Software
Houzz Logo Print
beaglesdoitbetter1

well problem- gpm question- answers needed asap please

15 years ago

I am cross posting this to the kitchen and plumbing forum because we need an answer for our builder tomorrow morning so the well people can either leave or not.

We have dug down to 525 ft. and we are still only at 4 gallons per minute. Our builder is suggesting we stop. Everyone else that I have talked to says 4 GPM is not sufficient.

Anyone on here have a well that has such a low GPM or anyone have any info on why that will or will NOT be OK. We've already doubled our well allowance and our builder has no indication of if we will find more if we go further or how much further we would need to go. Our house is on top of a mountain.

If it makes any difference to anyone's answers, we have a 75 gallon hot water heater and a 50 gallon hot water heater, but we also have a big tub and multiple shower heads.

Thanks for the help again!

Comments (11)

  • 15 years ago

    How many bathrooms? How many people living in the house? Multiple laundry rooms? I know you have the doggie tub, but anything else special for plumbing? That information might help.

    I know our well is 5 GPM and with 2 bathrooms, 1 laundry, 1 kitchen sink and 5 people currently (maybe up to 7 if my wife gets her wish, I'm pulling for 6) we think that's good enough for us after talking with our GC and our well guy.

  • 15 years ago

    2 people living in the house right now, possibility of kids later. We'll have regular guests. We do have 2 laundry rooms, and we also have a large infinity tub and a shower with 4 shower heads. Two kitchen sinks, 2 dishwashers.

    Brickton, do you know how deep yours is and do you have any storage tanks or anything special to make sure the 5 GPM is enough or did your GC and well guy just think it would be fine?

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Beagles...Don't know if it will help, but we are also on a mountain and like you, we had to go waaaaay down to hit water. We were over 400 ft down when we finally hit water and it was only 4GPM. We were advised to continue drilling as 4GPM wasn't going to be enough. If I remember right we ended up about 650 ft down with 12GPM. 4 people will be living there & we have 3 bedrooms, 3.5 baths--1 with 3 shower heads + large infinity tub (which tub did you go with, by the way?), 1 laundry, 2 full size kitchen sinks & 2 dishwashers. A comment was made by the well drillers that even at 12GPM they wouldn't recommend putting in a sprinkler system (not that we were even thinking about it in the first place.)

    Can't say if you will get better GPM by going further down like we did. Have you talked with any of your neighbors to find out their well drilling experience on the mountain? How was the drilling site identified (i.e. are we even drilling in a good spot)? The water finding technique with the forked stick or even 2 metal hangers straightened into an 'L' shape really does work for finding water & locating ideal spots for wells. Did they do any type of testing to identify where to drill or did they just drill "over there somewhere in that stand of trees away from the septic field"? Who is paying the extra cost on the well since you're already at twice the allowance--you or the builder? What do the well drilling guys recommend at this point? An alternative is you can always go with this well for now and drill a new one if need be in the future.

    Hope some of this may have helped you make your decision. I'll keep my fingers crossed for you!

  • 15 years ago

    A well 6" diameter holds about 1 1/2 gallons of water per vertical foot. Subtract from 525 the static level of the water and subtract the distance from the bottom at which the pump will be placed for the usable depth of water. Multiply by 1.5. Let's say it is 445 feet x 1.5 for 667.5 gallons. That much is available without any additional inflow. and in the hour (assuming pumping at 10 gallons per minute, which requires a really good pump) that it takes to pump that out, 240 gallons more will inflow. The average household uses about 200 gallons per day. And 4 gallons per minute is 5,760 gallons per day. Yes, I think your supply is quite adequate.

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you everyone!

    mydreamhome our neighbors have 5 GPM and they drilled down only 320 ft. but we are higher up on the mountain. The neighbors across the neighborhood on the other side of the pond from us actually had to dynamite to get the well. I have no clue what was done to find the spot for the well. We also had 4 geothermal wells done too, and all the wells are in one spot on the side of the driveway. Our lot is very very hilly so there was a limited area where the wells actually could go. We are paying the extra cost of this because we just had a well allowance and between doubling the cost + putting in the geothermal wells, we've got a shameful amount of money invested in wells already and really do not want to spend any more! Our inclination is to just go w/ the 4 GPM and we have 800 gallons of storage + a 150 gallon water heater, a 75 gallon water heater and a 50 gallon geothermal water holding tank. If we have an issue w/ water, our builder said we can just drill down deeper later, although it will cost more.

    GreenDesign, someone else on the other forum said that too. I wonder if it differs from place to place. I can't imagine our builder would have done something wrong, he is wonderful and extremely well respected here, everyone we talk to from the bank to accountants to tradespeople to random strangers we meet comments on how well built his houses are.

    And to answer the tub question, we went w/ the MTI caribe. I loved the customizability of being able to pick exactly what features we wanted and I loved that it was cheaper than the kohler! Did you get the kohler sok or a different one, I'm not sure how many there are on the market?

    Thank you bus_driver, that was very helpful!

  • 15 years ago

    Just wanted to say that with 800 gallons of storage I think you will be just fine.

    We have a trickle water setup that delivers at 0.5 gpm and a 400 gallon storage tank and have never run out of water with conventional usage.

    We had a good test of the true capacity/capability of our relatively small 400 gallon cistern: For 3 weeks we had 6 adults staying with us and using the "facilities" on a constant basis (2 of the visitors regularly had 1/2 hour showers....also lots of dishwasher and washing machine usage).

    We did not run out of water though I really thought we would. The 0.5 gpm recharge concerned me so I am pretty sure with 4 gpm flow and 800 gallons of storage there is little to worry about.
    As long as you are not using your water for irrigation or some other protracted or intensive usage, I can't see ever running out of water.

  • 15 years ago

    "400 gallon storage tank"

    Ouch.

    Well bore storage is often the most cost effective method.

    By pacing the pump well below the natural fill level all the water above the pump is available as needed.

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, 400 gallons is very small and could cause pain if the trickle water delivery is interrupted. Clearly we do not have much standby capacity.

    We are not on a well (municpal water is trickled in) so well bore storage is irrelevant in my case, but I was just giving perspective on storage capacity plus recharge flow rate for typical usage.

    From that standpoint I think bdib is going to be okay.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks! This decision made me very nervous so it is good to get feedback that we may be OK with not getting more!

  • 15 years ago

    Beagles--glad to hear you came to a decision. That MTI tub you got is a nice one. To answer your question, we went with the Kohler Purist--it overflows pretty much just on the bottom half as it's slightly sloped toward that end. We got a spectacular deal on the one with all the bells and whistles! Hopefully, we will both be relaxing in our respective overflowing bath tubs soaking away all this stress we're currently experiencing while building our houses in the very near future!