Software
Houzz Logo Print
newhome3_gw

is it too late now??? please help!

17 years ago

Hi All,

Our new construction is in full progress. However, last night, I realized that I have made the BIGGEST BLUNDER....in the layout of one of our bathrooms. It is a small bathroom on the 2nd floor for DD. The cabinet was installed yesterday, and I now realize that there is absolutely no space between it and the shower directly opposite it. (approx 2 ft). Its my fault...I should have seen this on the plan, but, I honestly thought it would be okay...until that cabinet went in. Looking at the tightness of the space between the 2 fixtures, I am a little surprised that it actually passed code, but obviously, it did!!

Everything has been plumbed, and wired; the walls are primed for paint. The shower unit has been placed, but the toilet and sink countertop have not. Floors are not in yet.

My question is....are we going to incur a TONNE of costs to change the layout at this stage? Is it completely crazy to even think about these kinds of changes right now? I think that if we remodel this bathroom later on, it will be even more costly and more hassle.

I really regret this layout so much.....I cannot stop thinking about how bad it looks and functions :(

What would you do? Any ideas on the work that will be involved? Like I said, the bathroom is on the 2nd floor, and beneath it is part of the garage; there are no rooms on the main floor directly beneath it.

Of course, I know that I have to talk directly with the builder to get some answers but before I do, I was just wondering if any of you have had similar experiences?

This is causing me a lot of despair right now! DH says live and learn and just live with it, but its really hard to think this way (right now)

Sorry for the long post....

I really welcome any and all of your thoughts,suggestions and advice!

Thank you.

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    This may not help, but could you simply put in a smaller cabinet for the sink --- i.e. a shallower pedestal or a shallow sink cabinet?

    If post the layout of the bathroom, it might help to see what else you are working with to solve your problem.

  • 17 years ago

    Can you post a floorplan of how it is now and then describe the changes that you would make? How deep is the cabinet? If it is 24", can you just switch to an 18" deep cabinet, or less? Or how about a pedestal sink with a stand alone (i.e., not built in)cabinet. We have three pedestal sink and really like them. Even if the pedestal sink is still within 24" of the shower, the pedestal sink will open up the space.

  • 17 years ago

    You could also add a medicine cabinet over the sink...very Restoration Hardware and add a cabinet over the toilet for more storage. We used a Kohler sink that was about 20" wide and not very deep. I probably would only use a shower curtain not a door and keep it open (when not being used) to make the space feel larger.

  • 17 years ago

    Here's one that I saw in a very narrow bathroom. There are others.

    Anne

    Here is a link that might be useful: Bath sink for narrow bathroom

  • 17 years ago

    newhome3 - just curious - who drew the plan for this bathroom, was it your own design or did you have an architect? We had an architect design our house, haven't broken ground yet. I was always measuring and making him adjust size and space , just a foot here and there. I guess his idea of a comfortable space was different than mine. Don't beat yourself up , we start our build next week and I just know our great room which is to be the signature room of this house is to narrow. I have spent all week with a tummy ache over this, because I knew last summer during the design phase that the room needed about 2 additional feet added on and I let him convince me it was plenty big. So you are not alone with these dreadful feelings. Good luck!

  • 17 years ago

    Hi All,
    Thanks for all your responses. Mae919.....I know exactly what you mean about literally feeling physically ill over floor plans :( Sorry that you are feeling the same over your great room size.
    I have had 3 days to try and get used to my blunder, and find every way I can to live with it. I have thought about all of your suggestions to get a smaller depth cab(18"vs 24"). This can be done but our existing cab is not returnable or refundable. Also, this is my 12 yr olds bathroom, so, I am thinking she will probably need more space in that vanity.

    Mae919, our plan was a set plan that our builders have built before. We just made lots of changes to it. Originally, the builder had designed that bathroom to be more user friendly, but (big confession here...which is why I am feeling so bad) I changed it to the conguration it is now, thinking it would be okay. Reason for the change....I thought that hiding the toilet from being in full view from the bedroom would be a better arrangment. I was clearly not thinking straight!
    However, noone...builder or designer told/advised me that the clearences would be very tight, and that it would not be a good idea, in their 'experienced' opinion to make this change. Hence, the mess we are in. The NKBA recommends at least 30" in front of the vanity, 24" is minimum requirement. Not sure what our local codes are, but obvioulsy, barely 2 ft seems to be okay! I was not made aware of this.
    Anyhow, we are meeting with the builder tomorrow, and will ask him about changing the whole layout. My BIL who is a builder in another state, tells me it might run us around an extra $5000 to make such changes at this stage, compared to closer to $10000 if we completely remodel later.
    I am thinking that the arrangment is so bad, that not only will it not be a pain for DD, but it will also affect resale later on.

    'SIGH'.........I will keep you guys posted.....perhaps we could save some $$$ if we told builders to just replumb and rewire, but we will do the flooring install, and any paintwork, finishes etc. ourselves.

    Mae919...GOOD LUCK with your new house build.....can you make changes to your floorplan before they break ground (referring to your great room size)? It may delay your ground breaking somewhat, but its better to be really sure especially with major things like room sizes. Just measure and double measure EVERYTHING!!

    Thanks for listening everyone!

  • 17 years ago

    Newhome3, I too, feel your pain. I have had countless things turn out differently than I thought. I have felt sick to my stomach most of the time for over a year.

    I think you should do whatever you can to change things now to make it more workable. I know you can't return the cabinet, etc., but you could sell it on eBay or craigslist. What about the shower? Can it be made smaller? If it is a unit, could it be a shower that is tiled in and just a stand up? Also, i have seen a new house that had the sink in the bedroom. It wasn't my favorite look, but it was in a niche outside the bathroom. Any chance of something like this?

    Let us know what happens at your meeting. Maybe there will be a fix that your builder will help you see.

  • 17 years ago

    Without an accurately drawn plan of the bathroom we don't have enough information to help you other than to suggest a smaller lavatory which is pretty obvious (they can be as shallow as 9 3/4") With a dimensioned drawing someone might be able to solve this problem for far less than the costs suggested, perhaps with a corner sink or a different shower design. When you need an imaginative design solution it is wise to not limit the input to contractors or relatives; we're here to help, but you need to show us the problem.