I think a solid color would look good with it. green or red. Maybe even gold...

I saw poinsettia salad plates somewhere that would probably work. Don't remember where tho.

I love those plates...white is so hard to match, so a solid that picks up one of the colors may be the way to go..
Added bonus, you could use them all year round...

I thought of these, but do not know if this is the look you're going for.

Pic is here, and a link to the site to purchase them is below. If these don't work, perhaps you can find other salad plates that will.

Here is a link that might be useful: Replacements - Noel Pattern

Lynne,
I saw this plate and thought of your dishes. I dont think they have it at the Pier-1 that I go to. This may be too whimsical for your home's decor though. :)

Mo

Here is a link that might be useful: Pier 1 red plate

Lynn, look at these from Macy's. The red would really show up the santa design! ;o)

http://www1.macys.com/catalog/product/index.ognc?ID=337670&CategoryID=42643

(how do I highlight a site addy?)

Thanks for the suggestions!
Kathleen, I think you're right about going with a solid color. I know what you mean about matching the different whites!
Mo, I'm actually heading down to our local Pier One this afternoon to see if they have this set still in stock. I'll check out their plain red while I'm there. It's a sickness a lot of us here have, but aren't these pretty dishes? I don't need them, they're not to go with my Christmas dishes or anything, but they're on sale for less that $2 a plate and they're calling my name ;~O
{{gwi:1405424}}
Mamarazzi, that pattern looks very similar to what I have already, operhaps see them at Pier One? I noticed them on their website that Mo has here.
Leveta, hmmmm gold sounds interesting. I wonder where I can look at some.
Patty Cakes: those are drop-dead gorgeous plates (!!!!!), but I'm only looking for different accent plates to go with my dinner dishes. I'd love accent plates in that red there, but they don't come in red. Gosh, they're pretty, though!