Software
Houzz Logo Print
nanj

M_A: Is this correct window trim construction?

18 years ago

In a post on this forum in the last couple of weeks, MightyAnvil wrote:

"It's a beautiful house but I feel I should once again warn everyone about the use of "picture frame" trim below the window sills even though it is too late to do much about it.

A properly detailed window sill should extend over the siding and form a drip. Modern clad windows often omit this detail in order to make it easier to fabricate and ship their windows. That means it is necessary to add a "sub sill" below the window to form this drip feature.

When a flat trim board is installed below the window, water that runs over the sill will attempt to enter the cladding at the caulked joint. When this joint eventually fails (if it was caulked properly in the first place) water will be drawn into the wall system by capillary action.

The only way to avoid the problem without adding a sub sill is to bring the bottom of the sill flashing out between the first and second courses of shingles so only one course is exposed to potential water damage."

I found this photo from another post by MightyAnvil. Does this show the right way to detail a window sill?

Our neighborhood is about 5-6 years old, built by a respected local builder. As I look at the houses with picture-framed window trim, NONE seem to be done as MightyAnvil describes. From the street I could see the rot in a horizontal board under a southern-facing window on my neighbor's house!

Thanks,

Nan

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    You picked an unusual example of a drip sill. The photo is of an addition to a house designed in 1880 by William Ralph Emerson, first cousin of Ralph Waldo and well known as the architect of some of the finest Shingle Style homes in New England.

    The sill is a faithful reproduction of the original windows. It is about 3" thick and the drip is decorated with horizontal grooves similar to the jamb trim. Emerson also placed what we would call the trim against the framing instead of the sheathing and carried the shingles over it to a narrow band trim giving the window the appearance of popping out of a cloak of shingles, a highly desirable feature of the popular Shingle Style of the time.

  • 18 years ago

    Wow...what a neat detail. So would the trim have been stepped to provide the reveal after the walls sheathing was butted next to it?

    Does the copper head flashing cause any staining to the surrounding trim over time?

    Is that corner gutter redwood and attatched to a typical fascia? Are real wood gutters really as problematic as what you hear? What would the downspouts have been made of?

    Sorry for the off topic questions, just enjoy learning. Thanks MA

  • 18 years ago

    It's a fir gutter lined with copper. I don't expect the copper above the window to stain; it has been standard detailing around here for 200 years. It's difficult to know what you mean by "stepped" or "reveal".

  • 18 years ago

    I recently had a gentlemen tell me that copper would leave staining on exterior details if I was to use it. I have no personal experience with it and was curious.

    I was picturing in my mind that the windows trim maybe stepped where the sheathing would rest on it leaving the protruding grooved face detail. The windows trim would therefor be a full "wrap" inside of the rough framing.

    I wish our area had a more diverse architectual presence.

  • 18 years ago

    The "trim" boards of a wood window are an integral part of the frame instead of being added later. This restoration jamb detail shows a modern wood window. It is the same as the original but without, of course, the sash weight pockets.

    The original windows were built on site with "boxed" sash pockets that would require wide trim boards if the trim had lapped over the sheathing.

    The Shingle Style was a reaction against the highly decorated late Victorian "Stick Style" and therefore the trim was intentionally minimized to give the house the appearance of being wrapped in shingles rather than being built of many small decorative pieces.

  • 18 years ago

    The evolution of building design is so interesting - understanding why designs change as they have. Thank you for your insight!

    What I was trying to ask in my original post, and didn't do a very good job at it is, does anyone have a photo of the proper installation of a window trimmed in a picture-frame manner on a home with siding such as Hardi-Plank? I would like to verify with a builder that water is properly channeled and a picture is worth a thousand words!

  • 18 years ago

    What is the window type, manufacturer and model?

    Few sills are the same even from the same manufacturer.

    What is the trim size and material?

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you mightyanvil!