Software
Houzz Logo Print
bayareafrancy

Oh help! Will I EVER get a hood???

16 years ago

Hi all,

I need hood help, specifically concerning the price difference between a Modern Aire hood, and a custom wood hood.

I have been needing a hood for my vintage kitchen for several years now. YEARS!! (I have posts here regarding hoods going back to at least 2008.) I desperately want the popular vintage style Modern Aire PS26, but the cost is just so over-the-top for us. The hood would cost as much as our teeny bit of (cheapo) custom cabinetry and it feels a bit weird to put such an incredibly high end hood in such a modest, old, [cheap] kitchen.

And yet, this is the only style that looks right. (btw: do NOT want the similarly styled vent a hood. Want baffles for sure.)

Here are a few shots of the kitchen, to give you a feel for the size and atmosphere/style. (Note: we are still "in progress," adding cabinetry to the stove wall, tile, painting existing cabinetry, etc. These are just messy shots from a typical day.):

(from the hall doorway, stove peeking out at right side):

from dining room doorway:

TINY! (But I love it!!)

Here is the old stove (also feels weird to put up a hood that costs 3 times as much as the stove!):

Here is my dream hood, from klb's gorgeous kitchen (hope she doesn't mind my posting!). My hood would be much bigger though: 42" wide, 27" deep, and probably 30" tall (no cabinetry above). Her kitchen is as tiny as mine, but it is ALL so sparkling NEW that the hood is just perfect! (Most of my cabinets are 80 years old, cock-eyed from the settling house, dented, etc. But freshly painted!)

{{gwi:1427515}}

Here is the kind of wood hood I have in mind (from decodilly's beautiful kitchen--again--hope she doesn't mind my posting it):

I'm thinking this Modern Aire hood could cost over 3000 dollars. That is unspeakably huge for us. We spent half that on cabinetry (tho we still need more cabinetry so that cost will go up). And yet, I have been agonizing over every detail of this kitchen since 2006. Yep! Working on it since 2006! Gawd I need to be done, and I can't be done without a hood!! But what kind of hood does my kitchen "deserve?"

Sooooooo, I'm wondering if the wood hood (with a high quality interior--I fry a lot!)) could cost less than the Modern Aire. Of course, quality can really vary. My custom cabinets were (sadly) very cheaply done. Yeah--it was nice to pay so little. But the quality is just awful.

The main problem with the wood hood is that my cabinetry and walls are all vintage yellow. If I do a wood hood, the kitchen will really be over-the-top yellow-rific. I think the white hood would look MUCH better (but I think a wood hood would HAVE to be yellow, like the rest of the wood in the kitchen).

TheHusband firmly feels that a 3500 hood only belongs over a 3500 dollar range in an all-over expensive kitchen. Not over a, say, 12,000 kitchen (maybe our total when all is said and done). He also said that about the farm sink, but I won that battle. And about the soapstone. But I won that too. I think the sink and the counter look fabulous. But the fancy, schmancy, high end hood??

Oh, HELP!!!

Francy

Comments (11)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Francy,

    It's great to see you around these parts again! And, I must say -- your kitchen is looking great as well! You have really come a long way since the last time you were regularly posting. Very nice!

    As for your hood choice, I'm not so sure how much of a help I can be to you on that one. Probably because I'm an owner of a Modernaire PS26 and very much biased in favor it. However, I hear you on price. Even though I got a great quote by dealing with MA directly, it was still a pretty penny when all was said and done.

    Have you checked out Independent hoods at all? I'm noticing one of their line, the Copper Bonanza, that looks very similar to the PS26 without bands. Another plus is that it has baffle filters and is available in a 42" size. (It doesn't look as if 27" depth is available as a stock item.) My thinking is that, as a copper hood, it could be just the right thing to help pull together your yellow cabs, white appliances, wood floors and soapstone c-tops. OTOH, it could flop miserably. Sorry, I also can't tell you a thing about cost.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Independent's Copper Bonanza Hood

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey Marthavila!

    I've missed you! I wondered if you ever got your Modern Aire. I think it was about 2 years ago that I asked you to simply make the choice for me, and I'd do whatever you told me to do.

    I'm going to email you (using address I already have, if that is still current).

    :-)

    francy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I was SO wordy in my original post (I am always very wordy)!

    So to clarify what my actual question is:

    Although the Modern Aire is style-wise and excellent choice for my kitchen, does it seem like it is simply too--I don't know--NICE? for my humble little 12,000 kitchen??

    (We CAN get it if we really want it, but will it create aesthetic dissonance?)

    thanks!

    francy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Francy,

    I have almost the same exact stove as you, and have been Jonesing for that PS 26 hood for almost 2 years! I love, love, love it and don't think it would be too much from an aesthetic point of view. It would be lovely. If you can find something else that works and costs less, boy I'd love to know what it is.

    What's stopping me is the price. It would be the most expensive appliance in my house - LOL! Not to mention the install would be almost as much as the hood itself.

    I love your kitchen - it has such charm. I hope you find a solution soon and please, please share when you do.

    Cathi

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Cathi: come to think of it, I don't think there is a single item in my house whose individual cost would be as much as that dang hood (not counting the new furnace).

    Ok...all the wooden windows we had rebuilt. All of them together. Not one. All.

    Installation costs??????? Oh carp! I completely forgot about that part. Will it really be as much as the hood?

    francy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I got your email and responded to you offline, Francy. As to installation cost? I don't remember the specific cost of installing the hood as it was bundled in with other construction items. However, in no way was it near the cost of the hood itself!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a modernaire ps26 similar to the one pictured. Mine is red to go with my red Bluestar. I can't say enough good things about Modernaire. They wanted to know what range it was going over so they could get an exact color match. They called Bluestar to find out where they bought their paint, and ordered their paint from the same place as Bluestar, and actually, it turns out it was from the same batch of paint as the one used to paint my range. Superb company to deal with in every way.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yeah, furnace and windows = $$$$.

    As for install, I suppose it would depend how complicated it is. Location relative to ducting, electrical, outside, make up air, etc, etc. My range is currently on an inside wall, we have no outside venting or electrical anything in that area. Big project. As we are unsure if it will stay in that location if/when we remodel (keeps getting put off) I don't want to spend the money now only to have to repay for install if we change the kitchen layout.

    Modernaire was great to deal with and I thought very reasonable cost wise for a custom made hood that has the goods. Just not in the budget for me right now (nor apparently in the immediate future). Guess I misspoke about the install costs, but IIRC preliminary estimate was around 1,500 or so (w/o a formal estimate which would require putting holes in the wall and ceiling).

    Still hoping you get your hood soon, though.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Bayareafrancy: this reply has nothing to do with your request about hoods. I just wanted to say that your range totally rules.

    You know, insofar as a kitchen appliance can indeed "rule."

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you segesta. :-)

    But does she deserve a luxury hood? Do the 80 year olds cabs deserve a luxury hood?

    francy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes she deserves a luxury hood (one cool range BTW) and so do the 80 year old cabs, which look very nice to.

    Fancy it is obvious you love the hood and so nothing else is going to suit. If you get a hood that will just 'do' you will always wonder what if. YOU also deserve the hood, every time you look at it it will give you pleasure, make you happy. Get it and enjoy.