Software
Houzz Logo Print
flynfox

Oak Tree

19 years ago

Hello all. In Oct 05' I purchased a Mexican White Oak (aka Monterrey Oak). I planted it down here in Edinburg, TX. The first spring it got a little new growth but then some unexpected cool weather killed the new growth and turned the tips of the other leaves brown. It has sat this way ever since. No new growth and the tips of all the leaves are brown. I deep soak it about once per month except winter (using winter loosely). Is it still just shocked, is it not suited for this area, am I doing something else wrong? Any suggestions? Thanks.

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    I'd be willing to bet it's dead. Easy to check. Scrape the bark near the bottom (root flare) and if you see green it's alive. I can't imagine watering anything with all this rain we've been having. I also don't know how well suited Monterey Oaks are to coastal Texas. Maybe someone else will. PJ

  • 19 years ago

    We have an oak that was supposed to be a Schumar Red Oak, but it's not. Not sure what it is, but very bright vivid yellowish green leaves - We really like the tree. Anyway, the first year we had it, the same thing happened as yours. We thought it was dead. We babied it a lot, and it came back. That was 4 years ago, and it's put on a lot of growth since then. But every summer the tips of the new leaves turn black and shrivel up. We're not sure what's going on with it, because it happens every year, and there are no other signs of stress or disease.

  • 19 years ago

    missinformation - You probably do have a Shumard red oak, BUT it likely has a bad case of iron chlorosis (inability of the tree to take up iron due to soil alkalinity). It is very common in the Austin area for Shumards to suffer from this b/c many of these were planted from nursery stock that originated in the eastern US (or even east TX), in areas with acidic soil. Also, other oaks native to these acidic soil areas (willow oak, water oak, etc.) will suffer big time in alkaline soil. Chlorotic trees exhibit bright yellow/chartreuse leaves with dark green veins, and often burn in the sun causing brown crunchy areas. Many trees suffering badly from this eventually die. By the way, Shumards that were originally native to central Texas don't suffer from iron chlorosis.

    flynfox - MX white oak should grow OK in south TX. These trees grow well into Tamaulipas natively, in areas that are both humid and dry.

  • 19 years ago

    I had pin oaks that suffered from chlorosis. I tried everything. I finally got the one that survived to do well by adding a bag of green sand to it each year. Going great now.

  • 19 years ago

    Check your White Oak to make sure it wasn't planted too deeply. That's one of the most common causes of death in trees. Also make sure the roots are girdling. If everything checks out okay, be patient. It's probably working on growing a good root system. We planted a Texas Red Oak in our front yard (actually it was professionally planted) and the first 3 or 4 years it barely grew at all. Then, all of the sudden it took off and nothing's stopping it now.

    As for Shumards, a lot of people end up with Pin Oaks, thinking they were Shumard oaks. Or, they could be cross breeds. Pin oak leaves look very much like Shumard leaves. The shape of the tree is different, though. In areas with alkaline soil, pin oaks will be easy to tell apart from Shmards because pin oaks will be yellow instead of green.

    Sally

  • 19 years ago

    Great info regarding shumard oaks.. http://www.cityofirving.org/inspections/red-oak.html

    Read this article! I had the same problem. I had 2 shumard oaks from two different places. One had light green leaves. Did nothing at all. Another one had dark green leaves and grew so much more. I live in caliche soil which is pretty high pH (alkaline). I agree it is a huge problem right now. I see so many shumard oaks being planting everywhere around here and they look like they're having chlorosis problems. It's just terrible. shame on nurseries trying to make a quick buck...

  • 19 years ago

    This a great thread and very helpful to me. We also bought another oak labeled Shumard, but the leaves are dark green, it grew very quickly compared to the first "Shumard" and it it much more upright and tight. The tree with the bright yellow/green leaves grows much more slowly and tends to spread out more than shoot up. It's much more open than the other tree. So do you think the tight upright dark green is my Shumard and the light green open tree is a pin oak with chlorosis? Is that color right for a pin oak?

    I'm going to give the green sand a try - I assume it adds acid to the soil? If I do this, do you think there's a way to eventually "wean" this tree off the acid so it's happier living here?

  • 19 years ago

    Missinformation-

    Most likely, the one with light green is a wrong type of red oak for your soil. I have seen those red oaks like that in my area. I'm sorry but it isn't worth the trouble trying to make it work in the long run. I'd replace it with something else. It has proven to be difficult to know if it's the right red oak for alkaline soil until winter when you can look at the buds but most stores esp big boxes stores do not sell them during the winters. Specalized nurseries should have them but not many to pick one out.

    Did you even read the article that I provided the link to in the previous post? It pretty much answers the million dollar question - can it grow in alkaline soil? I spent many hours trying to look for specific answer and found this article because I had the exact same problem as you and a lot of other people are having. I just decided to get rid of that tree and kept the one with dark green leaves. It just performs so much better...

    Greensand might help to a degree but it didnt do much for mine at all. It does not make soil more acidic at all. In fact, it is on the alkaline side. Oak trees will get huge and will get more difficult to treat this kind of problem. it just isn't worth it. You'd have to spend hundreds of dollars trying to fix it when you can spend 25 dollars for 5 gallon container tree to replace it and it will grow much faster if it is the right kind that can grow in rocky alkaline soil. i've seen them thriving everywhere in central texas. the key is where the seeds come from...

  • 19 years ago

    I did read it, I was just hoping for a different answer.

    We planted trees for each of our children, and this one is the one we planted for our autistic son. He's very attached to it, and we have taken his picture next to it on his birthday since his first birthday.

    We'll probably just have to let it go as long as it's able and deal with it when it gives out. If there are any amendments or specific fertilizers that might keep it going longer, I'd appreciate knowing about them.

  • 19 years ago

    Okay. I understand...

    Here's what I would do...

    Get rid of grass within 10 feet diameter of the tree. DON'T TILL!

    Buy an auger to be used on power driller. one inch wide is good. Make holes about 8 inches deep every foot within the 10 feet diameter. Spread 50/50 mixture of greensand and lava sand. You mix them together first before you apply on the ground. You probably will need 2 bags of 40lbs of each. You can get them at Lowe's. By far the best price of anywhere. Try and get them into holes. You can use push broom to fill in the holes. Then you will need to put down a layer of compost. My preferred is the big bag from Lowes called Earth Finest by LETCO. It might take 3 bags. I'm not sure.

    Then apply 4 inches layer of coarse hardwood mulch on the entire 10 feet diameter with nothing touching the tree/root flares. my personal favorite is the one from LOWE'S. I forget what it is called... Organic hardwood mulch? It is a clear bag with red label . It might take 2-4 bags. I have no idea how much to cover 10 feet diameter hole.

    Put down 25 feet(???) of soaker hose circling around on the mulch and let a trickle out to leave on overnight. You want VERY SLOW SOAKING. Don't turn it at full blast. Just drip, drip drip...

    You just put down new mulch on top of old mulch every year. NEVER LET GRASS TAKE OVER. Always keep the mulch around the tree. This will keep pH down a little bit. The soil biology in the mulch releases acid which will help lower pH but it is a slow process.

  • 19 years ago

    Can two-30 gallon monterey oak trees planted in different locations die within 2 weeks after planting? Were they diseased to begin with or was it overwatering or the combination? There are bores now, how would I be able to tell now which caused it?

Sponsored