Software
Houzz Logo Print
remodelfla

All induction or gas and induction?

18 years ago

If you had the choice to go all induction or combine gas and induction; which would you choose? I haven't cook with gas since I was a kid but acknowledge it's appeal. I definately want induction and plan on an electric oven. I have gas lines in the home we are going to remodel, and it wouldn't be too difficult to convert. The home currently has electric but there will be alot of electrical updating since this a whole home remodel and small addition so saving money there won't play into the decision.

It will just be the 2 of us and I"m the primary cook. We do alot of grilling (Florida) outside and have a great gas grill and smoker. I do love to entertain but that's only once every week or two. I'm wondering if a gas stove top and induction would be overkill...more then I really need. Since I'm still working, at least for another 5 years, it's mostly just dinner that gets cooked (excluding weekends and summers... teacher) Opinions?

Comments (16)

  • 18 years ago

    I think by most standards, having high-power gas and induction is an overkill. That is what my wife is telling me anyway, as she lets me spend the money on both :).

    Ideally, we would get a bluestar cooktop/range and then compliment that with a couple of induction hobs. That way, if a pan doesn't work on induction, there is high power gas ready to get the job done. Alas, bluestar doesn't make a standard 24 inch griddle so we are bouncing back and forth between them and Wolf.

    Net, net, we are undecided on the gas unit but the decision to have both has long been made. If I were still living in florida, I would get a multi-hob induction and just one or two gastops as to not waste all that cooling in the process of cooking. Even in seattle, in summer time often we grill outside as to not heat up the house. So we are looking forward to havinv induction as to increase our choices then.

    Biggest considertion here then is the length of the hood as you increase the cooking surface. It can get huge in a hurry. In one configuration, we are looking at an 8 feet/96 inch custom hood! Sanity might set in :) and we will compromise to have less.

    If I had to go all induction, my favorite is the 5 hob Diva as it has a high-power unit and very easy to use controls. You can also get Diva mail order at reasonable prices.

    For our current induction needs (with gas), we have zoomed in on a commercial unit (cooktek).

  • 18 years ago

    remodelfla--I can recall a number of people on this forum who have gotten hybrid units say that they never or rarely use the gas burners, and if they had it to do all over again they'd get the all-induction units.

    If you have the luxury of lots of space, you might want to have both, just so you feel you didn't compromise, but hopefully those people I mention above will chime in here.

  • 18 years ago

    I should add that I was convinced I wanted both until I heard from these folks and it changed my mind to go all-induction.

  • 18 years ago

    The hybrid units are induction and 'regular' electric, not gas, but I would fear the same thing...That you'd love one and never use the other. I think with induction being so much cleaner, faster, etc., I would end up not using the gas. The only reason I went with gas over induction was burner sizes and configuration...I needed at least 4 big ones for our large family, and wanted to use a griddle pan over 2, but it doesn't sound like that would be an issue for you.

  • 18 years ago

    amirm - I just started using this site and was wondering what the names of the online stores you can get Diva at reasonable prices?

    Does anyone know when the Miele induction will be available in the US?

  • 18 years ago

    I'd pretty strongly suggest all induction.

    The issue to my mind isn't the high power, it's the controllability, particularly at very low settings. You'd have to get a very expensive gas stove to match an induction unit and likely still have to use a flame tamer.

  • 18 years ago

    whereisthebeach, here are some quick links I had saved:

    http://www.ajmadison.com/cgi-bin/ajmadison/DDP2.htm

    http://www.homeclick.com/web/search/search.aspx?Ntt=diva+induction

    I am sure there are more.

  • 18 years ago

    I live in a warm climate, like you, and do my "fire cooking" outside.

    The induction is great because it doesn't heat up the kitchen like gas.

    I actually got rid of my gas range to get induction and I couldn't be more thrilled.

    Well, one caveat - I wish instead of On/Off buttons, there was Hi/Lo/Off. It bugs me to put the kettle on at level 5 and have to press "+" 9 times. But the kettle sure boils fast!

  • 18 years ago

    Well... I guess that answers that question! I had a feeling that induction would be the answer for us but I thought I'd poll the collective great minds of this forum.

    lightlystarched... I've read from others who mentioned the irritation of having to press to go up in increments to get where you want. Are there any brands of induction units that bypass that with a different kind of control system like knobs? Do those units have a hob with the higher power that some units offer? I think I have some researching to do on this but at least I know to focus my attention on induction for sure.
    Thanks for all your input!

  • 18 years ago

    "Are there any brands of induction units that bypass that with a different kind of control system like knobs?"

    First, Diva has what OP was asking about. That is, it has pre-sets for med, med-low and high. We really liked this.

    Second, yes, Gaggenau, Viking and Cooktek are three that I know of that have knobs like gas ranges.

    "Do those units have a hob with the higher power that some units offer?"

    In case of Gagg and Cooktek, yes. Diva if I am not mistaken, has the highest power I have seen at 4,000 watts. Cooktek is also great at 3,500. Note that 3,500 is better than 30,000 Gas BTU equiv.

  • 18 years ago

    amirm... thank you for the specific info. I'm going to print it out at school tomorrow so I can use it as a reference when it comes time to order my appliances. Gotta love this forum!

  • 18 years ago

    My own thoughts would be to have a 2-burner gas unit, and a "full complement" of induction, whatever that means for you. Then you have a bit of gas for cookware that's not induction-capable, and for power outages.

    I understand that Bluestar will build custom configurations, including a 2-burner cooktop. There are several companies that make "modular" cooktops that have 2-burner gas modules, including Wolf and Gagg.

    Some of the modular configurations will allow you to mix gas and induction. Although, as of the last time I looked (which has been a while), I didn't like any of their induction modules.

  • 18 years ago

    The induction site has the 36" diva for $3295 and I think that includes shipping.

    The largest hob on the Gagg boosts to 4400kW, but though it has a knob, the power settings aren't infinite. I really like the cooktop, it has a good configuration, lots of power, boost on all elements and timers, but that knob thingy freaks me out. I still don't know which unit I'm buying. Narrowed it down to:

    Diva 36"
    Gagg 36"
    Viking 36"

    This indecision is killing me and driving DH crazy!!!!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    We have the 36" Diva and it is awesome. We love boiling water for our friends with the "professional" gas stoves. They are blown away. We also always put a paper towel under the pans. Keeps the top clean (a reason for no knobs) and the pans stay like new. In terms of power, they are basically limited by the 50A circuit. They could go to 60A, but that would require a new line and they are trying to stay within the typical electric stove circuit of 50A. However, seems like more than enough power. I wouldn't turn my back on it! I would also point out that these things are complicated (I'm an electrical engineer) and you get what you pay for. The Diva has two speed controlled fans for ventilation of the hobs which is extremely important. Make sure the unit you select has fans and that they can breath in your cabinet (i.e. suck in cool air from the toe kick). They these are basically high powered low frequency transmitters.

  • 18 years ago

    I am considering going induction/ceramic AND gas via a modular set up. I am looking at Miele, Wolf, Gagg, and Kupp. The set ups range from 33.5" (Miele) to 46" (Gagg). So I have a lot to consider.

  • 18 years ago

    We ordered the 5 burner Diva and I can't wait...we used to have a Wolf range top, but now we have propane (very expensive). We are in CA and have a great grill outside and also a smoker. We don't see any need for gas anymore...go "test drive" induction at your local appliance store an you will see for yourself!