Software
Houzz Logo Print
mlo1_gw

Cedar siding flare detail

18 years ago

I have been building some mock-ups to try and find a combination of numbers that enhance a lower flare detail using cedar siding.

So far I have been using both tapered blocking heights of 24" and 30" for the actual 2 x 4-1/2 blocking attatched to face of the studs/sheathing. The blocking will rest on the brick ledge and be covered with 1/2" cdx.

I really like the look of a subtle radius to the flare. I have been using a 8.5' radius on the 30" high blocks and a 6' radius on the 24" high blocks. This seem to be enough for the radius to telegraph through the siding if the plywood is kept tight to the radius and the shingles themselves are shortened a few inches to facilitate thier bending into the radius as well.

I have looked at many homes around me and none of them do this radius detail. They simply make a straight taper with the blocking (24" tall). They also finish the tapered reveal off at the door jambs and garage wrap with mdf or plywood and do not shingle the return of the taper, is this normal?

My crawl vents are between the 2x8 joists cavity through the rim joists. I have decided to deal with the flare detail at these openings just like a door jamb. So the flare protrusion on top of the vent would protrude over a louvered grill. I was at a loss on how else to deal with this.

On most jobs I saw they used staples and literally sank them through the shingles. I have been told (i think on this site) to hand nail the thin shingles. Can anyone elaborate?

I have also been told that it is very worth while to treat the backside of the shingles with a preservative like TWP as they will cup otherwise from the moisture behind them.

I am sure I have forgot some of the questions I had while analyzing doing this flare detail. I would love to hear from anyone who can shed some light on what I am doing or anything else pertaining to this style.

TIA

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    What kind of shingles and what finish if any? I have always shingled the return. The flare doesn't have to be a chord of a circle, it can be parabolic, but I guess the circle is easier to layout. It makes for quite a kick at the bottom when the flare is so deep. I've never done one that deep so I can tell you much. It sounds like you are on the right track.

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you mightyanvil,

    I am 99% sure we have decided on the red cedar. I really think it looks best with the green roofing and maybe a white painted trim and soffits.

    We need to meet stc 40 exterior walls. The munincipality dictates 1" sheathing unless using brick or a cementous composite siding (Hardie)to achieve that. You can then use 1/2" sheathing, which I did preparing for a brick wainscoting and cementous board facade. You also need double 5/8" gypsum on exterior interior walls and ceiling.

    Now shelving the brick and cement fiber board exterior detail I am needing to address the sheathing code requirement again if going with cedar siding. Windows are already in and flashed. I am trying to address the stc issue by going with a icynene insulation. Problem is the munincipality will not listen to logic unless I can show a rated assy that will be exactly like I will build. Everything I have seen rated by insulation companies is for interior walls showing gypsum on both sides, very frustrating. Things have slowed to a crawl while I am addressing this being it effects all finishing work from here forward. My hope was to somehow achieve an stc 40 rated exterior wall by leaving the 1/2" cdx I have, and hoping an insulation product would be so good I could even eliminate needing the second layer of 5/8" gypsum. That would save a bunch of money (jamb returs, electrical boxes, gypsum, labor) I could then justify spending more on a great insulation, if such a product exist.

    I was not even thinking parabolic. I like that as the chord design makes for a thin and long transition from 1/2 way up to the top of the flare. Any ideas on figuring the parabolic?

    I have found measuring the foundation that my brick ledge varies from 4.5 to 5 inches wide. I certainly want this transition insect proof. I am thinking of defaulting to a 5 inch width to cover the variations. Any ideas on framing the blocking out to make the bottom tight to the elements?

    I will post some photo's in a fallow up thread of a home I recently visited being built. I was unimpressed with the visuals and am trying to figure out how to do it with shingled returns as it will change how I block everything out.

    TIA

  • 18 years ago

    Yes on finishing the back sides of the shingle and yes to hand nailing w/stainless steel ring shank nails.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, I answered your above thread without realizing you had posted this thread. Sorry.

    Amy

  • 18 years ago

    From my experience (I put cedar shingles on almost all of the houses I design here in MA and the Cape) white cedar shingles should be sealed front and back and I would recommend double dipping them in stain at the factory.

    I have never seen nor heard of red cedar shingles being coated on the back and can't imagine how that would be done without making a mess not to mention the labor cost. If you think natural red cedar is not sufficiently resistant to water, you should have them dipped in a clear preservative. Of course, this usually darkens them quite a bit and some people seem to like it. Unfinished 16" tall wood shingles provide triple weather coverage with excellent ventilation. They will outlast anything except slate or metal siding. I would not back prime them.

    Since the nails are not exposed to the weather and the shingles are deeply overlapped they require nothing fancier than hot dipped galvanized nails in my opinion. If you use a preservative that contains a lot of copper you might consider stainless steel nails.

  • 18 years ago

    Dependent on location, even double hot dipped can lose galvanization and cause staining on natural or even sealed shingles. This generally takes a long while for it to happen, but it can so that is why i always used stainless regardless. More pricy but less worries.

  • 18 years ago

    Mightyanvil, can you reccomend a source for red cedar shingles?

    My local lumber yards supply does not look very nice.

    Seems Maibec only sells white cedar, unless I am missing it.

    TIA

  • 18 years ago

    Maibec white cedar shingles are made in Quebec. Western red cedar shingles are made in the Pacific Northwest.

    Your lumberyard should be able to order whatever kind of western red cedar shingles or shakes that you want. You should not have to find a wood source for a lumber supplier.

    The best red cedar is clear (no knots), edge grain (vertical graining), heartwood (no sapwood). Different degrees of that quality are "labeled" as No. 1, 2, 3 and 4 and often use the corresponding titles blue label, red label, black label and undercoursing. Lengths are usually 16" (FiveX), 18" (Perfection) and 24" (Royal).

    Price the better grades, then make up your mind.

    Check out the Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau website for more information.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you mighty, I will do some research.

    The shingles my lumber yard carried were quite thin and brittle. Another thing I noticed is that they are not "squared up", that may not mean anything.

    I wish we had better lumberyards. Many of the good ones are gone.

    Is there any reason I should be concerned about having "weap" holes under the flare?

    I'm thinking a good way to seal the horizontal dimensional differences on the brick ledge, is using a pressure treated 2x4 on its side against the concrete and installing the flare blocking on top of it. That would effectively give me a flat transition that may extend near an inch for stem wall width variations. I would then use a 1/2cdx over the blocking and tye it into the new "sill plate" basically. I would rip an angle on the edge of pt 2x4.

    Sound logicall?

  • 18 years ago

    Not only are weep holes a good idea, but you can incorporate that as a continuous venting for your crawl space vents as well ,dependent on their location.

    We always fabricated radiused flares laminating 3/4" marine grade plywood to make "studs" for the flairs. This was made easier with an onsite bandsaw. The plywood was doubled,ran 16'o.c and attached to a ledger notched above, then horizontal strapping instead of plywood sheathing layed out for the shingles. The corners were treated similar to a hipped roof where you scribe the "hip stud" and get your angle cut above by way of straight edge and bevel square. This was how we did it back in the mid eighties on cape cod and in them days ran a solid 1x on the bottom. I now see that as being an area of rot w/o having weep holes/venting.

  • 18 years ago

    Very interesting Sierraeast...thanks

    I had put some thought into doing a perimeter venting so-to-speak, to vent the crawl space rim openings. Two things seem to need to be adressed doing this. The application and product choice of something that will vent. And that product being made tight enough to the structure/foundation interface for insects to thrive in that cavity.

    On my build, the foundation stem wall is level its full 10 inch width (no brick ledge "drop" integrated). So the brick ledge and mud-sill are sitting level to each other. My 1/2" cdx sheathing was held up a 1/4" above the concrete when applying.

    The wheels are turning...please keep any advice flowing. This is definately a time consuming detail. I sure want to do it right.