Software
Houzz Logo Print
craig00_gw

Induction cookware review: long post

15 years ago

For those of you looking for induction cookware here's what we bought to replace 13 of our 18 pieces (not counting lids). We have multiples of some as we use them all.

Headings and brands are listed alphabetically with regular price (price paid), and website.

I then give opinions and a grade based on our expectations of how they should perform for practical purposes. We're good home cooks and just want cookware to do the job. Looks don't matter a whole lot but it's nice to have range-to-table ability. Your priorities may differ.

COOKWARE SET

Calphalon Cookware, Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 13 Piece Set

$399.99 @ Macy's ($240 Last one in stock + Macy's credit card discount)

BONUS 6-piece mixed utensil set and crock

BONUS 5-qt. Dutch oven set but not induction compatible

http://www1.macys.com/catalog/product/index.ognc?ID=468730&CategoryID=7709#fn=sp%3D1%26spc%3D19

Calphalon Tri-ply is terrific and a phenomenal value. For the price I'd take these over All Clad 5 ply hands down. They even look the same down to the lip and descriptive printing on the bottom. The glass lids have an unwelded seam around the metal edge but we've had no problem with the seam separating.

Grade: B+

DUTCH OVENS

Le Creuset Round Red Dutch Oven, 7 1/4-Qt.

$285.00 (Gift)

http://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/le-creuset-signature-7-quart-round-dutch-oven/?pkey=cdutch-ovens-braisers:ckwdutdut

LE Creuset Cast Iron 6.75-qt. Dijon Oval Dutch Oven (B+)

$270 ($99 @ Williams Sonoma sale table)

Both of these pieces are examples of why Le Creuset is heirloom quality. A joy to use and behold when new or with a years-old patina. The only downside is the plastic handle which gets hot and others report is prone to crack or break. I've never used Staub which I hear is equally good but less expensive.

Grade: B+


FRY PANS

Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron 9-Inch Skillet with Iron Handle, Red

$104.95 (gift)

http://www.amazon.com/Creuset-Enameled-Cast-Iron-9-Inch-Skillet/dp/B00005QFSO/ref=sr_1_6?s=kitchen&ie=UTF8&qid=1303128523&sr=1-6

Even though eggs tend to stick to it I've used this skillet daily for years until the Lodge. It's been used to grill steaks at screamingly high temps and is a workhorse in the truest sense. After over five years I'm starting from scratch trying to season it but it's downgraded because food sticks to it.

Grade: B-

Lodge 6102933 Round Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Griddle 10-1/2" (B)

$14.87 ($11 @ TJ Maxx)

http://www.amazon.com/Lodge-L9OG3-Pre-Seasoned-2-Inch-Griddle/dp/B00008GKDN

Heavy and with a lip is limited in what it can do. Takes a great seasoning and now I know why people like Lodge so much.

Grade: B


ROASTING PANS

Mystery pan

Cheap and thin but does the job

Grade: C

Sur La Table Tri-Ply Stainless Steel Roasting Pan, 16" x 12" (B+)

149.95 ($100 promotional)

http://www.surlatable.com/product/PRO-516385/Sur-La-Table-Tri-Ply-Stainless-Steel-Roasting-Pan

Excellent roasting pan that's right up there with Calphalon tri-ply and All Clad stainless. Substantial weight and does fine at high temps on the range-top for deglazing. The only downside is it doesn'et come with a rack.

Grade: B+


SAUTE' PANS

All-Clad d5 Stainless Steel Saute Pan 6 qt.

$285.00 @ 20% off $228.00 ($30 after gift certificate)

http://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/all-clad-d5-stainless-steel-saute-pan/?pkey=ccookware-all-clad:ckwallssd

We've had All Clad in the past and it's the best. We'd never pay full-price, but on a few occasions we've used a gift card or got a piece at very deep discount at closeout.

Grade: A

TOOLS OF THE TRADE BASICS - STAINLESS STEEL 12 INCH 5 QUART DEEP DISH FRYING PAN (B)

$29.99 ($15 on sale)

http://www.amazon.com/TOOLS-TRADE-BASICS-STAINLESS-FRYING/dp/B000TYDBO4/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&s=home-garden&qid=1303124673&sr=1-2

Long story short I bought this instead of a $130 All Clad fry pan w/lid or an $80 Calphalon tri-ply saute. Utilitarian and works just fine. Takes an inconsequential minute or so longer to heat than the others.

Grade: B-


STOCK POTS

American Kitchen Commercial Stockpot, 20qt Exclusive to Williams Sonoma.

$180.00 $56 delivered ebay

These are available with a glass lid for $114 on Amazon

http://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/american-kitchen-20-quart-commercial-stockpot/?pkey=cstock-soup-multi-pots:ckwssmstk

Excellent, substantial weight and tight fitting lid. Has handy volume markers inside.

Grade A

Wolfgang Puck Bistro Elite 10qt Stockpot with Lid (we bought two) (B)

HSN Price: $59.90 $35 @ TJ Maxx

http://kitchen-dining.hsn.com/wolfgang-puck-bistro-elite-10qt-stockpot-with-lid_p-6232280_xp.aspx

Great for soups and stocks. Thick bottoms and good value. The glass lids have metal seams which aren't welded but are holding up so far.

Here is a link that might be useful: Calphalon Tri-Ply induction set

Comments (7)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Very comprehensive review, especially the info about the roasting pans. I've had a difficult time finding one that works on induction.

    FWIW, I think you missed the best tri-ply cookware out there for induction, which is LeCreuset. I like it much better than All-Clad tri-ply or d5.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    As I said, our interest tends to be utilitarian and "Your priorities may differ." Looking at the cost we paid (in parenthesis) you'll see our intent was to spend as little as possible for that particular cook ware. We were willing to spend a lot more on the Electrolux range and my Japanese knives.

    We were looking at Tramontina as a great value and I had no idea Le Creuset even made tri ply!

    Keep your input coming as induction is getting more popular and others want info on compatible cook ware.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    FWIW, I like ScanPan's CTX non-stick induction cookware line, and noticed last week that ScanPan also has a CSX line of similar stainless induction cookware, at Sur la Table. The handles on both lines are very nice, much better than All Clad's uncomfortable handles (IMHO).

    I also like my Staub dutch ovens for braising. And Ikea's Favorit line of induction cookware works quite well -- I have one of their larger stock pots.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I thought LeCreuset only made cast iron.

    I was watching 'How It's Made' tonight and realized why stainless pans with an aluminum bit put on the bottom will buzz. The upper part of the pan is a piece of stainless that is 'press-fit' to make the shape of the pan. It is then turned upside down and an aluminum disk a bit less than the diameter of the pan is placed on it followed by another stainless disk a bit larger than the pan diameter. The three pieces are then welded together at the center. The pan then goes onto a heater which raises the temperature of the bottom to 900F which softens the aluminum disk. It then moves on to a press that pushes the bottom stainless and aluminum disk onto the bottom of the pan with several tons of force. After that the pan gets polished and smoothed, and handles are attached.

    My Circulon pans are made like this. And they buzz when they are 'cold'.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I purchased the Le Creuset stainless pots and a fry pan and they work great on my induction. I really like the lip around the top that makes it easy to pour without a drip.

    I also have the Le Creuset non-stick fry pans which have the disc on the bottom that works with the induction. These heat up slower than the stainless steel. My favorite non-stick is the Bosch non-stick with stainless up the sides. This heats up much faster than the Le Creuset. If I were to look for another non-stick I would make sure it has the stainless up the sides too.

    The Le Crueset dutch oven and regular cast iron skillets also work great. I have absolutely no complaints with either one.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Two additional quasi-economical sources may be of interest:

    All Clad makes Emeril's pans, and so far these have held up well in use on our induction cooktop.

    Demeyere makes induction stainless items for the Bistro/Restaurant trade that are somewhat less expensive then their other lines but at least one has proved quite rugged. We have only the 2L teapot but it has survived being boiled down to zero water by accident and heated to beyond the tolerance of a silicone pad before the cooktop auto shut down.

    kas