Just my opinion, but I like it. I think the subway tiles will make a fantastic contrast to the rest of the tile. I love, love your vanity/mirror combo as well.

I agree. But our opinions aren't the one that's important. ;-)

YOU'RE the one who's going to have to live with your decision. If you like the concept, then go for it!

I would have no objection to what you describe, and in fact the color contrast sounds refreshing. Have you purchased the tile yet? The only thing I'm wondering is if a larger format tile might not be a good idea for the bathtub surround- like 12x12? Fewer grout lines to keep clean, probably cheaper to purchase AND install (unless it's DIY, then it is just time) and it may look nice to have not only color contrast, but size contrast between the two areas.

Ans I love your vanity mirror! Who needs ornate shower tile when you have that?????? Gorgeous!

I love the vanity. Can you tell me where you got it?

Thanks,

anita

ps - I love the mirror, too!

I think it is great - primarily because you said -

" because I like the look of the tile and tub being the same color. I also like the idea of using a matte and a shiny finish vs. all matte, or all shiny."

You know what you like - trust your gut. I love the mirror too - the bathroom is going to look great.

Thanks everyone! I will proceed with the plan, keeping in mind the idea of maybe a larger white tile in the bath surround.
The vanity was purchased from Overstock.com