants but I will say that with that small of a container - too small for any but the the dwarf varieties IMO - it is going to be difficult if not impossible to over-water your plants simply because they are going to dry out so fast in your zone 7.

    Stiff stems with drastically wilted leaves early in the day that quickly respond to water as yours are doing is the sign of a root-bound plant - the roots have filled up the container so there is little soil left to retain moisture. So to keep it alive until the fruit ripens, you are likely going to have to water at least daily if not more often as well as put the containers into large saucers where additional water will be availble to them to wick up as needed. You are also going to have to feed it at least weekly.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Dave,

    Try to find the online book on vegetable root growth. The tomato chapter has been posted here a couple of times. It clearly shows that the entire 3-4 ft depth is filled with roots from a mature plant, not just one or two tap roots. The horizontals turn downward, I'm guessing in response to drying soil, or maybe reduced nitrogen later in the season.

  • 18 years ago

    I have to say a cheap $5 moisture meter has helped me a lot. I have seen mixed reviews so maybe there are some lemons out there but I like the one I have. I tested it with known soil and it read correctly. Its much easier to test 6 inches down quickly. My containers are all over the place when it comes to water needs. The melon vine in the container seems to have little demand for water even though its now a large plant. The pole beans have registered as dry quite often and seem the most demanding water wise. I would hate to have to do the finger test so often. Watering on a fixed schedule would have under or over watered something.