Software
Houzz Logo Print
herus_gw

Travertine - a few questions

17 years ago

Two areas of our home are the target of updates, with tile. One is the sunroom which doubles as the breakfast room. Six chairs and a table. This is approx 10 x 13.

The other is the master bath. Approx 100 sq ft on the floor, plus 175 sf in the shower (walls, floor, ceiling) and about 40 sf around the jacuzzi tub.

Total of approx 340 sf.

The tile guy I interviewed was a recommendation from a casual friend who is a real estate investor and uses various contractors constantly. He did not tell me what rate he pays though.

When the tile guy came in we talked about some tile in the basement which I later decided not to do at all. At this time he said his labor rate was $2/sf with me providing all materials but the grout. When we went to the master he recommended travertine and then said that rate is $3.50, plus $1/sf for demolition work on the existing tile. So a rate of $2 is not $4.50...

Is this about right? He says travertine is more difficult to install than tile. But it seems they don't use grout on travertine - so that part seems like a reduction, not an increase (plus he doesn't have to pay for grout).

If it's proportionate to what people are paying (this is in GA) then that's ok, but really don't want to be taken into a bait-n-switch. Besides the yellow pages I don't really have other leads for tile people and usually try to go on recommendations as much as possible.

Also - I have done a bit of searching here for 'travertine' and find that some are less durable than others, esp with regard to color. He did mention sealing, but didn't specify if it is included in the cost of installation (I don't mind doing it; just looking to know if it is a standard part of an install).

Finally, the breakfast area will of course get wear with people dragging chairs with their weight on the chair and perhaps the occasional food spill. Is travertine hardy enough to take this without scratches/stains or should I consider something else, or perhaps a specific type of travertine?

Thanks to all...

Comments (17)

  • 17 years ago

    Some really quick thoughts. We put honed travertine in a bathroom in ATL a few years ago.

    I think you'd want very small grout lines, but grout lines nonetheless. It's going to be harder to install b/c of the variation in thickness and how close you're placing the tiles. A solid install will have minimal/no height variation (lippage) across adjacent tiles.

    I spent a while looking at various sources. Some folks here had decried the grout filled travertine in favor of epoxy filling of the natural voids. I didn't find a vendor that had the epoxy-filled. The price range I found for the tile was ~$2/sq ft at Floor & Decor up to $7 or $8/sq ft at some of the tile shops.

    I admit that thickness tolerance may make up for some of the price difference. I ended up going with the cheaper tile and did my best to be very picky about the tiles I bought.

    I don't have a reference for durability- ours gets light traffic. Using the grout-filled tile may be an issue, as the grout may deteriorate in spots and leave gouges/holes in the tiles.

    Sealing yourself is a snap- I like the water based sealers.

  • 17 years ago

    Let me start by saying anyone who would be willing to set travertine even for 3.50 a foot-- I wouldn't want doing my floor, much less TWO dollars a foot!!

    For a travertine floor, not including underlayment or prep, my price for basic 12x12 square set would START at 8.00 a foot, and I'm no where NEAR the most expensive around! Even when I lived in south Florida, where it's about as cheap as it gets, I was still getting 5.00 a foot for that same installation. The guys getting 2-3.00 a foot would come in, slam it down, get the check, and move on. Tail light warranty. End of story.

    Is that what you're looking for?

    Find another installer, and be willing to pay a fair price.

  • 17 years ago

    Bill_v, did your figures include materials (except the tile itself)? As noted, his price is $4.50 which includes demolition but NOT cement or backerboard. Rough calc including this leads me into the $10/sf range.

    Not to start any arguments in this area - PLEASE- but these boys are from South America - perhaps that accounts for some price differential. Combine this with the fact that the local building trade, like most areas, is hurting. In fact one of the 3 partners in this outfit relocated temporarily to Charlotte to take advantage of the better market there.

    I still don't know about my original question - is travertine more expensive to install than regualr ceramic/slate, etc? Thull, I'll talk to the guy about thin grout. BTW, I saw a travertine master bath one of them (the relocated guy) did in my own subdiv, and it has held up well after about 5 years.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Bill. WAAAAYYY too cheap. I'm also in the South, and a going rate here for the install of natural stone tile would be around $5-6 plus materials, and that would be from "tile guys" with little available background to be checked rather than true tile contractors who are licensed and bonded and have verification of their past work. Travertine is a lot harder to install than ceramic, needs a lot more maintainence, is softer and doesn't wear as well, and usually costs more. But, it's natural material and some people prefer that label regardless. I prefer function over form personally.

  • 17 years ago

    Not to start any arguments in this area - PLEASE- but these boys are from South America - perhaps that accounts for some price differential. Combine this with the fact that the local building trade, like most areas, is hurting. In fact one of the 3 partners in this outfit relocated temporarily to Charlotte to take advantage of the better market there.

    It would most certainly account for the price differential. I lived in Homestead, Fla., just after Hurricane Andrew, and at the end of the last big recession, when prices were super low, then as well. THAT was when they were getting 5.00 a foot for travertine. There was a crew of Cuban illegals running around South Dade, though, backed by a wealthy LEGAL Cuban immigrant, selling whole house tile jobs for 1.00 a foot, materials and labor included. They would decend on homes in groups of 10- 15 guys, and bang the whole house out in a day, and then grout it the next day. Believe me when I tell you, I saw some of their work. It LOOKED like 1.00 a foot workmanship.

    But that's okay. You go ahead and hire them, if you think you can save a buck. But you can bet it's going to cost alot more when a REAL tile guy has to come in and fix their mess.

    This is the last time I respond to this thread.

  • 17 years ago

    "This is the last time I respond to this thread."

    And still, only the second. Not much to say, then, eh?

    I should have known that any discussion of labor prices raises the hackles of those who feel that the 'furrners' and illegals are swarming into this country and stealing food from the mouths of the good ol' Murricans.

    Sorry but EVERYTHING is a global market nowadays. In fact on-site labor is still relatively less affected by this. I am a software developer - don't talk to me about low wage competition from overseas. Those guys don't even have to have the guts to run, swim and face danger to life and limb to steal my lunch.

    So I say hey - you want REAL software that doesn't break, doesn't melt your computer, doesn't steal your bank account information, hire an American! See how silly that sounds?

    Ah, forget it. Maybe instead of hanging around on forums you should be making money doing what you do 'best' and you wouldn't have to complain about people who have hearts, minds, bodies and families just like you do, except maybe their facial features and languages are different, coming to YOUR land (I wonder what Chief Sitting Bull would have to say about THAT).

  • 17 years ago

    Easy, there.
    I rarely post but have read enough Bill V. to know that he knows what he's taking about, and I didn't see anything in his post about someone not being able to tile because of lacking the right facial features. I believe he was talking about training and experience and a wage (and who knows, even benefits?) that is representative.

  • 17 years ago

    "I believe he was talking about training and experience and a wage (and who knows, even benefits?) that is representative. "

    Then why couldn't he say so? Instead, this: "There was a crew of Cuban illegals running around South Dade, though, backed by a wealthy LEGAL Cuban immigrant, selling whole house tile jobs for 1.00 a foot, materials and labor included. They would decend [sic] on homes in groups of 10- 15 guys, and bang the whole house out in a day, and then grout it the next day..."

    Does this sound like anything but chauvinistic nationalism to you? Where is the mention of training, etc? Because they are illegals (actually because they are foreigners trying to feed their families left behind in a dictatorship they managed to escape with sheer guts and luck), they are automatically assumed to be untrained/stupid/unethical...

    Let me lay a flash on you: the education level of the so-called 'legal' US population is nothing to write home about. Yes, Virginia, those 'untrained' foreigners have been taking this country away right under your very eyes and in the shadow of those pathetic mental abbatoirs we call schools, and will continue to do so at an accelerating rate (gee, look at all the 'untrained' scientists with Chinese and Indian names working in top positions at innumerable research institutions, universities and think tanks all over the country).

    If you haven't been seen by an Indian or Pakistani doctor yet, don't worry about being a part of an ever-shrinking minority - sooner rather than later, you will. Ya think those good ole country doctors with their little black bags and cuddly bedside manners (if there are even any left) are going around muttering "untrained foreigners"?

    The new day is already here but some people refuse to greet the sunrise.

    PS: You may have the dubious benefit of having read a lot of Bill V. Regrettably or otherwise, I have not. I read the replies to my post, here and now, because that was the question I requested an answer to, not the countless times he may or may not have gushed forth with words of gentle, noble and magnanimous wisdom. This was not one of them. In fact, at no point did he deign to even attempt an answer to my original questions. Can you say 'soapbox'?

  • PRO
    17 years ago

    Look, "Herus," Spin it anyway you want. You want a cheap job? Go for it. You want a quality install with someone that has a fixed address and has had the training and experience to properly do the job....that's something entirely different.

    You can buy oats for $5 a bushel. If they've already been through a horse, the price is considerably cheaper.

  • 17 years ago

    Does this sound like anything but chauvinistic nationalism to you? Where is the mention of training, etc?

    No. It sounds like unfair trade practices (paid under the table, no contractors liability, no comp, no unemployment, no license) depressing the industry, as well as giving sh*t jobs, giving the trader a black eye, as well.

    Look, you want to hire these guys, you get what you pay for. But then when it all goes south, don't expect a bargain basement price from a REAL tile guy to fix it all. Additionally, don't blame it on the tile as a bad finish. Blame it on your own stupidity for not hiring a qualified installer in the first damn place!!

    As for your original questions, ask your installer. I'm sure he'll have the answers for you. As for my qualifications, I'm not good enough to tile your house.

  • 17 years ago

    "You can buy oats for $5 a bushel. If they've already been through a horse, the price is considerably cheaper."

    How terribly clever of you. Your original pithy saying, no doubt?

    Here - I'll try to make it easy for you and Bill.

    Just.
    Read.
    The.
    Original.
    Post.

    I didn't ask what quality it was likely to be. I asked mainly (with a bit of follow-on about travertine itself) whether it cost more to lay travertine than regular tile. One of the respondents to my post provided an answer. The ones who answered the unasked questions need to take Remedial Reading for Comprehension. And don't pick your original school. They teach reading about as well as some people lay tile.

    Over and out. And unlike Bill, I mean it.

  • 17 years ago

    You really needn't be so rude to folks just because you didn't like the answer they provided. Your rant was extremely uncalled for and far more offensive than any "hidden message" that YOU inferred from Bill's post. Put that chip off of your shoulder and take the advice of an experienced professional. Or don't. But don't give him hell about something that he didn't even say. YOU are the one who first introduced the topic of the nationalities of the "tile guys" and implied that their immigration status was a factor in their pricing structure. not Bill.

    You owe Bill and eveyone else who reads this thread an apology.

  • 17 years ago

    Herus,

    Please spit your venom someplace else.

    Bill is an expert. And he happily shares his wisdom and experience with all for FREE. Most contractors wouldn't even educate you after you have hired them, Bill gives out great advice in this public forum.

    Asking for free advice and then lashing out to answers you don't like is simply childish.

  • 17 years ago

    There was more work installing Travertine in our shower than floor. I had my shower done in Nov. Each piece was cut. One was installing and the other was running downstairs and outside to cut them. (4 days) My floor took just a day, 18X18 tiles with fine grout lines. I don't know what the charge was for the shower but the floor was $7.99 a foot including everything. Here is a picture of the shower. You can't see much of the floor. Sorry the picture is not that great and too large.
    {{gwi:1397100}}

  • 17 years ago

    msgreatdeals-
    Love your bathroom. What kind of countertop is on your vanity? The colors all look well together. We are struggling with countertops with our travertine tile.

  • 17 years ago

    Bill, don't even respond to this person. I for one love and appreciate you and I know I am not alone!

  • 17 years ago

    trudymom-- Actually, since this thread was hot, Herus actually contacted me by email, and apologized. Matter of fact, it was completely out of the blue, and only about a couple of weeks ago. I'd forgotten about this, and for him to go out of his way like that, told me that I may have been wrong about him. He didn't have to do that. I give him alot of credit.