Software
Houzz Logo Print
sjsh_mom_gw

A few spec questions

16 years ago

Hello all. Totally new at this so, I was wondering if we could get your opinion. Knowing that each region of the country has different prices and cost of build varies but I was wondering what the experienced builders (owners and prof) thought of the following proposed specs: (4500 sq ft NJ 4 bed 3 full bath-2 of which will have shower and tub, one a jaccuzi the other just a tub, 2 half bath). A price fixed with allowance type of contract

1. 3/4" water feed lines

2. 75 gallon water heater

3. $12,000 for 1 tub/shower combo, 1 shower stall, 5 toilet, 6 sinks

4. 300 amp electric

5. Roof-30 yr Timberline, 15 lb tar paper, 1 inch roof, 36" ice shield, alcoa aluminum gutters, 5" OG 0.032" thick

6. Stairs: Oak treads, white pine stringers and riser, 5/4" X 6" oak handrails 1 3/4"wood baluters

7. Window casing: 4" with 6" base

8. $50,000 kitchen cabinet allowance about 12 feet of counter space per side with a large center island

9. Foyer $10/sq ft

  1. Tile allowance $7/sq feet

Thanks!

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago

    While I like this game - ie guess the price - you don't really give much info. I'm unclear what $12,000 for plumbing means - is that the price for fixtures or for the rough in plumbing (or both)?

    I built a similiar size house and around here at least we do 400 amp electric. Again - similar size house and we had $28k in the entire house cabinetry. So by that I could say that you are just about twice ours so I'll say $1,050,000.

    Most expensize items - type of siding/brick/stone, appliances (well they can be), HVAC, Permits/site work/grading/landscaping, Basement or slab.

    I'd expect electric, plumbing, even trim to be about a standard per sq foot per region so there is not much to say about those things.

    But lighting allowance - $10k?
    Fireplaces? Masonry?
    Window quality - this could be a $50k item?

    The window casing size is great but it is a very small item compared to other things you didn't give any info on.

  • 16 years ago

    This isn't a specification; it's something you might write on a napkin if you were in a hurry and didn't know the correct terms for materials.

  • 16 years ago

    You need to provide more info including style and floor plan because it gets more complicated than that but I'll comment on a few points:

    My guess is, you are going "traditional" if you are using those balusters in your handrailing.

    1. 3/4" water feed lines - I am guessing you mean the Main feed LINE - 3/4" is fine provided that the plumbing layout is correct and your plumber knows when to reduce the diameter of the pipe to 1/2". If the master bath shower has multiple shower heads or a rain shower head (see link) you might want to go with a 1" main line if you can manage the guilt of the wasted water but that is a totally different story. What state are you at?

    2. In regards to the water heater, A 75 gallons wh is ok, depending on the layout. If bathrooms are far apart, you want to have a circulating pump or a pipe loop so you do not waste hot water - or install 2 - 40 gallons WH far apart.

    3. If the 12,000 for plumbing includes all the fixtures, that would be a low allowance so in the case you have to get a different plumbing sub you probably will have a hard time finding one that charges you 12,000.

    5. Roof-30 yr Timberline, (SO SO) 15 lb tar paper (I RECOMMEND YOU TO USE 30 LB "TAR" PAPER), 1 inch roof (IF YOU MEAN THE SHEATHING, ITS PRETTY GOOD),

    6. Stairs: Oak treads, white pine stringers and riser, 5/4" X 6" oak handrails 1 3/4"wood baluters (I HOPE THE PINE STRINGER IS NOT VISIBLE)
    7. Window casing: 4" with 6" base (IS OK)
    8. $50,000 kitchen cabinet allowance about 12 feet of counter space per side with a large center island (NICE ALLOWANCE BUT, IS THE COUNTERTOP INCLUDED?)
    9. Foyer $10/sq ft (WHAT IS THIS ???)

    1. Tile allowance $7/sq feet (ONLY THE TILE??? IS OK)

    Here is a link that might be useful: shower head

  • 16 years ago

    We don't know here you live but where I live the domestic hot water would be part of the central heating system.

    Avoid allowances by specifying the fixtures in the contract or supplying them yourself. You will have to make these decisions later anyway and it will be cheaper if you include the cost in the original bid. Contractors use allowances to pad their profits so they may be reluctant to give them up.

    A roofing warranty is a rough indication of quality and means little in terms of actual reimbursement in case of a roofing failure because the payment is prorated over 30 years (if you can get it at all) and doesn't include labor. The important part of a warranty is he first 5 years. The quality you need depends largely on the climate and exposure of which we know nothing.

    I can't imagine what structural condition would require 1" thick roof sheathing (if that is what you mean by a 1" roof).

    I assume you mean Timberline shingles as manufactured by GAF. GAF is not a brand I would specify but it helps to mention the manufacturer in the specification. The same goes for "ice shield"; if you don't specify "WR grace Ice and Water Shield" you will get an inferior thin knock-off product and this is not a place to be cheap. This material should extend from the roof edge to 36" inside the exterior wall line and that is often more than 36".

    Your description of the stairs does not tell a carpenter enough to know what you want. The handrail is unlikely to meet code.

    If you want to get good pricing, design the house and write a good specification, then bid it. If you want confirmation of the project cost early you will need to hire a contractor as a consultant or enter into an agreement with one with the understanding that you will negotiate the final price later.

    Or you can play 20 questions with the members here as we try to guess what you want and what the project requirements are.

  • 16 years ago

    Macv - why not Timberline? One of the options for roof is their Slateline product. Architect recommended Grand Manor but I don't like the look. We are still very early in the process so I am just doing research at this point. Fear natural slate is out of budget, and would rather do a quality asphalt than a manufactured fake slate.

  • 16 years ago

    I thought Timberline and Slateline were made by GAF and Grand Manor was made by CertainTeed.

    I just prefer CertainTeed to GAF/ELF.

    Here is a quote from Roofing.com:

    "...Ask that contractor about Certainteed's "sure start protection warranty". Compare that to any other warranty offered by any other asphalt shingle. Now there is your answer. Certainteed has the best track record, has the best research development and testing, they have the best programs and support for the homeowner and contractor, they have the best warranty. They will warranty your roof against shading which I believe they are the only company that does this. They will warranty it for 10 years even if the attic is not properly vented. They will warranty a wind blow off claim even if it is a "winter application." They use a thicker and much better fiberglass matt than any other shingle. They do not sell their products to big box store like Home Depot, they don't sell to lumber yards etc. They only sell to professional roofing suppliers. I have been roofing for 14 years. I have layed and repaired/replaced many shingles of every type of shingle manufacture and I say hands down Certainteed is the best."

    I just try to go with what works, then consider what they look like. If they don't have what you want then look at the other brands.