Software
Houzz Logo Print
tom8olvr_gw

A soft yummy hybrid

18 years ago

Does anyone know of a soft fleshed, tasty, vigorous hybrid??

I know this will offend, but... I never met a hybrid I like - and I've been trying to figure out why... and I THINK it's because the ones I've tried are kinda hard and kinda orangey-red (if you know what I mean? - not that soft orange or gold I associate with a heirloom) and somewhat bland.

I think I recall someone saying that Black Brandywine was a hybrid... is that true, because I DID like that one...

Anyone? Suggestions? Comments?

Comments (14)

  • 18 years ago

    I think I recall someone saying that Black Brandywine was a hybrid... is that true, because I DID like that one...

    Anyone? Suggestions? Comments?

    ****

    No, Black Brandywine is not a hybrid.

    It resulted from a cross between Brandywine ( female parent) and an unknown black in the fields of a commercial grower in CA.

    And was dehybridized to the OP state. Some folks find it still isn't genetically stable.

    For a not rock hard variety with excellent taste I might suggest Supersonic and Jet Star, both hybrids and quite available. Of the hybrids I've grown I think these Harris varieties have the best taste I've experienced.

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    Does anyone know of a soft fleshed, tasty, vigorous hybrid??...

    Brandy Boy F1 produces large (8-18 oz) deep-pink (not wimpy pale-pink) fruits set on indet PL plants. Its thin-skinned fruits are usually a bit on the juicy side. Somewhat mild in taste but good tomato flavor is quite evident. Med-heavy producer.

    And not that the following has much significance, but not a few of Brandy's fruits (esp the first ripes) show some scarring on blossom end and cat-facing as well, however most have been relatively free of significant surface blemishes in my 4 years of growing it.

    Reg

  • 18 years ago

    The newer (at least in catelogs) Ugly hybrid variety fits the description that you want fairly well. These will be softer than Brandy Boy or Jet Star (I haven't grown Supersonic lately to compare). The variety is moderate in production, I'd rate it similar to Jet Star and much better than Brandy Boy.

  • 18 years ago

    The newer (at least in catelogs) Ugly hybrid variety fits the description that you want fairly well. These will be softer than Brandy Boy or Jet Star (I haven't grown Supersonic lately to compare). The variety is moderate in production, I'd rate it similar to Jet Star and much better than Brandy Boy.

    *****

    Neither Ugly nor Ugly Ripe are hybrids and I do hope that no one is represenbting them as such.

    Carolyn, who has followed the Ugly/Ugly Ripe story, with quiet fascination, from almost the beginning which was maybe about 5-7 years ago when only Ugly was being sold.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Carolyn, this is the first time that I have been able to find out that Ugly was not a hybrid. That should make it fair game for Tom's educated squirrels which he claims (like himself in one of his first postings on here) will not touch a hybrid.

    I shared the remaining seed that I had from the original packet that I bought (which did not indicate whether they were hybrid or not) but went ahead and fermented and saved quite a few seed, which looked considerably better than the seed that I bought. I also shared some of those with the usual disclaimer with the people that I sent the other seed to.

    I found them to be but a bit bland for my taste coming from my garden last spring, but we had so much rain that may have been the cause for that. My wife and one DIL liked the taste and rated it high on their list, but I would only give it about a 7 on my list last spring because it was sweeter and milder than I like. HOWEVER, after some hot, dry weather in late summer then an Indian summer type fall, several people that I shared them with said that they had never tasted a better tasting tomato.

    The tomatoes that grew from this variety in my garden were fairly uniform and smooth and none of them were particularly ugly.

    Another thing that Tom may not like about them (after seeing several of his postings complaining about tomatoes being "seedy") is the fact that they do containing quite a lot of seed and gel. To me that often is a more flavorful part of the tomato, but I do not know how Tom's squirrels feel about that.
    Just my .02
    Bill P.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with Carolyn. Jet Star and Supersonic are two delicious hybrids. They have been my favorites for years.
    Primetime is another hybrid from Harris that is an excellent tomato.
    Brandy Boy is good too, but nowhere near the production, at least for me, of these others.

  • 18 years ago

    Bill, you have quite a memory... about my squirrels... :) Impressed you remember my distaste for large loculed/seedy toms... And here I know nothing about you! :)

    Carolyn, what is the story about Ugly...? The supermarket in my area spells it UGLI. Gotta be the same...

    I'm contemplating Reg's suggestion on Brandy Boy.

    Thanks!

    Tom

  • 18 years ago

    Carolyn, what is the story about Ugly...?

    ****

    Tom, long story, which I'll shorten, about Ugly which then segues into Ugly Ripe and I'll get back to you later on this b'c today my closest friend from the last place where I taught is driving up from Saratoga for the day and I have stuff to do before she arrives.

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    I will give another vote for Brandy boy grew it for the first time last year and it will be making a return next year and I can only squeeze about 8 plants in contains at my townhouse.

  • 18 years ago

    BrandyBoy is an excellent hybrid.

  • 18 years ago

    Carolyn, what is the story about Ugly...? The supermarket in my area spells it UGLI. Gotta be the same...

    *****

    So here we are again and this is the short version, trust me. LOL

    The variety named Ugly was initially marketed by a woman who lives in FL who got it from a neighbor. The almost consensus is that it's a Costoluto type from Italy. Costoluto in Italian just means ribbed,and there are several known ones named for the places where they were found.

    Such as Costoluto Genovese, from Genoa and Costoluto Fiorentino from Florence.

    Life was perking along fine and Ugly was a sure name catcher and then the Procacci Bros of Philly entered the scene and brought out one they called Ugly Ripe to compete with Ugly.

    Ugly Ripe is the variety Marmande, an old English heirloom variety, that has a few disease tolerances bred in but is still OP.

    Some background info here. It was the Procacci Bros who sued Andrew Chu who made the words grape tomato a household name with the variety Santa F1 which was bred in Taiwan by the Known-You seed co. They were able to tie up the sale of Santa F1 in the US for many years and only they had access to seed. In Europe the ban did not apply so Thompson and Morgan and others were selling the seed , and I guess still do, at a highly inflated price.

    No US based Co can sell Santa F1 seed although they did before the law suit, TGS being one of them.

    Andrew Chu had access to F1 Santa seed elsewhere but could not use the word grape in his packaging of his product. Procacci sells them as Santa Sweets. I forget right now the label that Chu uses.

    Although it's a hybrid 99/100 saved seeds come true so thousands of folks have just bought the F1 fruits and saved seeds and many are now on the F6 thru maybe the F8 and it's still doing fine.

    So why am I telling you this? B/C the Procacci's are not the faves of many people, starting with their Ugly Ripe and then b'c of their law suit against Andrew Chu, and then they took over the Ugly people in a nasty takeover.

    So now they produce both Ugly and Ugly Ripe, usually in FL and Mexico in the winter and elsewhere in the summer.

    And then the FL Tomato Commission said they couldn't ship them out of FL b/c they didn't meet their specs, which are basically round reds.

    So the Procacci's sued again.

    And that went on for a long time and although I'd have to check I think the Procacci's won that one.

    I've grown both Ugly and Ugly Ripe , from saved seeds from fruits, and I see nothing at all special about them and there are hundreds of varieties I'd grow before growing them again.

    But the names are eye-catchers and that translates into sales, and for many folks who shop only at large supermarkets where they're sold, they're novelties, and so they buy them for that reason as well.

    End.

    Carolyn

  • 18 years ago

    Lovely story! NOT! :)

    How was your visit with the Saratoga guest?

  • 18 years ago

    So now they produce both Ugly and Ugly Ripe, usually in FL and Mexico in the winter and elsewhere in the summer.

    And then the FL Tomato Commission said they couldn't ship them out of FL b/c they didn't meet their specs, which are basically round reds.

    Right, Well apparently Procacci Brothers thinks that paying an annual fee of ~$250 K to a government agency to "certify" thay UglyRipe tomato has been produced according to the requirements of the "Identity Protection Program" (and is thereby worthy of being deemed a "product of Florida") is well worth the investment to circumvent the (I think archaic) requirements of the FL Tomato Commission for out of state sale of FL tomatoes during the winter months. Now I wonder how Procacci Brothers would react if the FTC dropped or lowered its requirements for such shipments. Would be none too happy I think. But you gotta admit that what they did was apparently legal. And a good business move that most smaller competitors could not afford. BTW anybody, are Ugly Ripes really that much better than others that can be had in winter months ? Reg
  • 18 years ago

    I have not found them to be any better than the tomatoes they sell on the vine - the cluster tomatoes. But lets face it they all look like and taste like orange painted rocks this time of year! :)

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting