Software
Houzz Logo Print
julieh1926_gw

Island Hood Recommendations

17 years ago

We're starting our search for appliances, and know that we'll have a 36" electric cook top in our island. Can't do gas, unfortunately. I know we'll need to look at 42" hoods -- but don't have any idea what brands to look at, what features we'll want, etc. Can anyone help me mine this field??? Any suggestions and/or experiences you've had? Thanks!

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    I found vent hoods to be the most overwhelming part of our kitchen remodel.

    In addition to a cooktop, we also had a grill which put out a lot of smoke.

    A couple of questions, are you looking for a finished hood or will it be enclosed in a wood cabinet?

    What size of ducts do you have? Can you use an external blower in the attic, roof, or side of the house or do you need a internal blower.

    I think the best place to start is to go to a showroom and compare Vent A Hood to a traditional "baffle" system. Modern Air has a good reputation and builds beautiful hoods, but it is hard to see them in real life unless.

    Vent A Hood brings out strong feelings in people. On an island, they have the advantage of being wider than most other brands.

  • 17 years ago

    julieh, I'm looking at vent hoods as well. I heard good things on gardenweb about the seller on ebay called "steamshowersellers". I looked at some of that person's hoods and am leaning toward them. I've also been looking on overstock.com.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the responses. We will be using an external blower going out through the roof. This will be all new (don't have one currently) so I would imagine duct size will be whatever we need it to be, right?

    As for styling, originally we were going to go with a wood finsihed hood, but I think we're leaning toward stainless steel now. So, the look will be important. We'd lean toward clean,simple lines with nothing ornate, etc. Our kitchen will be transitional in style, using cherry cabs with a simple recessed door.

  • 17 years ago

    If you can do an external blower, you have a lot of options.

    Confirm your max duct size before shopping. I ran into trouble with this during my remodel. I bought a Vent a Hood pro model which required a 12" duct, but when we opened the ceiling, there were pipes crossing the space and I could only do 9", max.

    Generally, most 1200 cfm vents want 10".

    Anyway, on an island, you want a high CFM so your fan/blower and duct layout is important to maximize efficiency.

    You also want to make sure you have adequate width, which is sometimes an issue with some brands.

    I think Modern Aire makes beautiful hoods. I know (as of last week) that the 48" liner (requires a cabinet) with an internal blower was going to cost about $2500 shipped from CA to OK. Production time is about 10 days.

    Their stainless hoods are very cool. I think they have the best variety of stocked hoods on the market. Clean lines.

  • 17 years ago

    An air curtain is the term used to describe how air currents get sculpted in commercial establishments to direct air flow in certain ways. It's invisible. This is how tall open-face freezer displays in supermarkets keep their cold air. You pick your yogurt off an open shelf. It's how a store keeps its doors open on a hot day while keeping its cooled air right at the door and not sliding outside. Without an air curtain, cooled air slides out at ground level and warm air slides in at top level. Some singers have an air curtain on stage. This gives them the right kind of air for their vocal chords. There are many other applications. Air is forced upwards from slots below, while the same quantity is sucked into slots above. Very little escapes the closed loop.

    The same principle could one day be used to make island cooktop vents more effective at sucking the air from an (invisible) air cone around the cooktop and not from all the eye-level air nearest the vents. It would require blowing air upwards from slots around the cooktop, This new air coming into the room directed upwards is a source, and it coordinates with an"air sink" overhead where the hood's grease filter is. The air current thus created would be effective at separating greasy smelly cooking air from the open air of the room surrounding the current. This would isolate an island cooktop's air from the rest of the air. This would answer the OP's question. The bigger the CFM flowing out of the room, the greater the need for Make Up Air (MUA) which I'm suggesting should be directed in such manner as to make a current that aids evacuation of cooking air.

  • 17 years ago

    An air curtain is probably a good idea, but would require some differences from the food store example to work with the upwelling and expanding effluent flow from a cooktop. There are published studies of various effects on keeping the flow heading into the hood, and any turbulence around the flow will usually disrupt it. Hence, the air curtain would have to be somewhat spaced away from the cooktop, I imagine. This would also force the hood to be larger in capture area.

    Some commercial ventilation setups do put the make-up air into the room below the cooktop, generally aimed downwards at the back of the unit. Hood testing is usually done with a large bank of make-up air diffusers at a distance from the cooktop-hood setup being analyzed. Then there is minimal turbulence around the cooking zone. In real life, air currents and air disturbances from the non-stationary cook disrupt any idealization of the flow.

    kas