Software
Houzz Logo Print
vancleaveterry

Ideas for fire resistant home?

18 years ago

Are there any techniques or materials that can increase the fire resistance of new construction homes?

Steel framing? Or how about steel studs in just the kitchen? What's the most fire resistant insulation?

Etc...

Thanks!

Comments (23)

  • 18 years ago

    ICF with stone exterior and metal or clay tile roofing might help.

    Is the threat of fire greater from outside or from within?
    A sprinkler system inside the house would probably be the way to go if you're talking about fires starting from within.

    Stumpy

  • 18 years ago

    I am building a home with cast-in-place concrete walls, exterior stone, interior stone, interior walls masonry, interior floors and roof concrete on metal decking. Fire resistant, termite resistant, mold resistant, tornado resistant etc.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Terry - drop me an e-mail if you need some contacts for ICF.

    A little off-topic, but your question reminded me of a designer in Slidell that we used once - I asked him about steel framing and he responded that he personally wasn't comfortable with steel framing because he was afraid that it would melt in a fire. I'm not sure what the temperature is that steel melts at, but I'm fairly sure that wood would be long gone by that point!

    There are some fire resistant paints on the market that you might look at.

  • 18 years ago

    Obviously a sprinkler system is the best and most reliable method and smoke detectors will already be required.

    In terms of the most common causes of home fires, people leaving cooking unattended causes the most property damage but the least loss of life. People smoking causes the greatest loss of life.

    The first defense would be to prohibit smoking and keep a fire extinguisher near each door of the kitchen.

    The next best defense is to use solid core doors or 1 3/4" MDF paneled doors and add automatic closers to the important doors, especially bedrooms.

    The idea is to prevent flashover in the room of origin from expanding the hot gases and smoke to other rooms before the fire department can arrive.

    For structural protection it can help to use type-C fire-resistant drywall in increasing thicknesses. It doesn't matter what kind of studs or insulation you use; it will all disappear when the drywall is gone unless you are considering heavy timber.

  • 18 years ago

    Actually exposed heavy timber beams can sometimes be more fire resistant than exposed steel beams. Thick wood chars which protects it some. When steel reaches a certain temperature it fails structurally; it doesn't have to melt. Failing steel framing above can fall and collapse an entire building.

    Intumescent paint swells up, chars, and provides limited protection for materials. It would not be needed on drywall or hardwoods and is usually used for exposed structural steel.

    Here is a link that might be useful: intumescent coatings

  • 18 years ago

    Steel increases in strength with temperature increases up to about 400 deg F. It then declines in strength with higher temperatures to about half original strength at about 850 deg. By 1200 deg, it probably will collapse in structural applications. Firemen typically decline to enter a high ceiling steel frame building because the concentrated heat at the top can cause collapse without warning. A wooden beam burning evenly along it's entire length will support itself until it burns through. As it burns, the decline in strength is accompanied by an identical decline in weight.
    The ICF with fire-resistant outer covering is an excellent choice.

  • 18 years ago

    I have to agree with MA on this one. We live in forest fire country. For external fires (forest fires) your best defense will be landscaping. Give your self at least 100' of defensible space. That is minimum. It means raking all ground clutter, having no trees that touch each other, getting rid of all ladder fuels, etc. etc..

    Next thing is your roofing material. Metal, slate, or tile are best, but class A fire rated comps are good too. Shake shingles are asking for trouble in fire country.

    Siding can be important, you can use a complete wall system such as IFC or cast concrete. Cement fiber also is fire resistant. Siding or wall systems only go so far if, your house has windows. A 1800 degree forest fire will not care if your walls are made of 2 foot thick concrete when you have a window that will allow that heat to ignite items within your home.

    Also, many fires start when embers or sparks get sucked up into your roof or soffit vents. Again no amount of fireproofing or concrete will stop that. They do make spark screens, but my firefighting friends say they do not always work.

    Inside, use fire sprinklers! Best defense available.

  • 18 years ago

    Thin film intumescent coatings (paint) is BY FAR the easiest to implement using existing construction techniques. It basically is a special paint a little thicker than normal. Much easier to apply than sprinkler systems, metal structures, etc. I won't say it is better/worse, but definitely easier.

    I've have done extensive (professional) research in this area. Contego Int'l that MA mentioned is just one of about 2 dozen companies that offer such a product. Stuff costs ~$40-$120 per gallon depending on brand. Thick film (mastics) are most commonly used on steel structures (support beams & columns, oil platforms, etc.) and are not what is needed for residential.

    The biggest problems with thin film intumescents is finding one that has good exterior/environmental longevity tests. Interior tests are 'relatively' easy to pass, but exterior is another story.

    If you have any specific questions, ask away...

  • 18 years ago

    Someone posted this site over on ICFtalk:

    http://icf-dev.com/Gallery/#Disaster

  • 18 years ago

    In terms of fire danger from outside it is the roof that is most vulnerable.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the replys.

    A few extra facts that I should have included in the first place:

    This is new construction, a three car garage with a guest bedroom downstairs and a full apartment above. Exterior will be brick and the woods are kept safely away. None of us smoke, except guests.

    Potential dangers would come from a car fire and kitchen fires. I suppose electrical fires are always a possibility.

    I will reply to the individual suggestions later tonight.

    Thanks!

  • 18 years ago

    Given that situation, I'd go with higher fire rating on the drywall. I would not entertain ICFs (or for that matter SIPs, or Steel, or whatever), if I were concerned about the overall structure; once the drywall or covering on the inside (or the brick on the exterior), is breached, it's all done anyhow, both for the occupants and structure. A gridwork of either concrete or steel girders is no longer structural after the fire in many cases, and there's nothing left to build onto anyhow. It's a moot argument.

  • 18 years ago

    Stumpy, I'm going to look into sprinklers for over the three car bays. I don't suppose they are a good idea in the kitchen and I hate the idea of a malfunction soaking everything I own. Katrina did a fine enough job of that.

    Jrdlh, that sounds wonderfully strong but a bit too expensive for me. Maybe I can find a place for some interior brick.

    Carter, my neighbor, is ICF something that lasts? Can repairs be done? I once saw pics of a house made of cinder blocks, with rebarb, then poured solid with concrete, and then given a brick exterior. I suppose that would cost too much. Would ICF sheathed with brick be reasonably affordable?

    Mighty Anvil, I will look into solid core doors or 1 3/4" MDF paneled doors and type-C fire-resistant drywall. I am thinking of heavy exposed timbers over the living room.

    Busdriver, Mikey, Buzzsaw, Robin and Jason, thank you for the suggestions. The ICF homes that survived the disasters were pretty impressive.

    Thank you all!
    Terry

  • 18 years ago

    You don't need sprinklers in the garage unless your cars are so valuable that you can't insure them adequately. Statistically a garage is one of the safest places in your home and it is also required to separated from your house and spaces above by rated drywall. The only reason a garage is treated differently is because it is unattended space and people tend to store things there that they shouldn't but the same could be said of basements.

    If you are worried about the garage, increase the rated drywall thickness. You would have to heat the garage to add sprinklers anyway.

    The most dangerous place in a non-smoking home is the kitchen and a sprinkler will work fine there, contrary to popular belief, but such fires usually occur when you are in the house and can use a fire extinguisher.

    Home fires are easy for fire services to extinguish when they are contained in the room of origin. When "flashover" (temperature in the room ignites everything) occurs, the fire becomes much more dangerous. Flashover will occur before the fire can penetrate even non-rated drywall. Therefore, closed doors is the most effective defense against hot gases and smoke moving to adjacent rooms before the fire service arrives but added fire-resistance at the walls can't hurt. Just making the standard 1/2" drywall type X (C is even better) is a big improvement.

    No one wants closers on their doors but alternatively you can close the doors when you leave the house and when you are home you can rely on a hard-wired smoke detector to alert you so you can put out the fire or at least close the doors.

    The best door would be a solid lumber core flush door but for traditional doors Bolection makes a solid 1 3/4" thick MDF door that has a 7/8" thick flat panel.

  • 18 years ago

    Terry, since I built with ICF, I should know more about ICF than I do - here are some impressions that I have:

    - ICF can be built to withstand 500 mph winds - it's a function of concrete thickness and the amount/size of rebar. You would probably want to build to 150 mph winds.

    - Rebar will rust over time - I don't know what that time is, but am guessing over 50 years before that becomes a problem. You could use coated rebar, or there are some new fiberglass fillers that can be added to the concrete that will take the place of the rebar.

    - You could use brick, stucco, vinyl, hardi, etc. for the exterior.

    Rennaissance Doors in Long Beach and Biloxi or OS (I can't remember which) have good prices on solid wood doors - the operation is a bit shady though - they say that their doors are manufactured in Louisiana but they are actually imported from China.

    I included a link to Energy Wise Construction Products - Joe Riddle is the owner. He deals with Nudura block (there are other blocks out there that are also good). Joe will be able to put you in touch with some of the local Nudura builders (the one out of OS is supposed to be really good). If you call Joe, tell him that Erica told you about him. (Joe saved me $10K worth of block that my first GC tried to steal - I try to send as much business his way as I can.)

    You might also try Rodney Newman with Ecosystems (he should be in the phone book, his ICF is Eco-block). He was around pre-K, but was a little on the pricey side for my project.

    I forgot to include my e-mail earlier - it's carterinms at pngusa dot net.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Energy Wise Construction Products

  • 18 years ago

    Also, AmeraDeck for any outside decking that will touch the main home. Composite decking material with impressive fire resistant properties. Watch the video at this site.

    Here is a link that might be useful: AmeraDeck composite decking

  • 18 years ago

    You might want to consider concrete roof tiles. The cost is dropping, although IMO, they remain expensive compared to standard or even highly resistant asphalt shingles.

    And a word about kitchens: make it a family rule that no one, absolutely no one for any reason, leaves the room if there is heat under a pot. If you gotta go, you gotta go but turn off the burners first. Also take the moment to soak potlifters in a borax solution (borax is a fire retardant, your local FD can give you the ratio). BTW, in my area, public places [such as churches] are *required* to have all drapes and curtains soaked in the borax solution before they can be hung.

    Everyone should know how to use the fire extinguishers. Spend a few bucks for a spare and practice! If you have quarters on the second/third floor, be sure there are usable escape ladders in each room. It's required to have a window large enough to egress, but that's not much good if you are looking down at a 2 story drop and there's no ladder.

  • 18 years ago

    Carter... Any special problems when you brick an ICF home?

    How do the walls made of Nudura block compare to the wall shown in the link below? (third pic down on left side).
    That example wall looks nice and thick compared to some.

    I'd like to build something that lasts a few hundred years. I don't want to saddle my family with walls that start to crumble after 50 years with no way to repair them. So I will look into the fiberglass filler.

    I am 30 minutes from the nearest concrete mixing plant... is that a problem? I hear concrete has problems if in the truck too long.

    Thanks!.. and I will look into the decking material suggested. And practice with a fire extinguisher.

    Here is a link that might be useful: example wall... third picture down

  • 18 years ago

    '- Rebar will rust over time - I don't know what that time is, but am guessing over 50 years before that becomes a problem. You could use coated rebar, or there are some new fiberglass fillers that can be added to the concrete that will take the place of the rebar. '

    I don't think that this is an issue in residential construction (unless you have concrete piers in salt water or something similarly corrosive). From Wikipedia:

    'the alkaline chemical environment provided by calcium carbonate (lime) causes a passivating film to form on the surface of the steel, making it much more resistant to corrosion than it would be in neutral or acidic conditions.'

    Here is a link that might be useful: Reinforced concrete

  • 18 years ago

    Someone told me that rebar rusts over time, but I had already used regular rebar so did not spend any time researching this issue - jrldh found out more in two minutes than I knew! Just something that I would research if I (god forbid) ever had to do it again! The fiberglass may save on labor and cost, but the rebar helps hold the blocks in place during the pour - probably it's done with a combination of rebar and fiber. Also something I never researched.

    I don't think there is any difference with bricking an ICF house, but we never considered brick - it's hard to make an elevated house look good with brick. I have a friend who's looking at building with ICF and he is impressed with novabrik (www.novabrik.com).

    The Nudura blocks range from 4' of concrete all the way to 12'. I'm sure the other blocks do to. In that picture, the foam is around 2.5', so the concrete looks to be 6'. My first GC (the one sitting in jail) said not to use the 4' blocks because even though they meet the higher wind requirements, it is harder to get the rebar in correctly.

    I wouldn't think that 30 minutes would be a problem - if it is, how are you going to pour your slab? One of our concrete trucks got lost for an hour or two - nobody seemed to think it was a problem.

    Here's a link to my blog, with all the gory details of my build. There's a video of them pouring the concrete into the chain wall forms.

    Here is a link that might be useful: bayou build

  • 18 years ago

    Steel studs: too thin of metal. Twist and structurally fail at very low temperature. Allow easy passage of heat, flame and fresh oxygen within a framed wall, allowing for accelerated spread of a fire. A wood stud wall is superior, keeping it's strength until a significant portion has burn through and much better impediment to heat, flame and fresh oxygen.

    A wood stud wall with plastic electrical boxes and non-vented (sealed) panels provides very superior impediment to the spread of heat, flame and fresh oxygen. The wires enter into the plastic boxes from the bottom where ever possible and are sealed. Seams from studs to plates are seated and the stud surface and plastic box surface are sealed to the drywall (acoustic seal works well). This creates a "sealed panel" which is "non-vented": a fire inside the wall has limited oxygen with which to start, maintain or spread. There are no air gaps for a flame to spread through: fire can only spread by burn through or by reaching flash temperatures.

    I've read some papers on why commercial code for preventing the spread of fire aren't working well. Bottom line appears to be poor workmanship leaving larger air gaps for flames to spread through and/or insufficient code allowing for larger air gaps than is effective.

    Target points for improvement: non-vented stud walls and eliminate air gaps for flame passage. I.e.; all electrical boxes (plastic and sealed); wires, pipes and ducts through studs, plates and other structures. Like the gap in a floor for the air vent: seal the vent to the wood.

  • 18 years ago

    don't think anyone has mentioned cork. i've been researching cork flooring for our playroom and everything i've looked at says cork is "fire resistant and also does not release any toxic gases on combustion..."

  • 18 years ago

    vancleaveterry ~ re being 30 minutes from cement plant: That should not be a problem. Our local plant has trucks going 30 miles in every direction, often in bumpertobumper traffic. The trucks are designed to carry the cement in a humogeous canister which is constantly rotating, stopping only when the cement is actually being released for delivery. This is why they prefer to deliver in multiple cubic-yard lots rather than a bit here and a bit there. I can't imagine any cement plant not having that same type of delivery truck.

    Re sprinklers in kitchen -- that's only a so-so idea, because they are suitable and effective only for non-cooking and non-electrical fires. You don't want water on a grease fire, and most foods being cooked have *some* grease. A Type-B extinguisher is required for grease fires, never water.

    Here is a link that might be useful: grease fire demo