Software
Houzz Logo Print
stupidgringo

Building and Deed Restrictions

16 years ago

My wife and I are under contract on a riverfront lot where we plan to build a vacation home. It's a corner lot in an old neighborhood with no HOA. The financing for our land and construction has been approved, and we're very close to hiring a builder.

Today, the title company issued their title commitment, which included a set of deed restrictions that had not been previously disclosed, and had apparently been unknown to the seller or his agent. One of the restrictions has been interpreted by the title company to require a 30' setback on each street, and since the lot is only 55' wide would make the lot unusable for a home.

The restriction states:

"No improvement shall be constructed on said property within easement lines or nearer than 30 feet to the front property line, nor nearer than 10 feet to side property lines, except that in the case of corner lots no improvements shall be constructed within 10 feet of side property lines adjacent to streets 30 ft. setback."

I don't know exactly what that means. The title company believes that in means that there is a 30' setback on each side of the lot that is bordered by a street. They have put an exception from coverage (they will not cover losses resulting from...) in their title commitment that states:

"30 foot front setback line; a 10 foot side building setback line, except corner lots on streets which shall have 30 foot building setback lines, as recited in Volume 124, Page 387-388, Comal County, Texas Deed Records."

Like I said above, I don't know what the restriction means, and I'm not sure it means what they think it means.

The selling agent, who lives in the neighborhood, has told our agent that 75% of the homes in the neighborhood violate the deed restrictions and so no one could ever complain or sue. She also believes, I think incorrectly, that the restrictions have expired. The restrictions state that they automatically renew every 10 years, unless amended or canceled in writing by a majority of homeowners and filed with the county. This has not happened. She has also told my agent that since no one follows the restrictions and they have never been enforced, then they can no longer be enforced.

The title company told me that they have interpreted the deed restriction correctly, but they also told me that they think it's expired. They could not tell me why it's included as an exception if it's expired.

The lot is being surveyed. The fieldwork is done, and the survey is supposed to be done Monday. The surveyor told my agent that he believes there is NO setback.

I left a message for an attorney late today, but I don't expect to hear from him until Monday.

I don't expect anyone on this board to be able to solve this problem, but I hope you can help me figure out what form a solution might take.

What value does the survey have? If it is signed and sealed with no setbacks, does that somehow protect me?

Is there anything to the argument that deed restrictions that are not followed or enforced are no longer enforceable?

What kind of documentation or assurances should I require to be satisfied that I can build without future potential repercussions?

Lastly, what do you think that deed restriction means?

These are all questions that Ill ask the attorney I have called. In the mean time, I appreciate any advice you all might have.

Comments (26)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This problem is the fault of the seller so the seller owes you an amendment modifying the restrictions signed by a majority of homeowners before transfer of owner ship occurs and work proceeds.

    Why would work be proceeding when you don't have title to the property?

    The surveyor only verifies the boundaries and easements on paper and and sets markers on the property. You shouldn't be doing work without that.

    In the end you need to find a way to get title insurance without caveats or exclusions.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Be sure to get an attorney that is experienced in real estate matters. Under the laws of some states, deed restrictions do expire after a specified period of time regardless of what the restrictions say. Since the title company thinks they are expired, your state probably has such a law. However, the title company does not want to foot the bill for a law suit to verify that fact, so it included the exclusion for the restrictions and it shifting the burden to you to determine for yourself whether they have, in fact, expired. You need to get a lawyer to give you a written opinion that the restrictions have expired and then the lawyer, not the title company, would be liable if he/she gave you that opinion, you relied upon it, and it turned out to be wrong. Or you can find another piece of land.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have seen title companies include non applicable exclusions on the policies they write. We have an spring access easement exclusion on our property that pertains to a spring that is actually on someone else's property. Both properties are part of a subdivision of a much larger piece of property.

    The title company can't tell where the spring is, so they left the language intact. It has no impact on us, so it isn't a problem. Your case may be similar if the exclusions only apply if the restriction is actually enforceable. You will need a real estate attorney to determine that for you.

    If your regular attorney is not a real estate attorney, go attorney shopping. You don't want a generalist handling real estate matters.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "The title company told me that they have interpreted the deed restriction correctly, but they also told me that they think it's expired. They could not tell me why it's included as an exception if it's expired."

    Even invalid restrictions often travel with the deed.

    In some places it is a long and expensive process to get them removed, so why bother?
    Invalid is invalid.

    One of my titles included a restriction on selling to "Negroes."

    It propagates with the title, but the title insurance company noted it "cannot work a forfeit" since such restrictions were long ago declared invalid.

    The insurance company probably does not want to be responsible for ensuring the restriction is invalid.

    Talk with your RE attorney.
    They should be able to conform if the restriction is invalid (including expired) and guide you.

    Even if the restriction is invalid, an adjacent landowner may still be able to sue for enforcement.

    They may not prevail, but it costs money to fight a civil case, and getting it paid by the loser is not a sure thing.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for your replies. I want to clarify, no work has begun. We are scheduled to close on the lot and construction loan on Jan. 5. We had to order a new survey and we should receive it on Monday.

    I'm interested in knowing more about the route suggested by Carolyn53562. If an attorney issues an opinion that the restriction is invalid or that it does not require a 30' setback, how am I protected? I could still be sued. What if a judge later disagrees with his opinion?

    I still can't figure out what, short of a vote to remove the restriction, would make me comfortable closing on the lot.

    What do you all think about my case for breaking the contract and keeping my earnest money? Like I said above the seller's disclosure stated that there were no deed restrictions, but now it turns out that there are. I would rather solve this, but if I can't, does that give me grounds to break the contract?

    I will obviously ask my attorney about these issues on Monday, but I do appreciate your information now.

    I

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The restrictions were not disclosed. I see no reason you could not bow out with your earnest money in your pocket.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    cross posting from building:

    "unless amended by a majority of homeowners on file with the county."

    What homeowners? Those are your angels.

    Personally, I think the deed restriction was written that way (badly, though) to clarify that any corner lot would be considered to have only one "front" street side subject to the 30-foot setback and that another boundary on the adjacent (corner) street would be considered a side, subject only to the 10-foot setback.

    I am surprised the title company is interpreting it in exactly the opposite way. It seems clear to me that the intent is to only impose a 10-foot setback on the adjacent street side. I think your attorney will agree.

    Regardless, this is something you might be able to take to the specific homeowners cited and get them to amend the rule to be more clear and require 30-foot setback on only one street side of a corner lot.

    If these deed restrictions are open to amendment by a group, it also stands to reason that there is a group, whether or not the current members are aware of it. I suspect that there are more documents on file with the county that specify how and when this group can amend or withdraw the restrictions.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hadley, thanks for your response. I appreciate your interpretation of the restriction.

    The homeowners referenced are the owners in the subdivision. Unfortunately, they are not organized, and apparently have not been in many years. Many, maybe more than half, of the homes are vacation homes and vacation rentals. I will encourage the seller to pursue an amendment to clarify the restriction.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I do think you could cancel the contract.

    I agree with the title company on the meaning of the language. I don't know where you are, but around here it is typical for all street frontages to be considered the same as the front for set back purposes. If I was your attorney, I would seek guidance on the meaning of the language by looking at how the language was written into the other deeds or if the town has what the language was supposed to be (this could be in records from when the subdivision was approved). It seems there is a comma or word missing.

    Even if the 10' setback is used on the side you could only build a 35' wide house. Is that adequate?

    Even if the seller can get the other owners to agree to amend the set backs, I don't see that happening by 1/5. Unless there is something special about this lot, I would find another that doesn't have this baggage.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Congratulations on the lot, and on your building plans. I can't be very helpful here, other than to agree with another poster suggesting to find another lot if this one is not special/ unique.

    From the moment we purchased our lot in Jan. of 2008, we have been tied up with a "deed restriction" based lawsuit that is ridiculous (has nothing to do with us, but it affects our ability to build on our property). Even though the suing party has neglected to enforce their restrictions in countless previous instances, in this case, they are choosing to sue. I am very interested in your question, "Is there anything to the argument that deed restrictions that are not followed or enforced are no longer enforceable?"

    I am also interested in the suggestion that in some states the deed restrictions expire. How does one learn more about each individual states' laws regarding deed restrictions?
    Best of luck with your situation. Find a good real estate attorney and make sure you protect yourself (in writing). A promise that it will be fine, "everybody is doing it" is not a good enough argument in the event somebody decides to sue you for deed restriction violations. Keep us posted and good luck!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "How does one learn more about each individual states' laws regarding deed restrictions?"

    Google. A lot of states have their laws posted on line. If so, Google will find them. Specialist law firms often have write ups on the area(s) they specialize in. Google will find these, too.

    When the law is not clear cut to you, you can post to one of the legal forums and usually get an answer, although it may just be, "You need an attorney."

    Or you can consult a RE attorney, which is the best route for anything more serious than a mere curiosity.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "One of the restrictions has been interpreted by the title company to require a 30' setback on each street, and since the lot is only 55' wide would make the lot unusable for a home."

    Probably why it is for sale and not built on.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Creek side, Thanks very much for your link. I am going to scour it for a situation similiar to mine, though frankly, it is so absurd that I can't imagine it could have happened before. The neighborhood next to mine is asking for the sewer connection (municipal) to my neighborhoods 18 lots to be removed. While everybody says this will never happen (there are 8 homes built, utilizing this sewer), while we wait for a judge to decide, we cannot build unless we have an alternate to sewer (or we risk having our dream home condemned if a judge decided to take it away). And, of course, my lot doesn't "perc" in any form. Even crazy engineered systems don't seem to be suitable. So.... I have to wait for a January 2010 court date. Then, wait out any appeals, so it could potentially drag on for quite some time. Truthfully, this is a personal battle between our developer and the neighboring developer, but it is putting 18 innocent families at risk. So, any little thing I can find that might help our cause is greatly appreciated!

    Sorry to hijack OP, but I know when people are asking you to take a risk, they tell you, "oh, that will never happen" (in my case removing the sewer), but nobody can guarantee it, so unless you have something ironclad (and the burden transfers from you to this person guaranteeing you are OK), I would not move forward with your lot purchase, assuming you can get it all worked out.
    Thanks again for the input for my situation creek side

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ronellis-
    Two things:
    The municipality I lived in for many years had a requirement that front and back yards have 30' setbacks, and that the sideyards have 10' setbacks. However there was a footnote that said something like: for corner lots, the two yards that do not border streets are defined as side yards. I had a corner lot, and that provision meant that I could have the size house I wanted...it just wasn't in the middle of the lot. This is a fairly common provision, and you might want to check on that possibility.

    The other thing is that you need to confirm where the setback is measured from. In my area, the setback of 30' was measured starting at the centerline of the road, not the property line.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I talked to the attorney this morning. His initial reaction is that the restriction is valid and makes the lot unbuildable. He also believes we have an out from our contract. He's reviewing our contract an the deed restrictions, and will advise us tomorrow.

    My RE agent told me tonight that the survey will be finished tomorrow, and that it will show a setback of only 10' on each side. I'll also send that to my attorney, but I'm not sure it's the silver bullet my RE agent thinks it is.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The surveyor's interpretation is irrelevant. Never take advice from a real estate agent; all they want to do is close the deal.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So, we got the survey today, and the surveyor indicated 10-foot setbacks on both sides of the lot. As a result, the title company has changed the title commitment. The exception now states that the side setbacks are 10 feet and references the survey.

    My lawyer will look at the new title commitment tomorrow and give me the pros and cons of proceeding. I've also asked my banker to weigh in on it, since she had previously told me she would be "uncomfortable" lending if we were violating the deed restrictions.

    Any thoughts on this development?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "10-foot setbacks on both sides of the lot." How many "edges" does the property have? If four, you have 10' setbacks on two sides, 30' on the front, and what is the fourth "edge" considered? A front, a side, or something else?

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's a corner lot.

    I would be cautious about making important legal decisions based on a surveyor's interpretation of legal documents.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The adjacent lots (at least) can object to the changes.

    Even nearby landowners may have some 'standing' to object to the change in interpretation the surveyor is trying to sneak through.

    Changes like these often require public advertisement of the change, possibly public hearings, and often zoning board permission.

    The onbly deed restrictions I have seen 'expire' are ones involving HOAs.
    If the HOA is defunct its powers go away.
    Other restrictions are removed by law (no sales to certain groups like blacks or Jews).
    Local government often has the power to alter public right of way setbacks requirements, but often holds hearings and solicits comments on changes.

    If the lot was originally purchased to preserve a view, the buyer may not have cared if the lot was not buildable due to the restrictions (and may have actually supported them0.

    They could then sell the lot and still maintain their view.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    macv - I understand it is a corner lot. That means it has two street sides and two non-street sides. If the front has a 30' set-back and the survey indicated 10-foot setbacks on BOTH sides, isn't there still a question as to what the set-back is on the remaining side? And is there something that clearly states which side has to be the front? Sorry, I guess I am not understanding something.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The lot is approximately 55' x 250'. The front, which is 55' and borders a street has a 30' setback, the "right" side (250') which borders a neighbor has 10' setback, and the "left" side (also 250') bordering another street has either 10' or 30' setback. The fourth or back side is the Guadalupe River. There is no defined setback from the river.

    The setback in question is on the "left" side.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "The lot is approximately 55' x 250'. The front, which is 55' and borders a street has a 30' setback, the "right" side (250') which borders a neighbor has 10' setback, and the "left" side (also 250') bordering another street has either 10' or 30' setback. The fourth or back side is the Guadalupe River. There is no defined setback from the river."

    Not unbuildable at all with those dimensions.
    You just need a design that is shallow (the 55 foot direction) and long (the 250 foot direction).

    There is an infill house near one of my older homes that is built shallow and wide for the same reason.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The fourth or back side is the Guadalupe River. There is no defined setback from the river.

    Governments, from towns to the feds, tend to restrict how close you can build to a river. I would check to see if any statutory restrictions come into play.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My guess would be that the rear setback would correspond to the FEMA flood plain. But YMMV

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "There is no defined setback from the river."

    Are you sure? I assume that's Texas, have you checked with the state equivalent of the EPA? The town or county may also have restrictions. I would be shocked if you are able to build 10 feet from a water resource.

    When we built we were required to stay 75' from the pond, the restriction is now 100'. The town adjacent to us has a 200' setback requirement. My father lives in another state and just added on to his garage and was required to stay 75' from a tiny brook that only runs seasonally.