Software
Houzz Logo Print
nanj

Article on types of construction contracts

16 years ago

I stumbled across this document and thought it might be helpful to others who are learning about the ways contracts can be done for building a home.

TYPES OF CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS

by

Gary Michael Smith, Esq.

Whether undertaking a simple tenant improvement, developing

commercial land, or building your dream home, you will need to enter into a

contract to get the project done. Knowing the types and choices of contracts

before signing on the bottom line is the first best step towards protecting

yourself. In this issue we compare common forms of construction contracts.

These are by no means the complete universe of contracts, and most of the

below-described forms can be blended to create hybrids. So, regardless of

what form you use, remember that not all contracts fit the same scenario.

Whenever presented with any contract, it is best to have your lawyer review it

BEFORE you sign.

_________________________________________________

LUMP-SUM aka Fixed Price aka Complete Plans and Specifications aka

Stipulated Sum

This type of contract promises to build X project for Y dollars.

The Pros: For people on a budget, it is very predictable. Also, for consumers

who are able to fully articulate the project specifications they want, this can be

very equitable.

The Cons: This type of contract requires complete plans and specifications

setting forth directions in enough detail to enable a contractor to carry them

out. For consumers who are not able to fully articulate the desired project

specifications, they should expect that the contractor will attempt to shake out

as much profit as possible from their contract, meaning that if the consumer

did not provide a specification for a certain aspect of construction, the

contractor will most likely use the lowest suitable grade materials and

workmanship to save costs.

COST-PLUS

Under this arrangement the contractor is reimbursed for the actual cost of

labor and materials, plus charges a fee (typically an agreed-upon lump or

percentage of the total costs) for overhead and profit. This arrangement seldom

begins with a blank slate regarding specifications and costs. Rather, the

consumer and contractor will create a list of specifications and an estimated

budget to match to those specifications. Although the contractor under this

arrangement will have to keep copious records of its costs, most residential

consumers in a cost-plus arrangement suffer from kid-in-a-candystoreitis and

overspend. One way to prevent breaking the budget is to set a guaranteed

maximum price. However, even a maximum price will not alleviate problems.

The Pros: Where the consumer wants to have open reign to select materials and

workmanship as the project proceeds, this arrangement can be extremely

flexible and accommodating. Also, cost-plus typically requires the contractor

to obtain competitive bids from subcontractors, translating (in theory) to lower

construction cost.

The Cons: Because cost-plus contracts are usually used where the scope of

work is uncertain, the costs can quickly get way out of control. Even under a

maximum price, poor control in materials selection and on-the-fly design

modification can quickly consume budget, leaving line items on the project

starved for capital. This in turn requires either a diminution in quality in

certain aspects of the project and /or total elimination of aspects of the project

and /or the need for an additive change order to increase project funding. As

one might imagine, the cost-plus contract tends to cause construction lenders

fits. However, it is used frequently to great success.

DESIGN AND BUILD aka Design Build aka Turnkey

In a design-and-build contract, the consumer contracts with a single party that

both designs and builds the project. Commonly this other party is either a

joint venture between an architect and builder, or a lone builder that also

wears the hat of design professional.

The Pros: possible substantial cash and time savings by using one party;

predictable cost; and better execution of the project due to clearer

understanding of the creative vision by the builder. Also, in the event of

problems, the consumer may look to a single source for the responsibility for

the finished product. In other words, whenever a problem arises in

construction, the consumer will not be stonewalled by a separate builder and

design professional each blaming the other for whatever error occurs.

The Cons: the documents for the solicitation of bids under design-and-build

require a lot of up front details furnished by the consumer including a program

setting forth the project scope and the size, type, and desired design character

of the building and site; project specifications covering type and quality of

materials and workmanship.

TIME AND MATERIALS

This is a rare contract and is typically only seen in maintenance arrangements

and certain public works contracts. Under time and materials, the contractor

charges an hourly or job rate plus the pass-through expense of its

consumables.

The Pros: You only pay when your contractor works.

The Cons: Your contractor will tend to work very slowly.

_________________________________________________

Other types of contracts include Construction Management; Project

Management; Single versus Multiple Prime Contractor; Unit Price; Fast Track;

Owner-Architect; Owner-Contractor; etc. Also, of these most terms are

negotiable from scope to price to timelines.

Locally, the predominant "canned" contract forms are from either the American

Institute of Architects (AIA) or the Associated General Contractors (AGC). Both

organizations copyright their forms (so dont steal them) and both have a fairly

well-written and comprehensive portfolio from which to choose. Even so, there

is no such thing as one-size-fits-all. So, before spending six to seven figures on

your next project, spend a few hours with your lawyer to see whether your

contract is what you think it is.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Gary Michael Smith, Esq. is a published author, judge

pro tempore, and a principal of Smith & Craven, P.L.L.C., a law firm whose

primary practice focus is businesses and the construction industry. Smith &

Craven, P.L.L.C. is based in the Scottsdale Airpark. To contact Gary Michael

Smith, call 480-222-2225, or visit www.smithcraven.com.

ô This article is for general information only and not to be construed as legal

advice or the basis for formation of an attorney-client relationship between the

reader and the author.

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for posting this explanation of different types of contracts.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thanks for this explanation..I want to share an explanation for Types of Contracts

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Most lenders expect or demand, as a condition of their construction loan, a fixed price contract. Lenders often review the qualifications, experience and financial strength of the contractor, to assure their ability to perform and complete the project so they can extract themselves from the construction loan and convert it into a permanent loan.

    Our fixed price contract usually contains some allowances, making it a "hybrid."

    High end projects are often done "cost plus" when the owner is writing checks without a lender.

    nanj thanked Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor
  • 7 years ago

    The inclusion of Allowances in a Stipulated Sum contract is like a small Cost Plus contract within the contract and therefore requires special terms but that rarely happens and can be the cause of unnecessary difficulties. I add a section for allowances and list the amounts so the work can be bid competitively.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Agreed, but most competitive bid requests do not define their allowances enough, so sometimes the low bidder is often higher than represented. I would expect you have a vetted group of contractors to bid work somewhat consistently.

    Examples include "light fixtures" whether they include recessed housings & trim, under cabinet fixtures, garage ceiling fixtures, all of which can swing the number $5-10K. Cabinets? Install, finish, delivery, etc. Tile... I used to give clients a "per foot" number but it was too easy to conveniently misunderstand, so I use totals now.

    An allowance should be the dollar representation of an understood specification.

    I try to limit it to materials, avoiding unvetted trade contractors.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    This, and similar articles, should be required reading for every consumer considering a construction process...before the the construction process!

  • 7 years ago

    and, take any contract to a real estate attorney before signing. don't be afraid to ask questions. this is likeley one of the biggest purchases of your life...

  • 7 years ago

    Definitely Allowances should only be for materials. I never provide an allowance for lighhting; I document what I think is appropriate and deal with changes later. Cabinets are another matter.